Plural voting
≈ 5 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Plural voting is the electoral rule that a voter might cast multiple ballots in an election. This can happen if a voter is allowed to cast a single vote in multiple districts or is allowed to cast multiple votes in one district or both. Because plural voting gives a voter more votes than another, it creates voting inequality and breaks the one man, one vote rule. Political philosopher John Stuart Mill endorsed the unfairness in the cause of competence and participation. Fiction writer Nevil Shute endorsed unequal plural voting in his 1953 time-travel book In the Wet. He predicted that varying the number of votes applicable based on personal qualifications and achievements would improve the quality of elected representatives. Mark Twain presented the idea of plural voting based on merit in his short story "The Curious Republic of Gondour". Plural voting is a form of weighted voting.
Plural voting is the electoral rule that a voter might cast multiple ballots in an election. This can happen if a voter is allowed to cast a single vote in multiple districts or is allowed to cast multiple votes in one district or both. Because plural voting gives a voter more votes than another, it creates voting inequality and breaks the one man, one vote rule. Political philosopher John Stuart Mill endorsed the unfairness in the cause of competence and participation. Fiction writer Nevil Shute endorsed unequal plural voting in his 1953 time-travel book In the Wet. He predicted that varying the number of votes applicable based on personal qualifications and achievements would improve the quality of elected representatives. Mark Twain presented the idea of plural voting based on merit in his short story "The Curious Republic of Gondour". Plural voting is a form of weighted voting.
Historical and modern-day use
Belgium
In Belgium, voting was restricted to the wealthy tax brackets from independence in 1830 until 1848, when it was expanded to include a somewhat larger number of voters. The restriction on voting was abolished in 1893 after the first general strike in Europe and replaced wide adult male franchise but with plural voting for some males. They were allowed one or two additional votes, if they were head of a family or had a certain amount of education or money. This was applied for elections from 1894 to 1919 as a way to limit the impact of universal suffrage. Every male citizen over 25 got one vote for legislative elections, but some electors got up to two supplementary votes according to some criteria: holder of a school diploma; family head over 30, paying a poll tax of at least five francs; holder of a savings account of at least 2,000 francs, or beneficiary of a life annuity of at least 100 francs. The system was unpopular. Two more general strikes - in 1902 and in 1913 - were conducted to demand the abolition of plural voting. For municipal elections, a fourth vote was granted to family heads who paid a fixed level of electoral tax, or whose cadastral income was at least of 150 francs.
United Kingdom
In the United Kingdom, up to 1948, people affiliated with a university were allowed a vote in both a university constituency and their home constituency. Also property owners could vote in the constituencies where their property lay and also the constituency in which they lived, if they were different. This was seen as unfair and the Chartists spoke out against plural voting as early as 1842. However it was only finally abolished in Parliamentary elections in 1948. In 1892 George Shaw-Lefevre MP stated: After 1910, the Liberal government was intent on passing a Plural Voting Bill that sought to prevent electors who appeared on the electoral register more than once from voting more than once. Liberal and Unionist headquarters were in agreement that 29 seats were won by Unionists in December 1910 because of plural voting. The bill passed third reading, but before it could pass into law, World War I started and the bill was shelved. Plural voting was finally abolished for parliamentary elections by the Representation of the People Act 1948, which first applied in the 1950 general election. Plural voting was used in local government elections for many years. It was abolished in Great Britain, outside the City of London, by the Representation of the People Act 1969. Plural voting is still used in elections in the City of London, with a City business having a number of votes based on its number of employees.
Contemporary theory
Philosopher Thomas Mulligan has proposed a system of plural voting which uses a mathematical algorithm to determine voters' ability and then gives higher-ability voters more votes.
See also
University constituency One man, one vote Suffrage Prussian three-class franchise Functional constituency
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372135235 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.