presuppositional apologetics

school of Christian apologetics that believes Christianity is the only basis for rational thought, presupposes that the Bible is divine revelation, and attempts to expose flaws in other worldviews

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Q4118925Snapshot

≈ 7 min read

Names in other languages

  • Englishpresuppositional apologetics
  • Nederlandspresuppositionisme
  • العربيةدفاعيات افتراضية
  • 한국어전제주의 변증
  • 中文预设辨惑论
  • 简体中文预设辨惑论
  • 繁體中文預設辨惑論
  • 日本語前提主義

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Presuppositional apologetics, shortened to presuppositionalism, is an epistemological school of Christian apologetics that examines the presuppositions at the basis of various worldviews, and invites comparison and contrast between the results of those presuppositions. It claims that apart from presuppositions, one could not make sense of any human experience, and that there can be no set of neutral assumptions from which a Christian can reason with a non-Christian.

Presuppositionalists claim that Christians cannot consistently declare their belief in the necessary existence of the God of the Bible and simultaneously argue on the basis of a different set of assumptions that God may not exist and Biblical revelation may not be true. Two schools of presuppositionalism exist, based on the different teachings of Cornelius Van Til (1895-1987) and of Gordon Haddon Clark (1902-1985).

Presuppositionalism contrasts with classical apologetics and with evidential apologetics. Presuppositionalists compare their presupposition against other ultimate standards such as reason, empirical experience, and subjective feeling, claiming presupposition in this context is:

Comparison with other schools of apologetics

Presuppositionalists contrast their approach with the other schools of Christian apologetics by describing the others as assuming that the world is intelligible apart from belief in the existence of God. Then they argue on purportedly neutral grounds to support trusting the Christian scriptures and the existence of God.

Specifically, presuppositionalists describe Thomistic (also "traditional" or "classical") apologetics as concentrating on the first aspect of apologetics with its logical proofs for the existence of God. Thus assuming common ground with the non-Christian and using a piece-by-piece methodology.

In this scheme, the common foundation of neutral brute facts leads to a generic concept of deity, then to the various characteristics of the Christian God as revealed in Scripture, and so forth. Piece-by-piece, Christian theology is built up from a neutral common ground.

Presuppositionalists assert that many of the classical arguments are logically fallacious, or do not prove enough, when used as arguments to prove the existence or character of God. They criticize both the assumption of neutrality and the "block house" or "piecemeal" method for failing to start at the level of the controlling beliefs of worldviews and implicitly allowing non-Christian assumptions from the start, thereby trying to build a Christian "house" on a non-Christian "foundation".

Evidentialists demur from this assessment, claiming that presuppositionalism amounts to fideism because it rejects the idea of shared points of reference between the Christian and non-Christian from which they may reason in common. The conclusion of evidential apologetics is that the Bible's historical accounts and other truth-claims are more probably true than false, thus the whole of scriptural revelation may be rationally accepted, and where we can't approach absolute certainty we must accept the explanations most likely to be true.

The goal of presuppositional apologetics, on the other hand, is to argue that the assumptions and actions of non-Christians require them to believe certain things about God, man, and the world which they claim not to believe. This type of argument is technically called a reductio ad absurdum in that it attempts to reduce the opposition to holding an absurd, i.e., self-contradictory position; in this case, both believing in facts of Christian revelation (in practice) and denying them (in word).

So, in essence, evidential apologetics attempts to build upon a shared acceptance of self-evident or worldview-neutral facts, while presuppositional apologetics attempts to claim all facts for the Christian worldview as the only framework in which they are intelligible. Another way presuppositionalism has been developed is by first presupposing reason as the laws of thought (common to all thinkers).This critically examines beliefs for meaning, and finally constructing a coherent worldview from the ground up.

This way of arguing has been called Rational Presuppositionalism. They postulate that thinking (or reasoning) is presuppositional in that we think of the less basic things, like the nature of man, in light of the more basic things, the existence or non-existence of God. How we view mankind's purpose and destiny depends on our assumption about man's origin.

Philosopher Surrendra Gangadean (1943–2022) opened his book Philosophical Foundation: A Critical Analysis of Basic Beliefs by stating the following. “Some things are clear. The basic things are clear.

The basic things about God and man and good and evil are clear to reason.” He argues step by step from knowledge is possible to the existence of God to the Good for man as knowledge of the eternal Creator.

History

The modern origins of presuppositional apologetics are in the work of Dutch theologian Cornelius Van Til, a member of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, who began to adopt a presuppositional approach to defending his belief in the truth of his faith as early as the late 1920s. Van Til personally disliked the term "presuppositional", as he felt it misrepresented his approach to apologetics, which he felt was focused primarily on the preeminence of the Bible as the ultimate criterion for truth, rather than denying or ignoring evidence. He did, however, accept the label reluctantly, given that it was a useful way of distinguishing between those who deny a neutral basis for apologetics and those who do not.

His student, Greg Bahnsen, aided in some of the later developments of Van Tillian Presuppositionalism, and the Bahnsen Theological Seminary continues to promote presuppositional apologetics in its curriculum. John Frame, another student of Van Til, also continues to advocate a presuppositional approach, although he is generally more critical of Van Til's thought than Bahnsen was.

Bahnsen's protégé, Michael R. Butler, has also been active in advancing the field. Among his contributions is a technical, metalogical study of transcendental arguments in general and the Transcendental argument for the existence of God in particular, which he wrote for Bahnsen's festschrift.

By 1952, presuppositional apologetics had acquired a new advocate in the Presbyterian theologian Gordon Clark. He embraced the label "presuppositional" since his approach to apologetics, emphasizing the priority of epistemology and an axiom of revelation, was more closely concerned with the logical order of assumptions than was Van Til.

The differences between the two views on presuppositionalism, though few in number, caused a significant rift between the two men, and even after both Clark and Van Til had died, John Robbins (a theologian and former student of Clark's) and Bahnsen were often involved in heated exchanges. In general, Van Til's approach is far more popular and widespread than Clark's.

See also

Christian existential apologetics Christian philosophy Herman Dooyeweerd Neo-Calvinism Rationalism Transcendental argument for the existence of God

Bibliography

. . "A friendly refutation of Cornelius Van Til's presuppositional apologetics."

Debates using a presuppositional approach

. . . , about the transcendental argument for the existence of God.

Debates and discussions on apologetic method

Bahnsen, Greg and Sproul, RC, "Classical Apologetics VS Presuppositional Apologetics", Reformed Theological Seminary 1997; archived from the original; retrieved 2021-09-01 on Randy Solis "Part 1 - RC Sproul vs Greg Bahnsen - Classical apologetics vs presuppositional apologetics", Part one of a two part video, June 9, 2019, 57:07, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQc9ck_PXWg&ab_channel=RandySolis . (25 MB download only). , critiquing Thomistic apologetics. on . , takes a semi-Clarkian approach to apologetics. , semi-Clarkian. , a critique of presuppositionalism.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376476438 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.