Primary Chronicle
≈ 9 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The Primary Chronicle ( ), shortened from the Russian Primary Chronicle, is a chronicle of Kievan Rus' from about 850 to 1110. It was compiled in Kiev in the 1110s. Medieval tradition attributed the work to the monk Nestor the Chronicler (hence Nestor's Chronicle), but modern scholars consider it an anonymous compilation edited by several authors, including Hegumen Sylvester of Kiev in 1116. The title comes from the opening line of the Laurentian text: "These are the narratives of bygone years regarding the origin of the land of Rus', the first princes of Kiev, and from what source the land of Rus' had its beginning". The narrative covers the legendary origins of the Slavs, the calling of the Varangians, the rise of the Rurik dynasty, and the 988 Christianization of Kievan Rus' under Vladimir the Great. The chronicle is the main written source for the early history of the East Slavs. Its authors drew on oral traditions, legal treaties, and Byzantine chronicles such as those of John Malalas and George Hamartolos. The original manuscript has not survived; the text is known only from later copies, primarily the 1377 Laurentian Codex and the 15th-century Hypatian Codex. Because the surviving manuscripts contain chronological errors, folklore, and political revisions, historians treat its historical accuracy critically.
The Primary Chronicle ( ), shortened from the Russian Primary Chronicle, is a chronicle of Kievan Rus' from about 850 to 1110. It was compiled in Kiev in the 1110s. Medieval tradition attributed the work to the monk Nestor the Chronicler (hence Nestor's Chronicle), but modern scholars consider it an anonymous compilation edited by several authors, including Hegumen Sylvester of Kiev in 1116. The title comes from the opening line of the Laurentian text: "These are the narratives of bygone years regarding the origin of the land of Rus', the first princes of Kiev, and from what source the land of Rus' had its beginning". The narrative covers the legendary origins of the Slavs, the calling of the Varangians, the rise of the Rurik dynasty, and the 988 Christianization of Kievan Rus' under Vladimir the Great. The chronicle is the main written source for the early history of the East Slavs. Its authors drew on oral traditions, legal treaties, and Byzantine chronicles such as those of John Malalas and George Hamartolos. The original manuscript has not survived; the text is known only from later copies, primarily the 1377 Laurentian Codex and the 15th-century Hypatian Codex. Because the surviving manuscripts contain chronological errors, folklore, and political revisions, historians treat its historical accuracy critically. |alt= The Chronicle was long regarded as the first compilation of the work of a monk named Nestor ( 1056 – 1114), who was also known to have written the Life of the Venerable Theodosius. Writers of the time spoke of the Chronicle of Nestor, and of the author as Nestor "the Chronicler." Based on the 1661 Paterik of the Kiev Monastery of the Caves, late 17th-century writers began to assert that Nestor "the Chronicler" wrote many of the surviving Rus' chronicles, including the Primary Chronicle, the Kievan Chronicle and the Galician–Volhynian Chronicle, even though many of the events they described took place in the 12th and 13th century, long after Nestor's death 1114. Another reason given for belief in Nestorian authorship was the word "нестера" in the opening lines of the Khlebnikov Codex (discovered in 1809), which some readers took to refer to Nestor "the Chronicler". According to Donald Ostrowski: "The word нестера was added in the Khlebnikov Codex, and thus cannot be used as evidence for the name of the compiler of the PVL." The word is not found in any of the other five main versions of the Primary Chronicle, and is thus an interpolation inserted into the text by an editor, perhaps guessing at the author's name. From the 1830s to around 1900, there was fierce academic debate about Nestor's authorship, but the question remains unresolved, and belief in Nestorian authorship persists. The internal evidence of the Primary Chronicle and the known works of Nestor often contradict one another, while the contents barely coincide in places where they seemingly should, so modern scholars have concluded that Nestor was not the author. A more likely candidate for the author of the Chronicle is Sylvester of Kiev, the hegumen (abbot) of the St. Michael's Monastery in Vydubychi, situated near Kiev, who may have compiled several sources in the year 1116. This attribution is based on the fact that the Laurentian text ends on page 286, lines 1 to 7, with the colophon "I wrote down (napisakh) this chronicle", after which he requests the readers to remember him in their prayers. Alternately, the real author may have been some other unnamed monk from the Kiev Monastery of the Caves mentioned in the title, and Sylvester completed his work, or was a very early editor or copyist of the Primary Chronicle.
Assessment and critique
Unlike many other medieval chronicles written by European monks, the Tale of Bygone Years is unique as the only written testimony on the earliest history of East Slavic people. Its comprehensive account of the history of Rus' is unmatched in other sources, but important correctives are provided by the Novgorod First Chronicle. It is also valuable as a prime example of the Old East Slavonic literature. However, its reliability has been widely called into question and placed under careful examination by contemporary specialists in the field of the Old East Slavonic history. The first doubts about trustworthiness of the narratives were voiced by Nikolay Karamzin in his History of the Russian State (1816–26), which brought attention to Nestor's questionable chronology and style of prose. Building upon Karamzin's observations, further inquiries into the philology of the Rus Primary Chronicle shined more light on various weaknesses in the text's composition. According to Dmitry Likhachov (1950), the chronicle exhibits the presence of plentiful "fillers" that were added post factum and, in effect, "destroyed the narrative's logical progression." According to Aleksey Shakhmatov (1916), some of the incongruities are a direct result of the fact that "the ruling Princes of Kiev had their own propagandists who rewrote the annals to make political claims that best suited their own purposes." Shakhmatov further described the Tale of Bygone Years as a literary creation that fell under heavy influence of the Church and the State. Dmitry Likhachov famously wrote in his 1950 critique of the Rus Primary Chronicle, "No other country in the world is cloaked in such contradictory myths about its history as Russia, and no other nation in the world interprets its history as variously as do the Russian people." The need to interpret the Chronicle, mentioned by Likhachov as essential to making sense of its narrative, stems from the facts that the text was initially compiled and edited by multiple authors with different agendas and that it had to be translated from Old East Slavic language, which proved to be an arduous task. Harvard linguist Horace G. Lunt (1988) found it important to "admit freely that we are speculating" when tales – such as Yaroslav the Wise being more than just "a patron of Slavonic books" – are reconstructed and the logical incongruities of the text are faced. Polish historian Wladyslaw Duczko (2004) concluded that the compiler of the Primary Chronicle 'manipulated his sources in the usual way: information that was not compatible was left aside, while the elements that should be there but did not exist, were invented.' Russian historian and author Igor Danilevsky mentioned that the Rus Primary Chronicle was more concerned with exploring the religious significance of the events rather than conveying to the reader the information about how it actually happened. As a result, a sizable portion of the text was directly borrowed from earlier works that contained a religious undertone like some Byzantine sources, and most notably, the Bible. The protagonists are frequently identified with biblical personages and so are ascribed certain relevant qualities and deeds that did not necessarily match the reality. Ukrainian historian Oleksiy Tolochko in 2015 upheld the conclusion reached by his many predecessors that the Chronicle’s contents are more or less fictional. Tolochko argued that some of the tales, like the story of the Rurikid clan's entry into Kiev, were invented "so as to produce a meaningful reconstruction of past events and include these well-known names" in the author's "historical scenario." Tolochko called the Rus Primary Chronicle an outstanding work of literature with an untrustworthy story and concluded that "there is absolutely no reason to continue basing our knowledge of the past on its content." Paul Bushkovitch (2012) from Yale University writes "the author was serving his rulers, identifying princes and people and leaving historians with a muddle virtually impossible to sort out." He also mentions that there are discrepancies when overlapping Scandinavian history with the narrative of the Primary Chronicle. For example, "archeological evidence does not fit the legends of the Primary Chronicle" such as: "in Scandinavia itself, there were no sagas of Viking triumphs and wars in Russia to match those recounting the conquest of Iceland and the British Isles". The credibility of the Primary Chronicle should be taken with a grain of salt for its undertone of being a political tool to justify rule.
See also
Freising manuscripts Nestor the Chronicler Russkaya Pravda
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378522530 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.