Prime avoidance lemma
≈ 5 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In algebra, the prime avoidance lemma says that if an ideal I in a commutative ring R is contained in a union of finitely many prime ideals P i 's, then it is contained in P i for some i. There are many variations of the lemma (cf. Hochster); for example, if the ring R contains an infinite field or a finite field of sufficiently large cardinality, then the statement follows from a fact in linear algebra that a vector space over an infinite field or a finite field of large cardinality is not a finite union of its proper vector subspaces.
In algebra, the prime avoidance lemma says that if an ideal I in a commutative ring R is contained in a union of finitely many prime ideals P i 's, then it is contained in P i for some i. There are many variations of the lemma (cf. Hochster); for example, if the ring R contains an infinite field or a finite field of sufficiently large cardinality, then the statement follows from a fact in linear algebra that a vector space over an infinite field or a finite field of large cardinality is not a finite union of its proper vector subspaces. Theorem (Prime Avoidance Lemma): Let E be a subset of commutative ring R that is an additive subgroup of R and is multiplicatively closed.
(In particular, E could be a subring or ideal of R.) Let I_1, I_2, \dots, I_n, n \ge 1 be ideals such that I_i are prime ideals for i \ge 3 . If E is not contained in any of the I_i , then E is not contained in the union \bigcup I_i . Proof by induction on n: The idea is to find an element of R that is in E and not in any of the I_i . The base case n=1 is trivial. Next suppose n\geq 2 .
For each i, choose z_i \in E \setminus \bigcup_{j \ne i} I_j , where each of the sets on the right is nonempty by the inductive hypothesis. We can assume z_i \in I_i for all i; otherwise, there is some z_k among them that avoids all of the I_i , and we are done. Put z = z_1 \cdots z_{n-1} + z_n . Because E is closed under addition and multiplication, z is in E by construction.
We claim that z is not in any of the I_i . Indeed, if z\in I_i for some i \le n - 1 , then z_n\in I_i , a contradiction. Next suppose z\in I_n . Then z_1 \cdots z_{n-1} \in I_n . If n=2 , this is already a contradiction.
If n>2 , then, since I_n is a prime ideal, z_i\in I_n for some i\leq n-1 , again a contradiction. \square There is the following variant of prime avoidance due to E. Davis. Proof: We argue by induction on r. Without loss of generality, we can assume there is no inclusion relation between the \mathfrak{p}_i 's; since otherwise we can use the inductive hypothesis.
Also, if x \not\in \mathfrak{p}_i for each i, then we are done; thus, without loss of generality, we can assume x \in \mathfrak{p}_r . By inductive hypothesis, we find a y in J such that x + y \in I - \cup_1^{r-1} \mathfrak{p}_i . If x + y is not in \mathfrak{p}_r , we are done. Otherwise, note that J \not\subset \mathfrak{p}_r (since x \in \mathfrak{p}_r ) and since \mathfrak{p}_r is a prime ideal, we have: \mathfrak{p}_r \not\supset J \, \mathfrak{p}_1 \cdots \mathfrak{p}_{r-1} .
Hence, we can choose y' in J \, \mathfrak{p}_1 \cdots \mathfrak{p}_{r-1} that is not in \mathfrak{p}_r . Then, since x + y \in \mathfrak{p}_r , the element x + y + y' has the required property. \square Let A be a Noetherian ring, I an ideal generated by n elements and M a finite A-module such that IM \ne M . Also, let d = \operatorname{depth}_A(I, M) = the maximal length of M-regular sequences in I = the length of every maximal M-regular sequence in I. Then d \le n ; this estimate can be shown using the above prime avoidance as follows. We argue by induction on n. Let \{ \mathfrak{p}_1, \dots, \mathfrak{p}_r \} be the set of associated primes of M. If d > 0 , then I \not\subset \mathfrak{p}_i for each i. If I = (y_1, \dots, y_n) , then, by prime avoidance, we can choose x_1 = y_1 + \sum_{i = 2}^n a_i y_i for some a_i in A such that x_1 \not\in \cup_1^r \mathfrak{p}_i = the set of zero divisors on M. Now, I/(x_1) is an ideal of A/(x_1) generated by n - 1 elements and so, by inductive hypothesis, \operatorname{depth}_{A/(x_1)}(I/(x_1), M/x_1M) \le n - 1 .
The claim now follows.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1344566333 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.