Proposition
≈ 9 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Propositions are the meanings of declarative sentences, objects of beliefs, and bearers of truth values. They explain how different sentences, such as the English "Snow is white" and the German " ", can have identical meaning by expressing the same proposition. Similarly, they ground the fact that different people can share a belief by being directed at the same content. True propositions describe the world as it is, while false ones fail to do so. Researchers distinguish types of propositions by their informational content and mode of assertion, such as the contrasts between affirmative and negative propositions, between universal and existential propositions, and between categorical and conditional propositions. Many theories of the nature and roles of propositions have been proposed. Realists argue that propositions form part of reality, a view rejected by anti-realists. Non-reductive realists understand propositions as a unique kind of entity, whereas reductive realists analyze them in terms of other entities. One proposal sees them as sets of possible worlds, reflecting the idea that understanding a proposition involves grasping the circumstances under which it would be true. A different suggestion focuses on the individuals and concepts to which a proposition refers, defining propositions as structured entities composed of these constituents.…
Propositions are the meanings of declarative sentences, objects of beliefs, and bearers of truth values. They explain how different sentences, such as the English "Snow is white" and the German " ", can have identical meaning by expressing the same proposition. Similarly, they ground the fact that different people can share a belief by being directed at the same content. True propositions describe the world as it is, while false ones fail to do so. Researchers distinguish types of propositions by their informational content and mode of assertion, such as the contrasts between affirmative and negative propositions, between universal and existential propositions, and between categorical and conditional propositions. Many theories of the nature and roles of propositions have been proposed. Realists argue that propositions form part of reality, a view rejected by anti-realists. Non-reductive realists understand propositions as a unique kind of entity, whereas reductive realists analyze them in terms of other entities. One proposal sees them as sets of possible worlds, reflecting the idea that understanding a proposition involves grasping the circumstances under which it would be true. A different suggestion focuses on the individuals and concepts to which a proposition refers, defining propositions as structured entities composed of these constituents. Other accounts characterize propositions as specific kinds of properties, relations, or states of affairs. Philosophers also debate whether propositions are abstract objects outside space and time, psychological entities dependent on mental activity, or linguistic entities grounded in language. Paradoxes challenge the different theories of propositions, such as the liar paradox. The study of propositions has its roots in ancient philosophy, with influential contributions from Aristotle and the Stoics, and later from William of Ockham, Gottlob Frege, and Bertrand Russell. Propositions are relevant to many fields. Logicians examine their logical form and inferential patterns as the premises and conclusions of arguments. Linguists investigate propositions as the meanings of declarative sentences and explore how natural language encodes this information, including the issues of ambiguity, vagueness, and context sensitivity. In psychology and philosophy of mind, researchers analyze how the mind deals with propositions, studying propositional attitudes such as belief, desire, and intention. The difference between analytic and synthetic propositions depends on the source of their truth. The truth of analytic propositions is determined only by the meanings of concepts, independent of the actual state of the world. For example, the proposition "all bachelors are unmarried" is analytically true because the concept "bachelor" already includes the meaning of "unmarried". The truth of synthetic propositions, such as "snow is white", depends on the state of the world. A similar distinction, based on the source of knowledge rather than truth, is between a priori and a posteriori propositions. A priori propositions can be known through pure reasoning alone, such as " 2 + 2 = 4 ", while a posteriori propositions describe empirical facts knowable through sensory experience, like "the sun is shining". Modal propositions express what is possible, necessary, or impossible. Rather than asserting how the world is, they describe how it could or could not have been, as in "it is possible that I will win the lottery" and "it is impossible to travel faster than light". Logicians examine the relation between different modal propositions. For example, classical modal logic states that a proposition is necessarily true if it is impossible that it is false. There are different types of modality. Alethic modality is about what is possible or necessary relative to the laws of nature, metaphysics, or logic. It contrasts with epistemic modality, which concerns what may or must be the case relative to someone's knowledge or evidence, as in "the butler cannot be the killer". Similarly, deterministic propositions express certain information, while probabilistic propositions indicate degrees of uncertainty. Normative propositions express what ought to be the case, like "you should not drink and drive". They include permissions, requirements, and prohibitions. Moral propositions are normative propositions that assert moral principles or judgments, such as "you should keep promises". Normative propositions contrast with descriptive propositions, which express what is rather than what ought to be. The schools of cognitivism and non-cognitivism debate the existence of normative propositions. Non-cognitivism argues that normative sentences are neither true nor false and do not express propositions, for example, because they convey emotions rather than propositions. A gappy proposition, also called an incomplete or unfilled proposition, is a statement whose subject matter is not properly specified, which results in an incomplete meaning. This can happen when the proposition involves an empty name, which does not refer to any real entity, such as the name Pegasus. Given the difficulties in assigning truth values to gappy propositions, philosophers debate whether they are propositions in the strict sense rather than other meaning contents. Temporal propositions, another type, are statements that refer to specific times, such as "the Berlin Wall fell in 1989". Propositions are also classified by the domain or field of inquiry to which they belong, such as mathematical, scientific, metaphysical, and theological propositions. One difficulty for the possible worlds view comes from necessary propositions, such as " 2 + 2 = 4 " and "there are infinitely many prime numbers". A proposition is necessary if it is true in all possible worlds, meaning that it is equivalent to the set of all possible worlds. As a result, all necessary propositions are identical since they all correspond to the same set, which implies that there is only a single necessary proposition. Opponents argue that this is false since different necessary propositions express distinct ideas. For example, a person may know one necessary proposition but be ignorant of another. Critics conclude that the possible worlds view is too coarse-grained to capture these distinctions. Other objections question the existence of possible worlds or hold that sets cannot perform the role of propositions since sets cannot be true or false. Another set-based proposal relies on the concept of truthmakers rather than possible worlds. A truthmaker of a proposition is an entity that makes the proposition true: if the entity exists, then it is responsible for the proposition being true. On this view, a proposition is a set of possible truthmakers. The theory is based on the idea that truth conditions are essential to a proposition: the proposition describes the conditions of what the world is like, and it is true if the world fulfills those conditions. The set of possible truthmakers encodes the truth condition of the proposition. Unlike the possible worlds view, this approach can distinguish necessary propositions: even propositions that are true in all possible worlds can still have different truthmakers. The Curry paradox, another conundrum, also concerns a self-referential proposition. It involves a conditional statement that can be used to prove any proposition, such as the claim that 2+2=5 . It has the form "if this proposition is true, then 2+2=5 ". If the conditional is true, then the antecedent is true, and it follows that 2+2=5 . If the conditional was false, then its antecedent would be false. However, a conditional with a false antecedent is automatically true. So in either case, it follows that 2+2=5 . Because the content of the second proposition does not matter for this deduction, it is possible to derive any arbitrary conclusion this way, including that pigs can fly or that the Moon is made of cheese. The Russell-Myhill paradox involves a contradiction about propositions that describe classes of true propositions. The contradiction arises when one adds the requirement that the proposition describing this class is not itself a member of the class, with the paradoxical result that the proposition is only included if it is not included. Other paradoxes concern propositions that deal with beliefs and references to different times. The truth regress is another proposition-related phenomenon, but it is usually not treated as a paradox in the strict sense. It is the observation that any true proposition generates an infinite regress: if the proposition "P" is true, then it is also the case that "it is true that P", "it is true that it is true that P", and so on, yielding infinitely many true statements. A similar regress in classical logic arises from double negation: if the proposition "P" is true, then it is also the case that "not not P", "not not not not P", and so forth. Philosophers debate how these regresses affect meaning and truth and whether they exist primarily on the level of sentences or propositions.
External links
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378847056 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.