Prout's hypothesis
Prout's hypothesis was an early 19th-century attempt to explain the existence of the various chemical elements through a hypothesis regarding the internal structure of the atom.
≈ 4 min read
Prout's hypothesis. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001377045249. /a/prout-s-hypothesis
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Prout's hypothesis was an early 19th-century attempt to explain the existence of the various chemical elements through a hypothesis regarding the internal structure of the atom. In 1815 the English chemist William Prout published two papers in which he observed that the atomic weights that had been measured for the elements known at that time appeared to be whole multiples of the atomic weight of hydrogen.
In 1816, he hypothesized that the hydrogen atom was the only truly fundamental object, which he called protyle, and that the atoms of other elements were actually groupings of various numbers of hydrogen atoms. The discrepancy between Prout's hypothesis and the known variation of some atomic weights to values far from integral multiples of hydrogen, was explained between 1913 and 1932 by the discovery of isotopes and the neutron.
According to the whole number rule of Francis Aston, Prout's hypothesis is correct for atomic masses of individual isotopes, with an error of at most 1%.
Influence
Prout's hypothesis remained influential in chemistry throughout the early 1800s. In 1826 Jacob Berzelius reported atomic weights significantly different from the ones that Prout used to back his claim and Edward Turner in 1832 added evidence in support of Berzelius.
However other chemists such as Edward Turner in 1833 measured values that seemed to be in plausible agreement with the hypothesis. Success of a sort continued in the 1840s. Jean-Baptiste Dumas found that synthesis of water matched the hypothesis.
Jean Charles Galissard de Marignac found agreement with his more extensive measurements for silver, potassium, bromine, iodine and nitrogen. However, his atomic weight of chlorine, which is 35.45 times that of hydrogen, did not match Prout's hypothesis. To explain this, Marignac proposed the basic unit was one-half of a hydrogen atom.
This change was not well received in the science community and when Dumas proposed a 0.25 unit of atomism in 1859 the concept lost additional value. Finally in 1860, Jean Stas summarized his 20 years of effort to confirm Prout's idea with rigorous but disappointing results showing the "hypothesis expressly contradicted by experiment."
Despite the ultimate failure, Prout's conjectures catalyzed more accurate and extensive measurement of atomic weights. The concept helped John Strutt and William Ramsay discover chemically inert Argon.
Prout's hypothesis was an influence on Ernest Rutherford when he succeeded in "knocking" hydrogen nuclei out of nitrogen atoms with alpha particles in 1917, and thus concluded that perhaps the nuclei of all elements were made of such particles (the hydrogen nucleus), which in 1920 he suggested be named protons, from the suffix for particles, added to the stem of Prout's word "protyle". The assumption as discussed by Rutherford was of a nucleus consisting of Z + N = A protons plus N electrons somehow trapped within thereby reducing the positive charge to +Z as observed and vaguely explaining beta decay radioactivity.
Such a nuclear constitution was known to be inconsistent with dynamics either classical or early quantum but seemed inevitable until the neutron hypothesis by Rutherford and discovery by English physicist James Chadwick.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1377045249 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.