Public Policy
journal
≈ 15 min read
Names in other languages
- astPublic Policy
- EnglishPublic Policy
- EspañolPublic Policy
- FrançaisPublic Policy
- ItalianoPublic Policy
- NederlandsPublic Policy
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Public policy is an institutionalized proposal or a decided set of elements like laws, regulations, guidelines, and actions to solve or address relevant and problematic social issues, guided by a conception and often implemented by programs. These policies govern various aspects of life, including education, health care, employment, finance, economics, transportation, and society as a whole.
The implementation of public policy is known as public administration. Public policy can be considered the sum of a government's direct and indirect activities and has been conceptualized in a variety of ways. They are created and/or enacted on behalf of the public, typically by a government.
Sometimes they are made by Non-state actors or are made in co-production with communities or citizens, which can include potential experts, scientists, engineers and stakeholders or scientific data, or sometimes use some of their results. They are typically made by policy-makers affiliated with (in democratic polities) currently elected politicians.…
Public policy is an institutionalized proposal or a decided set of elements like laws, regulations, guidelines, and actions to solve or address relevant and problematic social issues, guided by a conception and often implemented by programs. These policies govern various aspects of life, including education, health care, employment, finance, economics, transportation, and society as a whole.
The implementation of public policy is known as public administration. Public policy can be considered the sum of a government's direct and indirect activities and has been conceptualized in a variety of ways. They are created and/or enacted on behalf of the public, typically by a government.
Sometimes they are made by Non-state actors or are made in co-production with communities or citizens, which can include potential experts, scientists, engineers and stakeholders or scientific data, or sometimes use some of their results. They are typically made by policy-makers affiliated with (in democratic polities) currently elected politicians.
Therefore, the "policy process is a complex political process in which there are many actors: elected politicians, political party leaders, pressure groups, civil servants, publicly employed professionals, judges, non-governmental organizations, international agencies, academic experts, journalists and even sometimes citizens who see themselves as the passive recipients of policy." A popular way of understanding and engaging in public policy is through a series of stages known as "the policy cycle", which was first discussed by the political scientist Harold Laswell in his book The Decision Process: Seven Categories of Functional Analysis, published in 19561.
The characterization of particular stages can vary, but a basic sequence is agenda setting, policy formulation, legitimation, implementation, and evaluation. "It divides the policy process into a series of stages, from a notional starting point at which policymakers begin to think about a policy problem to a notional end point at which a policy has been implemented, and policymakers think about how successful it has been before deciding what to do next."
Officials considered that policymakers bear responsibility for advancing the interests of various stakeholders. Policy design entails conscious and deliberate effort to define policy aims and map them instrumentally. Academics and other experts in policy studies have developed a range of tools and approaches to help in this task.
Government action is the decisions, policies, and actions taken by governments, which can have a significant impact on individuals, organizations, and society at large. Regulations, subsidies, taxes, and spending plans are just a few of the various shapes it might take.
Government action aims to achieve certain social or economic objectives, such as fostering economic growth, reducing inequality, or safeguarding the environment.
Varying conceptions of public policy
Public policy can be conceptualized in various ways, depending on the speaker's or author's purposes and the characteristics of the situation at hand. One dividing line in conceptions of public policy is between those who see it primarily in terms of ideas (principles and plans of action) and those who see it as a collection of empirical phenomena (the things that are done and their outcomes).
The first of these conceptualizations is suitable when the matter of concern is relatively simple and unambiguous, and the means of enactment are expected to be highly disciplined. But where the matter is complex and/or contested – where intentions are confused and/or disguised – it may not be possible to define the policy ideas clearly and unambiguously.
In this case, it may be useful to identify a policy in terms of what actually happens. David Easton in the USA of the 1950s provided an illustration of the need he found to broaden his conceptualization of public policy beyond stated ideas: "If the formal policy of an educational system forbids discrimination against Negroes but local school boards or administrators so zone school attendance that Negroes are segregated in a few schools, both the impartial law and discriminatory practices must be considered part of the policy."
Easton characterized public policy as "a web of decisions and actions that allocates values". Other definitions of public policy in terms of a broad range of empirical phenomena include that of Paul Cairney: "the sum total of government action from signals of intent to the final outcomes".
An example of conceiving public policy as ideas is a definition by Richard Titmuss: "the principles that govern action directed towards given ends". Titmuss' perspective was particularly one of social contract ethics. In 2020, Antonio Lassance has defined public policy as "an institutionalized proposal to solve a central problem, guided by a conception" (Lassance, 2020: 7).
Lassance's perspective and concerns are grounded in a theory of change or program theory which he believes can be empirically tested. One of the most known and controversial concepts of public policy is that of Thomas R. Dye, according to whom "public policy is whatever governments choose to do or not to do" (Dye, 1972: 2).
Although widely used, Dye's concept is also criticized as being an empty concept. Dye himself admitted that his concept "discourages elaborate academic discussions of the definition of public policy - we say simply that public policy is whatever governments choose to do or not to do".
In an institutionalist view, the foundation of public policy is composed of national constitutional laws and regulations. Further foundational aspects include both judicial interpretations and regulations, which are generally authorized by legislation.
Public policy is considered strong when it solves problems efficiently and effectively, serves and supports governmental institutions and policies, and encourages active citizenship. In his book Advanced Introduction to Public Policy, B. Guy Peters defines public policy as "the set of activities that governments engage in for the purpose of changing their economy and society", effectively saying that public policy is legislation brought in to benefit or impact the electorate in some way.
In another definition, author B. Dente in his book Understanding Policy Decisions explains public policy as "a set of actions that affect the solution of a policy problem, i.e., a dissatisfaction regarding a certain need, demand or opportunity for public intervention. Its quality is measured by the capacity to create public value."
Other scholars define public policy as a system of "courses of action, regulatory measures, laws, and funding priorities concerning a given topic promulgated by a governmental entity or its representatives". Public policy is commonly embodied in "constitutions, legislative acts, and judicial decisions".
Transformative constitutions of the Global South consider judicial actions for Public policy as paramount, since the political forces that facilitate legislative decisions may run counter to the will of the people. Public policy focuses on the decisions that produce the outputs of a political system, such as transport policies, the management of a public health service, the administration of a school system, and the organization of a defense force.
The directly measurable policy outputs, "actions actually taken in pursuance of policy decisions and statements," can be differentiated from the broader policy outcomes, "focus[ing] on a policy's societal consequences." In the United States, this concept refers not only to the results of policies but, more broadly, to the decision-making and analysis behind governmental decisions.
As an academic discipline, public policy is studied by professors and students at public policy schools of major universities throughout the country. The U.S. professional association of public policy practitioners, researchers, scholars, and students is the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management.
Much of public policy concerns the evaluation of decision-making in governments and public bureaucracies.
Frameworks of public policy
Public policy frameworks provide systematic approaches to policy implementation, analysis, and improvement, offering insights into the roles of actors, institutional dynamics, and the broader context that influences decisions.
Public policy making and implementation
Public policymaking can be characterized as a dynamic, complex, and interactive system through which public problems are identified and resolved by creating new policy or reforming existing policy. Public problems can arise in countless ways and require different policy responses (such as regulations, subsidies, import quotas, and laws) at the local, national, or international level.
The public problems that influence public policy making can be of economic, social, or political nature. A government holds a legal monopoly on the initiation or threat of physical force to achieve its ends when necessary. For instance, in times of chaos, when quick decision-making is needed.
Public policy visualization
A topology model can be used to demonstrate the types of and implementation of public policy: Direct government action involving the use of money can be classified into 2 subsections. A government can either use its available resources to address the issue (Make) or contract out to the private sector (Buy).
Indirect government action involving money is the use of fiscal policy to influence behaviours. These take the form of levying taxes (Tax) or subsidizing an alternative (Subsidize). Other direct government action falls under the category of regulation.
This is when a government uses its authority to make people behave in a certain way (Oblige) or to make a behaviour illegal (Prohibit). Indirect government action without the use of money can again be classified into 2 types.
A government can provide information to its citizens on a particular issue, with hopes it affects their behaviour (Inform), or by appealing to their morality as a human or as a stakeholder in society (Implore).
Policy-Implementation gap
The Policy-Implementation gap refers to the difference between policy ideas and goals on paper and their implementation in practice. This gap arises when the goals, objectives, or provisions of a policy fail to be fully realized in practice, often due to challenges, inefficiencies, or unforeseen obstacles in the implementation process.
As an issue, it is often overlooked by governments, with implementation seen as an afterthought, sometimes referred to as 'the rest'.
Top-down and bottom-up implementation
"Top-down" and "bottom-up" describe the process of policy implementation. Top-down implementation means carrying out a policy from the top, i.e., by the central government or legislature. The bottom-up approach suggests that the implementation should start with the target group, as they are seen as the actual implementers of policy.
Evidence-based policy
Evidence-based policy is associated with Adrian Smith because in his 1996 presidential address to the Royal Statistical Society, Smith questioned the current process of policy making and urged for a more "evidence-based approach" commenting that it has "valuable lessons to offer". Some policy scholars now avoid using the term evidence-based policy, opting for terms such as evidence-informed.
This language shift allows continued thinking about the underlying desire to improve evidence use in terms of its rigor or quality, while avoiding some of the key limitations or reductionist ideas at times seen with the evidence-based language. Still, the language of evidence-based policy is widely used and, as such, can be interpreted to reflect a desire for evidence to be used well or appropriately in one way or another – such as by ensuring systematic consideration of rigorous and high quality policy relevant evidence, or by avoiding biased and erroneous applications of evidence for political ends.
The development and analysis of evidence-based / evidence-informed policy are supported by multidisciplinary public policy research and policy analysis.
Academic discipline
As an academic discipline, public policy brings in elements of many social science fields and concepts, including economics, sociology, political economy, social policy, program evaluation, policy analysis, and public management, all as applied to problems of governmental administration, management, and operations. At the same time, the study of public policy is distinct from political science or economics, in its focus on the application of theory to practice.
While the majority of public policy degrees are master's and doctoral degrees, several universities offer undergraduate programs in public policy. Notable institutions include: , home to the Balsillie School of International Affairs building on Walton Street Balsillie School of International Affairs Blavatnik School of Government Durham University Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, NUS Leiden University Hertie School, Berlin Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs, The University of Texas at Austin London School of Economics Sciences Po, Paris National Defence University, Pakistan Jamia Hamdard Traditionally, the academic field of public policy focused on domestic policy.
However, the wave of economic globalization that occurred in the late 20th and early 21st centuries created a need for a subset of public policy that focused on global governance, especially as it relates to issues that transcend national borders such as climate change, terrorism, nuclear proliferation, and economic development. Consequently, many traditional public policy schools had to adjust their curricula to suit this new policy landscape, as well as develop entirely new curricula altogether.
Controversies
The Austrian and Chicago school of economics criticise public policymakers for not "understanding basic economics". In particular, Thomas Sowell, a member of the Chicago school of economics, writes that "Under popularly elected government, the political incentives are to do what is popular, even if the consequences are worse than the consequences of doing nothing, or doing something that is less popular".
Therefore, since "Economics studies the consequences of decisions that are made about the use of land, labour, capital and other resources that go into producing the volume of output which determines a country's standard of living", this means that artificially tampering with the allocation of scarce resources by implementing certain public policies such as price controls will cause inefficiency in the economy and decline in the standard of living within society. One of the biggest controversies in public policy is that policymaking is often influenced by lobbyists, such as those from big corporations, to sway policies in their favour.
For example, the National Rifle Association of America (NRA) is an organisation that lobbies United States lawmakers to oppose stricter gun laws. International policy frameworks such as the United Nations are unable to enforce legally binding agreements on nations.
The Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples was implemented in 1960 to decolonise the areas colonised by the colonial powers of the 20th century. However, colonial territories persist despite the General Assembly's attempts to compel countries to return land.
Another controversy surrounding public policy is that individuals, including policymakers, hold biases and may seek out facts that confirm their preconceptions. A study of Danish politicians published in the British Journal of Political Science found that its subjects' preconceptions affected how they viewed data.
Further reading
Bueno de Mesquita, Ethan. 2017. Political Economy for Public Policy.
Princeton University Press Gilbert, Brett Anitra; David B. Audretsch, McDougall, Patricia P. (2004), The Emergence of Entrepreneurship Policy, Small Business Economics 22 Cohen, Nissim (2012) "Policy entrepreneurs and the design of public policy: Conceptual framework and the case of the National Health Insurance Law in Israel" Journal of Social Research & Policy, 3 (1): 5–26. David B. Audretsch; Grilo, Isabel; Thurik, A. Roy (2007), Explaining entrepreneurship and the role of policy: a framework, in: David Audretsch, Isabel Grilo and A. Roy Thurik (eds.), Handbook of Research on Entrepreneurship Policy, Edward Elgar Publishing David B. Audretsch and Beckmann, Iris A.M. (2007), From Small Business to Entrepreneurship Policy, in: David Audretsch, Isabel Grilo and A. Roy Thurik (eds.), Handbook of Research on Entrepreneurship Policy, Edward Elgar Publishing Considine, Mark (2005).
Making Public Policy. Polity Press
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378054674 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Public Policy” publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL