PubPeer

PubPeer is a website that allows users to discuss and review scientific research after publication, i.e. post-publication peer review, established in 2012.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 6 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

PubPeer is a website that allows users to discuss and review scientific research after publication, i.e. post-publication peer review, established in 2012.

The site has served as a whistleblowing platform, in that it highlighted shortcomings in several high-profile papers, in some cases leading to retractions and to accusations of scientific fraud,[1][2][3][4][5][6][7] as noted by Retraction Watch.[8] Contrary to most platforms, it allows anonymous post-publication commenting, a controversial feature which is the main factor for its success.[9][10] Consequently, accusations of libel have been levelled at some of PubPeer's users;[11][12] correspondingly the website has since 2016 told commentators to use only facts that can be publicly verified.[13]

Questions have been raised about the copyright ownership of PubPeer's often-anonymous contents.[14]

In 2021 a study found that "more than two-thirds of comments [on PubPeer] are posted to report some type of misconduct, mainly about image manipulation". Health sciences and life sciences were shown to have most comments, and most comments reporting publishing fraud and data manipulation. Social science and humanities disciplines in turn had fewer comments, but the highest percentage comments about critical reviews about theory and highlight methodological flaws. The research concluded that "while biochemists access the site to report misconduct... social scientists and humanists use it to discuss conclusions and detect methodological errors". The study also reported that 85.6% of comments are anonymous and that "only 31.5% of publications received more than three comments, and the response rate of authors is very low (7.5%)."[15]

In 2023 a study found that "only 21.5% of the articles [flagged on PubPeer] that deserve an editorial notice (i.e., honest errors, methodological flaws, publishing fraud, manipulation) were corrected by the [relevant] journal".[16]

In November 2024, PubPeer and its co-Founder, Brandon Stell, received the Institutional Award for research integrity from the Einstein Foundation (Germany).[17]

See also

edit edit source Scholia has a profile for PubPeer (Q19891828).

References

edit edit source
  1. ^ "Researcher admits mistakes in stem cell study". Phys.org. 23 May 2013. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  2. ^ Sven Stockrahm; Lydia Klöckner; Dagny Lüdemann (2013-05-23). "Zellbiologe gibt Fehler in Klonstudie zu". Zeit. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  3. ^ Cyranoski, David; Check Hayden, Erika (2013-05-23). "Stem-cell cloner acknowledges errors in groundbreaking paper". Nature. doi:10.1038/nature.2013.13060. ISSN 1476-4687. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  4. ^ Otake, Tomoko (2014-04-20). "'STAPgate' shows Japan must get back to basics in science". The Japan Times. Retrieved 2024-08-31. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  5. ^ Singh Chawla, Dalmeet (2024-04-29). "How reliable is this research? Tool flags papers discussed on PubPeer". Nature. 629 (8011): 271–272. Bibcode:2024Natur.629..271S. doi:10.1038/d41586-024-01247-6. PMID 38684831. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  6. ^ Ordway, Denise-Marie (2023-08-01). "5 tips for using PubPeer to report on research and the scientific community". The Journalist's Resource. Retrieved 2024-08-31. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  7. ^ Barbour, Boris; Stell, Brandon M. (2020-01-28), "PubPeer: Scientific Assessment Without Metrics", in Biagioli, Mario; Lippman, Alexandra (eds.), Gaming the Metrics, The MIT Press, pp. 149–156, doi:10.7551/mitpress/11087.003.0015, ISBN 978-0-262-35656-5, retrieved 2024-08-31 Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  8. ^ "Leading diabetes researcher corrects paper as more than a dozen studies are questioned on PubPeer". Retraction Watch. 12 January 2015. Retrieved 17 May 2017. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  9. ^ Torny, Didier (February 2018). Pubpeer: vigilante science, journal club or alarm raiser? The controversies over anonymity in post-publication peer review. International Conference on Peer Review. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  10. ^ Teixeira da Silva, Jaime A. (2018-01-01). "The opacity of the PubPeer Foundation: what PubPeer's "About" page tells us". Online Information Review. 42 (2): 282–287. doi:10.1108/OIR-06-2017-0191. ISSN 1468-4527. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  11. ^ Paul Jump (13 November 2014). "Can post-publication peer review endure?". Times Higher Education. Retrieved 5 December 2014. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  12. ^ "PubPeer's first legal threat" (blog). 24 August 2014. Retrieved 5 December 2014. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  13. ^ "PubPeer - How to comment on PubPeer". pubpeer. Archived from the original on 15 November 2016. Retrieved 17 May 2017. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  14. ^ Silva, Jaime A. Teixeira da (2018-07-01). "The Issue of Comment Ownership and Copyright at PubPeer". 教育資料與圖書館學. 55 (2): 227–237. doi:10.6120/JoEMLS.201807_55(2).e001.BC.BE. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  15. ^ Ortega, José Luis (May 2022). "Classification and analysis of PubPeer comments: How a web journal club is used". Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology. 73 (5): 655–670. doi:10.1002/asi.24568. ISSN 2330-1635. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  16. ^ Ortega, José-Luis; Delgado-Quirós, Lorena (2023-01-23). "How do journals deal with problematic articles. Editorial response of journals to articles commented in PubPeer". Profesional de la información. 32 (1) e320118. doi:10.3145/epi.2023.ene.18. hdl:10261/362437. ISSN 1699-2407. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19
  17. ^ "Einstein Foundation Awards". award.einsteinfoundation.de. Retrieved 2024-12-12. Wikipedia revision 1376130468, retrieved 2026-11-19

Further reading

edit edit source edit edit source

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376130468 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

References

  1. ↩Wikipedia “PubPeer” revision 1376130468 · retrieved 2026-10-20 date of establishment (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL