Quantum chaos

and classical mechanics.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 12 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

and classical mechanics. The figure shows the main ideas running in each direction. Quantum chaos is a branch of physics focused on how chaotic classical dynamical systems can be described in terms of quantum theory.

The primary question that quantum chaos seeks to answer is: "What is the relationship between quantum mechanics and classical chaos?" The correspondence principle states that classical mechanics is the classical limit of quantum mechanics, specifically in the limit as the ratio of the Planck constant to the action of the system tends to zero.

If this is true, then there must be quantum mechanisms underlying classical chaos (although this may not be a fruitful way of examining classical chaos). If quantum mechanics does not demonstrate an exponential sensitivity to initial conditions, how can exponential sensitivity to initial conditions arise in classical chaos, which must be the correspondence principle limit of quantum mechanics?

In seeking to address the basic question of quantum chaos, several approaches have been employed: # Development of methods for solving quantum problems where the perturbation cannot be considered small in perturbation theory and where quantum numbers are large. # Correlating statistical descriptions of eigenvalues (energy levels) with the classical behavior of the same Hamiltonian (system).…

and classical mechanics. The figure shows the main ideas running in each direction. Quantum chaos is a branch of physics focused on how chaotic classical dynamical systems can be described in terms of quantum theory.

The primary question that quantum chaos seeks to answer is: "What is the relationship between quantum mechanics and classical chaos?" The correspondence principle states that classical mechanics is the classical limit of quantum mechanics, specifically in the limit as the ratio of the Planck constant to the action of the system tends to zero.

If this is true, then there must be quantum mechanisms underlying classical chaos (although this may not be a fruitful way of examining classical chaos). If quantum mechanics does not demonstrate an exponential sensitivity to initial conditions, how can exponential sensitivity to initial conditions arise in classical chaos, which must be the correspondence principle limit of quantum mechanics?

In seeking to address the basic question of quantum chaos, several approaches have been employed: Development of methods for solving quantum problems where the perturbation cannot be considered small in perturbation theory and where quantum numbers are large. Correlating statistical descriptions of eigenvalues (energy levels) with the classical behavior of the same Hamiltonian (system).

Study of probability distribution of individual eigenstates (see scars and quantum ergodicity). Semiclassical methods such as periodic-orbit theory connecting the classical trajectories of the dynamical system with quantum features. Direct application of the correspondence principle. energy level spectra of hydrogen in an electric field near n=15.

Note that energy levels can cross due to underlying symmetries of dynamical motion. energy level spectra of lithium in an electric field near n=15. Note that energy levels cannot cross due to the ionic core (and resulting quantum defect) breaking symmetries of dynamical motion.

For conservative systems, the goal of quantum mechanics in non-perturbative regimes is to find the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of a Hamiltonian of the form H = H_s + \varepsilon H_{ns}, \, where H_s is separable in some coordinate system, H_{ns} is non-separable in the coordinate system in which H_{s} is separated, and \epsilon is a parameter which cannot be considered small. Physicists have historically approached problems of this nature by trying to find the coordinate system in which the non-separable Hamiltonian is smallest and then treating the non-separable Hamiltonian as a perturbation.

Finding constants of motion so that this separation can be performed can be a difficult (sometimes impossible) analytical task. Solving the classical problem can give valuable insight into solving the quantum problem.

If there are regular classical solutions of the same Hamiltonian, then there are (at least) approximate constants of motion, and by solving the classical problem, we gain clues how to find them. Other approaches have been developed in recent years.

One is to express the Hamiltonian in different coordinate systems in different regions of space, minimizing the non-separable part of the Hamiltonian in each region. Wavefunctions are obtained in these regions, and eigenvalues are obtained by matching boundary conditions. Another approach is numerical matrix diagonalization.

If the Hamiltonian matrix is computed in any complete basis, eigenvalues and eigenvectors are obtained by diagonalizing the matrix. However, all complete basis sets are infinite, and we need to truncate the basis and still obtain accurate results. These techniques boil down to choosing a truncated basis from which accurate wavefunctions can be constructed.

The computational time required to diagonalize a matrix scales as N^3 , where N is the dimension of the matrix, so it is important to choose the smallest basis possible from which the relevant wavefunctions can be constructed. It is also convenient to choose a basis in which the matrix is sparse and/or the matrix elements are given by simple algebraic expressions because computing matrix elements can also be a computational burden.

A given Hamiltonian shares the same constants of motion for both classical and quantum dynamics. Quantum systems can also have additional quantum numbers corresponding to discrete symmetries (such as parity conservation from reflection symmetry).

However, if we merely find quantum solutions of a Hamiltonian which is not approachable by perturbation theory, we may learn a great deal about quantum solutions, but we have learned little about quantum chaos. Nevertheless, learning how to solve such quantum problems is an important part of answering the question of quantum chaos.

P(s) = e^{-s}.\ In addition, systems which display chaotic classical motion are expected to be characterized by the statistics of random matrix eigenvalue ensembles. For systems invariant under time reversal, the energy-level statistics of a number of chaotic systems have been shown to be in good agreement with the predictions of the Gaussian orthogonal ensemble (GOE) of random matrices, and it has been suggested that this phenomenon is generic for all chaotic systems with this symmetry.

If the normalized spacing between two energy levels is s , the normalized distribution of spacings is well approximated by P(s) = \frac{\pi}{2}se^{-\pi s^2/4}. Many Hamiltonian systems which are classically integrable (non-chaotic) have been found to have quantum solutions that yield nearest neighbor distributions which follow the Poisson distributions.

Similarly, many systems which exhibit classical chaos have been found with quantum solutions yielding a Wigner-Dyson distribution, thus supporting the ideas above. One notable exception is diamagnetic lithium which, though exhibiting classical chaos, demonstrates Wigner (chaotic) statistics for the even-parity energy levels and nearly Poisson (regular) statistics for the odd-parity energy level distribution. g_c(E) = \sum_k T_k \sum_{n=1}^\infty \frac{1}{2\sinh{(\chi_{nk}/2)}}\, e^{i(nS_k - \alpha_{nk} \pi/2)}.

Recently there was a generalization of this formula for arbitrary matrix Hamiltonians that involves a Berry phase-like term stemming from spin or other internal degrees of freedom. The index k distinguishes the primitive periodic orbits: the shortest period orbits of a given set of initial conditions. T_k is the period of the primitive periodic orbit and S_k is its classical action.

Each primitive orbit retraces itself, leading to a new orbit with action nS_k and a period which is an integral multiple n of the primitive period. Hence, every repetition of a periodic orbit is another periodic orbit. These repetitions are separately classified by the intermediate sum over the indices n . \alpha_{nk} is the orbit's Maslov index.

The amplitude factor, 1/\sinh{(\chi_{nk}/2)} , represents the square root of the density of neighboring orbits. Neighboring trajectories of an unstable periodic orbit diverge exponentially in time from the periodic orbit. The quantity \chi_{nk} characterizes the instability of the orbit.

A stable orbit moves on a torus in phase space, and neighboring trajectories wind around it. For stable orbits, \sinh{(\chi_{nk}/2)} becomes \sin{(\chi_{nk}/2)} , where \chi_{nk} is the winding number of the periodic orbit. \chi_{nk} = 2\pi m , where m is the number of times that neighboring orbits intersect the periodic orbit in one period.

This presents a difficulty because \sin{(\chi_{nk}/2)} = 0 at a classical bifurcation. This causes that orbit's contribution to the energy density to diverge. This also occurs in the context of photo-absorption spectrum.

Using the trace formula to compute a spectrum requires summing over all of the periodic orbits of a system. This presents several difficulties for chaotic systems: 1) The number of periodic orbits proliferates exponentially as a function of action. 2) There are an infinite number of periodic orbits, and the convergence properties of periodic-orbit theory are unknown.

This difficulty is also present when applying periodic-orbit theory to regular systems. 3) Long-period orbits are difficult to compute because most trajectories are unstable and sensitive to roundoff errors and details of the numerical integration.

Gutzwiller applied the trace formula to approach the anisotropic Kepler problem (a single particle in a 1/r potential with an anisotropic mass tensor) semiclassically. He found agreement with quantum computations for low lying (up to n = 6 ) states for small anisotropies by using only a small set of easily computed periodic orbits, but the agreement was poor for large anisotropies.

The figures above use an inverted approach to testing periodic-orbit theory. The trace formula asserts that each periodic orbit contributes a sinusoidal term to the spectrum.

Rather than dealing with the computational difficulties surrounding long-period orbits to try to find the density of states (energy levels), one can use standard quantum mechanical perturbation theory to compute eigenvalues (energy levels) and use the Fourier transform to look for the periodic modulations of the spectrum which are the signature of periodic orbits. Interpreting the spectrum then amounts to finding the orbits which correspond to peaks in the Fourier transform.

Use d(E)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\Im(\operatorname{Tr}(G(x,x^\prime,E)) (tracing over positions) and calculate it again in stationary phase approximation to get an approximation for the density of states d(E) . Note: Taking the trace tells you that only closed orbits contribute, the stationary phase approximation gives you restrictive conditions each time you make it. In step 4 it restricts you to orbits where initial and final momentum are the same i.e. periodic orbits.

Often it is nice to choose a coordinate system parallel to the direction of movement, as it is done in many books. f(w) = \sum_k \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} D^{i}_{\it nk} \sin(2\pi nw\tilde{S_k} - \phi_{\it nk}). \phi_{\it nk} is a phase that depends on the Maslov index and other details of the orbits. D^i_{\it nk} is the recurrence amplitude of a closed orbit for a given initial state (labeled i ). It contains information about the stability of the orbit, its initial and final directions, and the matrix element of the dipole operator between the initial state and a zero-energy Coulomb wave.

For scaling systems such as Rydberg atoms in strong fields, the Fourier transform of an oscillator strength spectrum computed at fixed \epsilon as a function of w is called a recurrence spectrum, because it gives peaks which correspond to the scaled action of closed orbits and whose heights correspond to D^i_{\it nk} . Closed-orbit theory has found broad agreement with a number of chaotic systems, including diamagnetic hydrogen, hydrogen in parallel electric and magnetic fields, diamagnetic lithium, lithium in an electric field, the H^{-} ion in crossed and parallel electric and magnetic fields, barium in an electric field, and helium in an electric field.

For the case of one-dimensional system with the boundary condition y(0)=0 the density of states obtained from the Gutzwiller formula is related to the inverse of the potential of the classical system by \frac{d^{1/2}}{dx^{1/2}} V^{-1}(x)=2 \sqrt \pi \frac{dN(x)}{dx} here \frac{dN(x)}{dx} is the density of states and V(x) is the classical potential of the particle, the half derivative of the inverse of the potential is related to the density of states as in the Wu–Sprung potential. Quantum Chaos by Martin Gutzwiller (1992 and 2008, Scientific American) Quantum Chaos Martin Gutzwiller Scholarpedia 2(12):3146. doi:10.4249/scholarpedia.3146 Category:Quantum Chaos Scholarpedia What is...

Quantum Chaos by Ze'ev Rudnick (January 2008, Notices of the American Mathematical Society) Brian Hayes, "The Spectrum of Riemannium"; American Scientist Volume 91, Number 4, July–August, 2003 pp. 296–300. Discusses relation to the Riemann zeta function. Eigenfunctions in chaotic quantum systems by Arnd Bäcker.

ChaosBook.org

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1373648914 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

8 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.