Quantum tomography
≈ 14 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Quantum tomography or quantum state tomography is the process by which a quantum state is reconstructed using measurements on an ensemble of identical quantum states. The source of these states may be any device or system which prepares quantum states either consistently into quantum pure states or otherwise into general mixed states. To be able to uniquely identify the state, the measurements must be tomographically complete.
That is, the measured operators must form an operator basis on the Hilbert space of the system, providing all the information about the state. Such a set of observations is sometimes called a quorum. The term tomography was first used in the quantum physics literature in a 1993 paper introducing experimental optical homodyne tomography. In quantum process tomography on the other hand, known quantum states are used to probe a quantum process to find out how the process can be described.
Similarly, quantum measurement tomography works to find out what measurement is being performed. Whereas, randomized benchmarking scalably obtains a figure of merit of the overlap between the error prone physical quantum process and its ideal counterpart.…
Quantum tomography or quantum state tomography is the process by which a quantum state is reconstructed using measurements on an ensemble of identical quantum states. The source of these states may be any device or system which prepares quantum states either consistently into quantum pure states or otherwise into general mixed states. To be able to uniquely identify the state, the measurements must be tomographically complete.
That is, the measured operators must form an operator basis on the Hilbert space of the system, providing all the information about the state. Such a set of observations is sometimes called a quorum. The term tomography was first used in the quantum physics literature in a 1993 paper introducing experimental optical homodyne tomography. In quantum process tomography on the other hand, known quantum states are used to probe a quantum process to find out how the process can be described.
Similarly, quantum measurement tomography works to find out what measurement is being performed. Whereas, randomized benchmarking scalably obtains a figure of merit of the overlap between the error prone physical quantum process and its ideal counterpart.
The general principle behind quantum state tomography is that by repeatedly performing many different measurements on quantum systems described by identical density matrices, frequency counts can be used to infer probabilities, and these probabilities are combined with Born's rule to determine a density matrix which fits the best with the observations. This can be easily understood by making a classical analogy. Consider a harmonic oscillator (e.g. a pendulum).
The position and momentum of the oscillator at any given point can be measured and therefore the motion can be completely described by the phase space. This is shown in figure 1. By performing this measurement for a large number of identical oscillators we get a probability distribution in the phase space (figure 2). This distribution can be normalized (the oscillator at a given time has to be somewhere) and the distribution must be non-negative.
So we have retrieved a function W(x,p) which gives a description of the chance of finding the particle at a given point with a given momentum. For quantum mechanical particles the same can be done. The only difference is that the Heisenberg's uncertainty principle mustn't be violated, meaning that we cannot measure the particle's momentum and position at the same time. The particle's momentum and its position are called quadratures (see Optical phase space for more information) in quantum related states.
By measuring one of the quadratures of a large number of identical quantum states will give us a probability density corresponding to that particular quadrature. This is called the marginal distribution, \mathrm{pr}(X) or \mathrm{pr}(P) (see figure 3). In the following text we will see that this probability density is needed to characterize the particle's quantum state, which is the whole point of quantum tomography.
Born's rule states \mathrm{P}(E_i | \rho) = \mathrm{Trace}(E_i \rho) , where E_i is a particular measurement outcome projector and \rho is the density matrix of the system. Given a histogram of observations for each measurement, one has an approximation p_i to \mathrm{P}(E_i | \rho) for each E_i .
Given linear operators S and T , define the inner product S \cdot T = \mathrm{Tr}[S^\dagger T] = \vec{S}^\dagger \vec{T} where \vec{T} is representation of the T operator as a column vector and \vec{S}^\dagger a row vector such that \vec{S}^\dagger \vec{T} is the inner product in \mathbb{C}^d of the two. Define the matrix A as A = \begin{pmatrix} \vec E_1^\dagger \\ \vec E_2^\dagger \\ \vec E_3^\dagger \\ \vdots \end{pmatrix} . Here E i is some fixed list of individual measurements (with binary outcomes), and A does all the measurements at once.
Then applying this to \vec{\rho} yields the probabilities: A\vec{\rho} = \begin{pmatrix} \vec{E}_1^\dagger \vec\rho \\ \vec{E}_2^\dagger \vec\rho \\ \vec{E}_3^\dagger \vec\rho \\ \vdots \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} E_1 \cdot \rho \\ E_2 \cdot \rho \\ E_3 \cdot \rho \\ \vdots \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} \mathrm{P}(E_1 | \rho) \\ \mathrm{P}(E_2 | \rho) \\ \mathrm{P}(E_3 | \rho) \\ \vdots \end{pmatrix} \approx \begin{pmatrix} p_1 \\ p_2 \\ p_3 \\ \vdots \end{pmatrix} = \vec{p} .
Linear inversion corresponds to inverting this system using the observed relative frequencies \vec p to derive \vec \rho (which is isomorphic to \displaystyle\rho ). This system is not going to be square in general, as for each measurement being made there will generally be multiple measurement outcome projectors E_i .
For example, in a 2-D Hilbert space with 3 measurements \sigma_x, \sigma_y, \sigma_z , each measurement has 2 outcomes, each of which has a projector E i , for 6 projectors, whereas the real dimension of the space of density matrices is (2⋅2 2 )/2=4, leaving A to be 6 x 4. To solve the system, multiply on the left by A^T : A^T A \vec\rho = A^T \vec{p} . Now solving for \vec\rho yields the pseudoinverse: \vec\rho = (A^T A)^{-1} A^T \vec{p} . This works in general only if the measurement list E i is tomographically complete.
Otherwise, the matrix A^T A will not be invertible. \rho = \frac{1}{2}\left(I + \vec{r} \cdot \vec{\sigma}\right) = \frac{1}{2}\begin{pmatrix} 1 + r_z & r_x - \mathrm i r_y \\ r_x + \mathrm i r_y & 1 - r_z \end{pmatrix} .
The single-qubit state tomography can be performed by means of single-qubit Pauli measurements: First, create a list of three quantum circuits, with the first one measuring the qubit in the computational basis (Z-basis), the second one performing a Hadamard gate before measurement (which makes the measurement in X-basis), and the third one performing the appropriate phase shift gate (that is \sqrt{Z}^{\dagger}=|0\rangle\langle 0|+\exp(-\mathrm i \pi/2)|1\rangle\langle 1| ) followed by a Hadamard gate before measurement (which makes the measurement in Y-basis); Then, run these circuits (typically thousands of times), and the counts in the measurement results of the first circuit produces \bar{z}=(n_{z,+}-n_{z,-})/(n_{z,+}+n_{z,-}) , the second circuit \bar{x} , and the third circuit \bar{y} ; Finally, if \bar{x}^2+\bar{y}^2+\bar{z}^2\leq 1 , then a measured Bloch vector is produced as \vec{r}_{m}=(\bar{x},\bar{y},\bar{z}) , and the measured density matrix is \rho_m = \frac{1}{2}\left(I + \vec{r}_m \cdot \vec{\sigma}\right) ; If \bar{x}^2+\bar{y}^2+\bar{z}^2>1 , it'll be necessary to renormalize the measured Bloch vector as \vec{r}_{m}=(\bar{x},\bar{y},\bar{z})/\sqrt{\bar{x}^2+\bar{y}^2+\bar{z}^2} before using it to calculate the measured density matrix.
This algorithm is the foundation for qubit tomography and is used in some quantum programming routines, like that of Qiskit.
Example: homodyne tomography.
Electromagnetic field amplitudes (quadratures) can be measured with high efficiency using photodetectors together with temporal mode selectivity. Balanced homodyne tomography is a reliable technique of reconstructing quantum states in the optical domain. This technique combines the advantages of the high efficiencies of photodiodes in measuring the intensity or photon number of light, together with measuring the quantum features of light by a clever set-up called the homodyne tomography detector.
Quantum homodyne tomography is understood by the following example. A laser is directed onto a 50-50% beamsplitter, splitting the laser beam into two beams. One is used as a local oscillator (LO) and the other is used to generate photons with a particular quantum state. The generation of quantum states can be realized, e.g. by directing the laser beam through a frequency doubling crystal and then onto a parametric down-conversion crystal. This crystal generates two photons in a certain quantum state.
One of the photons is used as a trigger signal used to trigger (start) the readout event of the homodyne tomography detector. The other photon is directed into the homodyne tomography detector, in order to reconstruct its quantum state.
Since the trigger and signal photons are entangled (this is explained by the spontaneous parametric down-conversion article), it is important to realize that the optical mode of the signal state is created nonlocal only when the trigger photon impinges the photodetector (of the trigger event readout module) and is actually measured. More simply said, it is only when the trigger photon is measured, that the signal photon can be measured by the homodyne detector. Now consider the homodyne tomography detector as depicted in figure 4 (figure missing).
The signal photon (this is the quantum state we want to reconstruct) interferes with the local oscillator, when they are directed onto a 50-50% beamsplitter. Since the two beams originate from the same so called master laser, they have the same fixed phase relation. The local oscillator must be intense, compared to the signal so it provides a precise phase reference. The local oscillator is so intense, that we can treat it classically (a = α) and neglect the quantum fluctuations.
The signal field is spatially and temporally controlled by the local oscillator, which has a controlled shape. Where the local oscillator is zero, the signal is rejected. Therefore, we have temporal-spatial mode selectivity of the signal. The beamsplitter redirects the two beams to two photodetectors. The photodetectors generate an electric current proportional to the photon number.
The two detector currents are subtracted and the resulting current is proportional to the electric field operator in the signal mode, depended on relative optical phase of signal and local oscillator. Since the electric field amplitude of the local oscillator is much higher than that of the signal the intensity or fluctuations in the signal field can be seen. The homodyne tomography system functions as an amplifier.
The system can be seen as an interferometer with such a high intensity reference beam (the local oscillator) that unbalancing the interference by a single photon in the signal is measurable. This amplification is well above the photodetectors noise floor. The measurement is reproduced a large number of times. Then the phase difference between the signal and local oscillator is changed in order to 'scan' a different angle in the phase space. This can be seen from figure 4.
The measurement is repeated again a large number of times and a marginal distribution is retrieved from the current difference. The marginal distribution can be transformed into the density matrix and/or the Wigner function. Since the density matrix and the Wigner function give information about the quantum state of the photon, we have reconstructed the quantum state of the photon. The advantage of this balanced detection method is that this arrangement is insensitive to fluctuations in the intensity of the laser.
The quantum computations for retrieving the quadrature component from the current difference are performed as follows. The photon number operator for the beams striking the photodetectors after the beamsplitter is given by: \hat n_{i}=\hat a_{i}^\dagger \hat a_{i} , where i is 1 and 2, for respectively beam one and two.
The mode operators of the field emerging the beamsplitters are given by: \hat a_{1}= 2^{-1/2}(\hat a - \alpha_{LO}) \hat a_{2}= 2^{-1/2}(\hat a + \alpha_{LO}) The \hat a denotes the annihilation operator of the signal and alpha the complex amplitude of the local oscillator.
The number of photon difference is eventually proportional to the quadrature and given by: \hat n_{21}=\hat n_{2} - \hat n_{1} = \alpha^*_{LO} \hat a + \alpha_{LO} \hat a^\dagger , Rewriting this with the relation: \hat q=2^{-1/2}(\hat a^\dagger+\hat a) Results in the following relation: \hat n_{21}=2^{1/2}|\hat\alpha_{LO}|\hat q_{\theta} , where we see clear relation between the photon number difference and the quadrature component \hat q_{\theta} .
By keeping track of the sum current, one can recover information about the local oscillator's intensity, since this is usually an unknown quantity, but an important quantity for calculating the quadrature component \hat q_{\theta} . L(\hat\rho) = \prod_j \lang y_j|\hat\rho|y_j\rang^{f_j} where \lang y_j|\hat\rho|y_j\rang is the probability of outcome y_j for the state \hat\rho . Finding the maximum of this function is non-trivial and generally involves iterative methods.
The methods are an active topic of research. \displaystyle\mathrm{Tr}[\Pi_l \rho_m] = \mathrm{P}(l | \rho_m) . Exploiting linearity as above, this can be inverted to solve for the \Pi_l . Not surprisingly, this suffers from the same pitfalls as in quantum state tomography: namely, non-physical results, in particular negative probabilities. Here the \Pi_l will not be valid POVM's, as they will not be positive.
Bayesian methods as well as Maximum likelihood estimation of the density matrix can be used to restrict the operators to valid physical results. \mathcal{E}(\rho) = \sum_i A_i \rho A_i^\dagger , where \rho \in \mathcal{B(H)} , the bounded operators on Hilbert space; with operation elements \displaystyle A_i satisfying \textstyle\sum_i A_i^\dagger A_i \leq I so that \mathrm{Tr}[\mathcal{E}(\rho)] \leq 1 . Let \displaystyle\{E_i\} be an orthogonal basis for \mathcal{B(H)} .
Write the \displaystyle A_i operators in this basis \displaystyle A_i = \sum_{m} a_{im}E_m . This leads to \mathcal{E}(\rho) = \sum_{m,n} \chi_{mn} E_{m} \rho E_n^\dagger , where \chi_{mn} = \sum_{i} a_{im} a_{in}^* . The goal is then to solve for \displaystyle\chi , which is a positive superoperator and completely characterizes \mathcal{E} with respect to the \displaystyle\{E_i\} basis. SQPT approaches this using d^2 linearly independent inputs \rho_j , where d is the dimension of the Hilbert space \mathcal{H} .
For each of these input states \rho_j , sending it through the process gives an output state \mathcal{E}(\rho) which can be written as a linear combination of the \rho_k , i.e. \textstyle \mathcal{E}(\rho_j) = \sum_k c_{jk} \rho_k . By sending each \rho_j through many times, quantum state tomography can be used to determine the coefficients c_{jk} experimentally. Write E_m \rho_j E_n^\dagger = \sum_{k} B_{m,n,j,k} \rho_k , where B is a matrix of coefficients.
Then \sum_k c_{jk} \rho_k = \mathcal{E}(\rho_j) = \sum_{m,n} \chi_{m,n} E_m \rho_j E_n^\dagger = \sum_{m,n}\sum_{k} \chi_{m,n} B_{m,n,j,k} \rho_k . Since \rho_k form a linearly independent basis, \displaystyle c_{jk} = \sum_{m,n}\chi_{m,n} B_{m,n,j,k} . Inverting B gives \chi : \chi_{m,n} = \sum_{j,k} B^{-1}_{m,n,j,k} c_{jk} .
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372802944 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.