Reconciliation studies

Since about the 2010s, reconciliation studies has been a new scientific approach in the field of peace and conflict studies.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 13 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Since about the 2010s, reconciliation studies has been a new scientific approach in the field of peace and conflict studies. It has commonalities with peacebuilding, conflict transformation, and transitional justice research, and to a lesser extent with academic work on peace psychology, conflict resolution, conflict management, mediation, security studies, memory studies, and trauma and resilience studies.

Definition

Reconciliation is generally viewed as a process, outcome, or goal for improving relationships. More specifically, it is a process of creating "normal" and if possible "good" relationships between the parties in response to grave incidents such as wars, civil conflicts, genocides, atrocities, forced displacement, enslavement, dictatorship, oppression, colonialism, Apartheid, and other human rights violations and injustices.

In these situations of massive violations of human rights, reconciliation means creating a time and place to address past suffering, integrate, embrace, and share a common future. It is a process of improving relations between and within groups, recognition of social identities and power dynamics, addressing trauma and reckoning with the past.

Reconciliation mainly focuses on building or rebuilding relationships and dealing with the past, present and future and is an essential part of Peacebuilding by addressing the root causes of conflict and improving intergroup relations. The definition of reconciliation encompasses a variety of perspectives, open to wide applications and sometimes overlapping interpretations, depending on the actor employing the term.

Reconciliation is a critical part of the peacebuilding process and is intertwined with achieving justice, reducing violence, and conflict transformation. Discussions are still ongoing whether reconciliation is a process, an outcome, an ideal and perhaps utopian goal, or a specific stage or moment in the process of overcoming violent conflict.

However, there is a certain tendency to see reconciliation as an overarching concept for the long-term process to create better relationships after violence. Many scholars and practitioners also stress the importance of reconciliation efforts for the cessation of violence in the middle of conflict.

Reconciliation researcher Martin Leiner defines reconciliation studies as the "scholarly description, interpretation and evaluation of processes to develop 'normal' and if possible 'good' relationships between states, groups, organizations, and individuals reacting against past, present or preventing future grave incidents such as Wars, Civil Wars, Genocides, Atrocities, Forced Displacement, Enslavement, Dictatorship, Oppression, Colonialism, Apartheid, and other Human Rights Violations and injustices, and creating a scientific discourse of developing a common future to enable the transformation of conflicts towards the path of peace." Stressing the main goal of reconciliation as improved intergroup relations and the building or rebuilding of trust, Professor Karina V. Korostelina defines reconciliation as "a process of management of social identities and reckoning with the past.

Reconciliation processes depend on interrelations among conflict, power, social identity, and collective memory/ narratives about history." According to the Stanford Dictionary of Philosophy, political reconciliation includes the following practices: "Apologies, Memorials, Truth Telling, Amnesties, Trials and Punishment, Lustration, Reparations, Forgiveness and Participation in Deliberative Processes" Reconciliation is also viewed as a process of building long-term peace between former enemies through bilateral initiatives and institutions across governments and societies.

Other scholars would add at least trauma therapies, encounter programs, and the construction of a common human security structure in order to achieve no repetition. Within this field, reconciliation studies are characterized by four guiding assumptions: Relationship.

Reconciliation studies are focusing on the question of how trustful and cooperative relationships can be (re)built in the face of grave incidents of violence. This implies a closeness of reconciliation studies to philosophical and scientific anthropologies of humans as relational animals (Hegel 1807, Buber 1923, Rosa 2012, Fuchs 2007, du Toit 2017).

This focus on relationships has also practical consequences. For many reconciliation scholars, their field also includes the study of the distortions of relationships before grave incidents are happening.

The social construction of enemies, pathologies of communication connected with imaginaries of the other (Kearney 2003), frames for war, missed reconciliation in the initial moments of conflict, certain long-term structural realities of discrimination such as Apartheid, racism, islamophobia, antisemitism, antiziganism, ableism, xenophobia, classism, patriarchate, colonialism, slavery, and different cultural habits of dehumanization and exploitation often indicate needs and possibilities for reconciliation in order to create better relationships before violent incidents occur. Intergroup and Identity Dynamics.

Reconciliation not only creates a foundation for peaceful coexistence but also promotes cooperation between conflicting parties based on the management of social identities and addressing a contentious past. It requires reduction of intergroup threat, relative deprivation, and addressing trauma.

It also involves the dissolution of rigid social boundaries and the formation of common and cross-cutting identities; these identities then act as a foundation for stable and peaceful coexistence building on the respect and trust between former enemies. Thus, reconciliation processes are deeply rooted in interconnections between conflict, power, social identity, and collective memory.

Inclusiveness. Reconciliation studies often assume that all parties involved in a distortion of a relationship must be integrated into the process of reconciliation and that multiple kinds of processes of reconciliation (such as reconciliation with oneself, with the own group and with others) are intertwined and are happening simultaneously.

Reconciliation studies try to overcome limited concepts of reconciliation such as working only on individual I-Thou-relationships between persons or only working in so called "post-conflict settings". Transdisciplinary. The factors why reconciliation succeeds or fails are so multiple and complex that transdisciplinary research including a wide range of disciplines is required.

Scientific ambition. An important group of reconciliation scholars, the group that founded the International Association for Reconciliation Studies (IARS), aims at the goal of lifting reconciliation studies from the self-reflection of practitioners to a high-level scientific field.

Type and degree of reconciliation

Reconciliation is about building or rebuilding relationships and always involves the question of who to reconcile with. The target may be an individual, an interpersonal relationship, an institution, or social, political, ethnic, religious, or other groups. It could also reach into deeper areas, not just reconciliation between conflicting entities.

From this perspective, reconciliation can be classified into five dimensions: 1) With oneself, 2) With the other(s), 3) With the own group, 4) With the environment, 5) With transcendence. Reconciliation also goes beyond the personal encounter between victims and perpetrators; it also involves changing structural violence such as poverty, discrimination, and exclusion, and promoting mutual respect based on justice to heal deep-rooted hatred and hostility toward each other.

Reconciliation is a long-term process that creates a culture of sustainable peace. There is a description of the degree of (or level of) reconciliation. This is sometimes measured on a normative scale of reconciliation, such as “minimalist” to “maximalist” or “thin” to “thick”.

Thin-level reconciliation is a basic agreement for minimal coexistence between former enemies which is "simple coexistence". It excludes or minimizes recognition of the past and responsibility and focuses on the needs of the present. It is an important first step toward full reconciliation in that it can lead to a ceasefire and start a formal dialogue.

In contrast, the maximal and thick reconciliation approach would require individual as well as social transformation, encompassing acknowledgment of past wrongdoings, mutual acceptance, a shared future and even forgiveness. It is a more victim-centered approach aimed at respect and healing for the victims.

Some scholars also categorize reconciliation into non-reconciliation, shallow reconciliation and deep reconciliation based on the consensus of narratives, in which case the key factor in categorizing the degree is the history of both sides and the confrontation of historical narratives. The goal of reconciliation is a journey that starts at a minimal level and progresses to a maximal reconciliation through successive phases.

Process of reconciliation

There is no standardized reconciliation process of universal application. Interdisciplinary scholars are researching how reconciliation is structured and what procedures are desirable, based on historical and empirical records.

For example, Fanie du Toit (2018), former Executive Director at the Institute for Justice and Reconciliation proposed a theoretical approach to reconciliation-as-interdependence to initiate reconciliation in ongoing conflicts based on a case in South Africa. He emphasizes the restoration of just relations while reminding that reconciliation is the only alternative for the long-term well-being of one's own community and the hostile group.

In terms of the reconciliation process, most would agree with the following description. Reconciliation does not mean that victims should forget the series of past violence and move on for the common good. On the contrary, it is argued that for the prevention of its repetition, it is necessary to remember and, if feasible, forgive.

Thus, it rather involves justice, historical awareness of what the victims have experienced, reparation, psychological healing, punishment of the perpetrators and moral rectitude and many other practices. This requires a multi-dimensional approach which would promote the opportunity, space, actions, expertise and will for both victims and perpetrators to recover.

Addressing complexities of social identity and power in intergroup relations, reconciliation processes redefine social boundaries, reduce intergroup threat and relative deprivation, address traumas and historical injustices, and create inclusive and balanced collective axiology. Reconciliation is also not something that happens entirely after the conflict or violence is over.

Reconciliation in practice

Practical examples of facilitating reconciliation include politically documented acts such as treaties, conventions, or legal provisions; symbolic acts such as apologies from heads of state; formal reparations; or the establishment of memorials or monuments. Also, various research institutes, civil society organizations, and related organizations are running programs to promote reconciliation.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) is a well-known and the most common domestic organization which is tasked with reconciliation. Conflict Mediation, Trauma healing, Community Dialogue are representative programs being carried out by civil society. Many studies have also suggested that gender considerations significantly enhance the effectiveness of reconciliation processes.

Based on these findings, there is a growing number of programs that include female voices in testimony and records, engage female representatives in dialogue, and provide training for them.

Sources

Appleby, R.Scott (2000). The Ambivalence of the Sacred. Religion, Violence, and Reconciliation.

Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Aristophanes, Lysistrata and other Plays. Translated from the Greek. London: Penguin Auerbach, Yehudith (2009).

The Reconciliation Pyramid – A Narrative-Based Framework for Analyzing Identity Conflicts, in Political Psychology, 30 (2). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9221.2008.00692.x Avedian, Vahagn (2024). The Theory of Collective Reconciliation: A Trinity of Recognition, Responsibility and Reparation.

London: Routledge Bar-Siman-Tov, Yaacov (ed. (2004)), From Conflict Resolution to Reconciliation. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-516643-4 Bar-Tal, D. (2009).

Reconciliation as a Foundation of Culture of Peace. In J. de Rivera (Ed.), Handbook on Building Cultures of Peace (pp. 363–377). Springer New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-09575-2_25 Bar-Tal, Daniel, Intractable Conflicts (2015).

Socio-psychological foundations and Dynamics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press- ISBN 1107562546 Baum, Gregory and Harold Wells (1997) Reconciliation of Peoples: Challenge to the Churches. Eugene, Oregon: Wipf & Stock Publishers Bloomfield, D., Barnes, T., Huyse, L., & International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (Eds.). (2003).

Reconciliation after violent conflict: A handbook. International IDEA Brounéus, K. (2003). Reconciliation: Theory and practice for development cooperation.

The Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency Doxtader, Eric/ Villa-Vicencio, Charles (eds.) (2003), Through Fire and Water. The Roots of Division and the Potential for Reconciliation in Africa. Washington DC: Africa Research and Publications Du Toit, Fanie (2018) When Political Transition works.

Reconciliation as Interdependence. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Gardner-Feldman, Lily (2012), Germany's foreign policy of Reconciliation.

From Enmity and Amity. London: Rowman&Littlefield Publishers. ASIN:B008RAKQWM Gobodo-Madikizela, Pumla (2004) A Human Being Died That Night.

A South African Woman Confronts the Legacy of Apartheid. Boston: Mariner Books: ASIN: B00XWXRE5Q Gopin, Marc (2000), Holy War, Holy Peace. How Religion can bring Peace to the Middle East.

Oxford: Oxford University Press. Govier, T. (2006). Taking Wrongs Seriously: Acknowledgement, Reconciliation, and the Politics of Sustainable Peace.

Humanities Press Halperine, Eran (2015), Emotions in Conflict: Inhibitors and Facilitators of Peace Making (Routledge Studies in Political Psychology, Band 2. London. Routledge.

Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich (1807) Phänomenologie des Geistes. in Wolfgang Bonsiepen and Reinhard Heede (eds.,1980). ISBN 978-3-7873-4158-0 Keyes, S. (2019). Mapping on Approaches to Reconciliation.

The Network for Religious and Traditional Peacemakers, 1–24 Kriesberg, L. (2007). Reconciliation: Aspects, Growth, and Sequences.

Louis Kriesberg: Pioneer in Peace and Constructive Conflict Resolution Studies, 12(1), 1–21 Kutz, Susanne, Dirk Wegner and Dan Bar-On (2000): Bridging the Gap: Storytelling as a Way to Work through Political and Collective Hostilities, Hamburg: Körber-Stiftung Lederach, J. P. (1997). Building peace: Sustainable reconciliation in divided societies.

United States Institute of Peace Press Lederach, J. P. (2005). The moral imagination: The art and soul of building peace. Oxford University Press Leiner, M. (2018).

Conclusion: From Conflict Resolution to Reconciliation. In M. Leiner & C. Schliesser (Eds.), Alternative Approaches in Conflict Resolution (pp. 175–185). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-58359-4_17 Leiner, M., & Schliesser, C. (Eds.). (2018).

Alternative Approaches in Conflict Resolution. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-58359-4 Little, A., & Maddison, S. (2017). Reconciliation, transformation, struggle: An introduction.

International Political Science Review, 38(2), 145–154. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192512116681808 Malley-Morrison, Kathleen/Mercurio, Andrea/Twose, Gabriel (eds.) (2013), International Handbook of Peace and Reconciliation: New York: Springer. ISBN 978-1-4614-5932-3. Marwecki, Daniel (2020), Germany and Israeli: Whitewashing and Statebuilding.

London: C Hurst & Co Publishers Ltd. Nadler, Arie/ Malloy, Thomas E./ Fisher, Jeffrey D. (eds.) (2008), The Social Psychology of Intergroup Reconciliation. Oxford: Oxford University Press 2008. Pękala, Urszula/Irena Dingel (Eds.(2018)), Ringen um Versöhnung.

Religion und Politik im Verhältnis zwischen Deutschland und Polen seit 1945. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck&Ruprecht. ISBN 978-3-525-57069-2 Philpott, Daniel (2006), The Politics of Past Evil.

Religion, Reconciliation and the Dilemmas of Transitional Justice. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press. ASIN: B016YLHTSY Philpott, Daniel.

(2012). Just and Unjust Peace: An Ethic of Political Reconciliation. Just and Unjust Peace: An Ethic of Political Reconciliation.

10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199827565.001.0001 Rosa, Hartmut (2012), Weltbeziehungen in einem Zeitalter der Beschleunigung. Umrisse einer neuen Gesellschaftskritik. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp.

ISBN 978-3-518-29577-9 Tutu, D. (1999). No Future Without Forgiveness. Doubleday Verdeja, E. (2009).

Unchopping a tree: Reconciliation in the aftermath of political violence. Temple University Press Volf, Miroslav (1996), Exclusion and Embrace: A Theological Exploration of Identity, Otherness, and Reconciliation. London: Paragon OS. .

International Association for Reconciliation Studies the Academic Alliance for Reconciliation Studies in the Middle East and North Africa Center for International Reconciliation Studies at Waseda University Jena Center for Reconciliation Studies Mary Hoch Center for Reconciliation at the Carter School for Peace and Conflict Resolution

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1370753329 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

24 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.