Replaceability argument
≈ 9 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The replaceability argument, or the logic of the larder, is a philosophical argument against vegetarianism. It holds that consuming animal products can benefit animals because, if they were not consumed, fewer animals would be brought into existence.[1][2] The argument has been discussed especially in utilitarian ethics.[3]
History
edit edit sourceEarly utilitarian formulations
edit edit sourceIn 1789, the utilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham endorsed a version of the argument. He contended that painless killing of a nonhuman animal could be beneficial overall because it did not harm the animal, while the people who ate the animal's body were made better off.[1]
Late 19th-century debate
edit edit sourceRitchie and Stephen
edit edit sourceIn 1895, the philosopher David George Ritchie used the argument in response to claims made for vegetarianism by Henry Stephens Salt in Animals' Rights (1892), stating:[4]
If all the world were Jews, it has been well said, there would be no pigs in existence; and if all the world were vegetarians, would there be any sheep or cattle, well cared for, and guarded against starvation?
In 1896, the writer Leslie Stephen described the "argument for humanity" as the weakest argument for vegetarianism and repeated Ritchie's argument, stating: "The pig has a stronger interest than anyone in the demand for bacon."[5]
Salt's response
edit edit sourceSalt responded to both authors in an 1896 article titled "The Philosopher and the Pig". He called their argument fallacious because it referred to "another existence" when the question concerned "this existence". He also argued that it could not be shown that it was an "advantage to the Pig to be born".[6]
Salt's later treatment
edit edit sourceIn 1914, Salt published The Humanities of Diet, in which he again addressed the argument and called it the "logic of the larder". He described it as "the very negation of a true reverence for life; for it implies that the real lover of animals is he whose larder is fullest of them", and stated:[7]
It is often said, as an excuse for the slaughter of animals, that it is better for them to live and to be butchered than not to live at all. Now, obviously, if such reasoning justifies the practice of flesh-eating, it must equally justify all breeding of animals for profit or pastime, when their life is a fairly happy one. ... In fact ... there is hardly any treatment that cannot be justified by the supposed terms of such a contract. Also, the argument must apply to mankind. ... The fallacy lies in the confusion of thought which attempts to compare existence with non-existence. A person who is already in existence may feel that he would rather have lived than not, but he must first have the terra firma of existence to argue from; the moment he begins to argue as if from the abyss of the non-existent, he talks nonsense, by predicating good or evil, happiness or unhappiness, of that of which we can predicate nothing.
Late 20th-century utilitarian discussion
edit edit sourceSinger and Parfit
edit edit sourceIn Animal Liberation (1975), the utilitarian philosopher Peter Singer agreed with Salt's view. Singer later changed his position while writing Practical Ethics, after being influenced by Derek Parfit's discussion of "impersonal wrongs" and the nonidentity problem.[1]
21st-century treatments
edit edit sourceIn Killing Happy Animals (2013), the philosopher Tatjana Višak discusses the argument in relation to utilitarianism. She rejects the argument, holding that being brought into existence does not benefit animals.[8]
See also
edit edit sourceIn humans:
- Deprivation argument, that being born is inherently advantageous to unborn children, as part of the philosophical aspects of the abortion debate
- Every Sperm Is Sacred, a satire about taking the deprivation argument to its extreme of using no contraception
References
edit edit source- ^ a b c Delon, Nicolas (2016). "The Replaceability Argument in the Ethics of Animal Husbandry" (PDF). In Thompson, Paul B.; Kaplan, David M. (eds.). Encyclopedia of Food and Agricultural Ethics. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands. pp. 1–7. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-6167-4_512-1. ISBN 978-94-007-6167-4. Retrieved 8 March 2021.
- ^ Matheny, Gaverick; Chan, Kai M. A. (December 2005). "Human Diets and Animal Welfare: the Illogic of the Larder". Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics. 18 (6): 579–594. doi:10.1007/s10806-005-1805-x. ISSN 1187-7863. S2CID 154198751.
- ^ Višak, Tatjana (2015). "Do Utilitarians Need to Accept the Replaceability Argument?". In Višak, Tatjana; Garner, Robert (eds.). The Ethics of Killing Animals. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199396078.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-19-939607-8.
- ^ Ritchie, David George (1895). Natural Rights: A Criticism of Some Political and Ethical Conceptions. Library of Philosophy. London: Sonnenschein. p. 110.
- ^ Stephen, Leslie (1896). Social Rights and Duties: Addresses to Ethical Societies. Vol. 1. London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co. p. 236.
- ^ Salt, H. S. (5 December 1896). "The Philosopher and the Pig". The Vegetarian. 9 (49): 585. Retrieved 8 March 2021.
- ^ Salt, Henry S. (1914). "Logic of the Larder". The Humanities of Diet. Manchester: The Vegetarian Society. pp. 221–222.
- ^ Peterson, Anna (2014). "Review of Tatjana Višak, Killing Happy Animals: Explorations in Utilitarian Ethics". Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics. 27 (3): 523–525. doi:10.1007/s10806-014-9496-9. S2CID 140459084.
Further reading
edit edit source- John, Tyler M.; Sebo, Jeff (17 December 2020), "Consequentialism and Nonhuman Animals", in Portmore, Douglas W. (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Consequentialism, Oxford University Press, pp. 563–591, doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190905323.013.32, ISBN 978-0-19-090532-3, retrieved 9 March 2021
- Dombrowski, Daniel; The Center for Process Studies (2001). "The Replaceability Argument". Process Studies. 30 (1): 22–35. doi:10.5840/process200130112. ISSN 0360-6503. S2CID 170500961.
and drink
and events
cooking shows
- The Animals Film (1981)
- Diet for a New America (1991)
- A Cow at My Table (1998)
- Meet Your Meat (2002)
- Post Punk Kitchen (2003–2004)
- Peaceable Kingdom (2004)
- Earthlings (2005)
- A Sacred Duty (2007)
- Fat, Sick and Nearly Dead (2010)
- Planeat (2010)
- Forks Over Knives (2011)
- Vegucated (2011)
- Live and Let Live (2013)
- Speciesism: The Movie (2013)
- Cowspiracy (2014)
- PlantPure Nation (2015)
- What the Health (2017)
- Carnage (2017)
- Dominion (2018)
- Eating You Alive (2018)
- The Game Changers (2018)
- Milked (2021)
- Living on the Veg (2020)
- Punk Rock Vegan Movie (2023)
- Maa Ka Doodh (2023)
- You Are What You Eat: A Twin Experiment (2024)
and journals
and reports
- On Abstinence from Eating Animals (3rd century)
- The Way to Health, Long Life and Happiness (1683)
- Wisdom's Dictates (1691)
- Acetaria: A Discourse of Sallets (1699)
- The Fable of the Bees (1714)
- A Reasonable Plea for the Animal Creation (1746)
- Primitive Cookery (1767)
- The Cry of Nature; or, An Appeal to Mercy and to Justice, on Behalf of the Persecuted Animals (1791)
- Remarks on Cruelty to Animals (1795)
- An Essay on Abstinence from Animal Food, as a Moral Duty (1802)
- Vegetable Cookery (1812)
- A Vindication of Natural Diet (1813)
- Reasons for not Eating Animal Food (1814)
- Moral Inquiries on the Situation of Man and of Brutes (1824)
- Nature's Own Book (1835)
- Fruits and Farinacea (1845)
- "The Vegetarian; or a Visit to Aunt Primitive" (1847)
- The Penny Domestic Assistant and Guide to Vegetarian Cookery (1850)
- The Perfect Way in Diet (1881)
- The Ethics of Diet (1883)
- A Plea for Vegetarianism and Other Essays (1886)
- What is Vegetarianism? (1886)
- Flesh or Fruit? An Essay on Food Reform (1888)
- The First Step (1891)
- Shelley's Vegetarianism (1891)
- Behind the Scenes in Slaughter-Houses (1892)
- Why I Am a Vegetarian (1895)
- Figs or Pigs? (1896)
- Fifty Years of Food Reform (1898)
- The Logic of Vegetarianism (1899)
- Thirty-nine Reasons Why I Am a Vegetarian (1903)
- The Meat Fetish (1904)
- The Apsley Cookery Book
- The New Ethics (1907)
- A Fleshless Diet (1910)
- The Humanities of Diet (1914)
- The Benefits of Vegetarianism (1927)
- Living the Good Life (1954)
- Ten Talents (1968)
- Diet for a Small Planet (1971)
- The Vegetarian Epicure (1972)
- Moosewood Collective Cookbooks (1973)
- The Farm Vegetarian Cookbook (1975)
- Laurel's Kitchen (1976)
- Moosewood Cookbook (1977)
- Fit for Life (1985)
- Diet for a New America (1987)
- The Sexual Politics of Meat (1990)
- Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone (1997)
- The China Study (2005)
- Skinny Bitch (2005)
- Livestock's Long Shadow (2006)
- The Bloodless Revolution (2006)
- Of Victorians and Vegetarians (2007)
- Eating Animals (2009)
- The Kind Diet (2009)
- Why We Love Dogs, Eat Pigs, and Wear Cows (2009)
- The Vegan Studies Project (2015)
- Animal (De)liberation (2016)
- The End of Animal Farming (2018)
- Vegetable Kingdom (2020)
- Making a Stand for Animals (2022)
- Dinner: 120 Vegan and Vegetarian Recipes for the Most Important Meal of the Day (2024)
- Meat Atlas (annual)
- Animal Liberation (1987)
- Tame Yourself (1991)
- Manifesto (2008)
- Onward to Freedom (2014)
- Salvation of Innocents (2014)
- Holocaust on your Plate (2003)
- Annie Besant
- Arnold Hills
- Count Leo Tolstoy
- Edward Carpenter
- Ernest Bell
- George Bernard Shaw
- Havelock Ellis
- Hubert Bland
- Mahatma Gandhi
- James Keir Hardie
- John Galsworthy
- J. Howard Moore
- Ouida
- Peter Kropotkin
- Ralph Hodgson
- Robert Cunninghame-Graham
- Rudyard Kipling
- Thomas Hardy
- William Morris
- Algernon Charles Swinburne
- Rev. James Leigh Joynes (father-in-law)
- James Leigh Joynes (brother-in-law)
- Vegetarian Society (vice-president)
- Humanitarian League (co-founder and general secretary)
- National Society for the Abolition of Cruel Sports (co-founder)
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376992923 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.