Rhea letter
The "Rhea letter" was an early 19th-century political controversy of the United States stemming from the First Seminole War and the contingent annexation of what is now the U.S. state of Florida.
≈ 8 min read
Rhea letter. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001376931295. /a/rhea-letter
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The "Rhea letter" was an early 19th-century political controversy of the United States stemming from the First Seminole War and the contingent annexation of what is now the U.S. state of Florida. The controversy involves four (or rather three) key documents: the "Jackson January letter" sent by U.S. Army general Andrew Jackson to President James Monroe on January 6, 1818, with its later annotation that the "Rhea letter" had been burned; the presumably fictitious "Rhea letter" purportedly sent to Andrew Jackson by Tennessee congressman John Rhea at the behest of James Monroe in February 1818; the vaguely threatening letter sent to former U.S. president James Monroe on his deathbed in June 1831 by John Rhea at the behest of Andrew Jackson; the "Denunciation of the Insinuations of John Rhea" written by James Monroe as the last document he ever signed.
This chain of evidence relates to Andrew Jackson's after-the-fact rationalization and defense of his unauthorized invasion of Florida in 1818, a campaign that now goes by the name First Seminole War. This conspiracy and the extended controversy over Jackson's 1818 Florida campaign played out against the background of the dispossession and expulsion of Indigenous people from their lands in what is now the southeastern United States, the politics of the 1824, 18281, and 1832 U.S. presidential campaigns, and the Jackson–William H. Crawford–John C. Calhoun hate triangle that emerged after the last Founding Father president left office.
The controversy surrounding the 1818 invasion, and the Monroe administration's response, resurfaced a dozen years later and played a central role in the Jackson administration backbiting in 1831 that led to Calhoun's departure from the vice presidency in 1832. Since the late 19th century historians have broadly agreed that Andrew Jackson lied that he had been secretly granted secret special permission by James Monroe to invade Florida, when in fact he had been only copied on orders granting permission to pacify Seminoles, but specifically prohibiting engagement with the Spanish forts in Florida, and that he then conspired to create false evidence that such an order had been given.
Jackson wanted Florida, so he took Florida, and both the Monroe administration and the 15th Congress ultimately shrugged at the illegality of the popular 60-day war, but there was, however, just enough heat to the charges that Jackson scrambled to excuse himself through a combination of obfuscation and outright falsehood. Both John Quincy Adams and historian Richard Stenberg described Jackson's "Rhea letter" scheme as "depraved".
The notion of the first "Rhea letter" can fairly be put in scare quotes, as historians have variously described it as a hoax, a total fabrication, and a brazen lie, or in the best possible reading, cover for a shambolic imperial blitzkrieg "steeped in an air of guilty complicity". The current editor of The Papers of Andrew Jackson stated in 2010 that "the judgment of most historians" on the "Rhea letter" question is that "not only did [it] not exist, but could not have existed."
From Jackson's "self-righteously justified in a rhetorically rigid but flexibly pragmatic" perspective, honesty and honor were foolish notions and quite beside the point. In the words of United States Military Academy history professor Stephen J. Watson, "Old Hickory [that is, Andrew Jackson] was determined to secure the southern borderlands for American landholders, of whom he was characteristic, by whatever means he considered necessary, and his iron will drove this bellicose approach to defense and the aggrandizement of American interests from the War of 1812 until his death."
Second Rhea letter, and "Denunciation of the Insinuations of John Rhea"
Thus it came to be that, in the middle of the anti-Calhoun intrigues of Jackson's courtiers in 1831 and Calhoun's ultimately fruitless attempts to defend himself, former Congressman John Rhea wrote to former President Monroe at the behest of Jackson. Schouler, writing in 1884, described this letter as conveying violence in its very appearance: "Even to this day, that letter, deliberately composed and appearing to have been carefully copied out, bristles with hate and defiance, every line resembling a row of rattlesnakes."
This letter demanded that Monroe admit to having written Jackson with permission to invade by using Rhea as his amanuensis. Schouler, channeling Jackson biographer James Parton, commented, "Is it not singular that, while we are told that Rhea's letter to Jackson was burnt, neither Rhea nor Jackson has pretended to state what was its substance, what the dates of Rhea's interview with Monroe, what the terms of the supposed authority, or any other details?"
The editors of The Papers of Andrew Jackson comment, "The case for the existence of a Rhea document relies ultimately on Jackson's credibility. The corroborating testimony he obtained from John Overton, and from a nearly senile, and obviously eager-to-please, Rhea, was weak, and he apparently did not seek or obtain support from former military associates who might have seen Rhea's letter."
James Monroe was in his final illness when he received the letter from John Rhea, and thus one of the final acts of his life was dictating, and having witnessed and notarized, a statement denying all of Rhea's claims, which were in fact Jackson's claims. Monroe's son-in-law Samuel L. Gouverneur and William Wirt, U.S. Attorney General from 1817 to 1829, made it known that this document existed and they preserved it carefully, just in case Jackson should ever attempt to lay the blame at Monroe's feet.
Monroe had previously been publicly supportive while privately firm but gentle with Jackson, and he was said to have been shocked and distressed at Rhea's falsehoods; the document he dictated and signed in response is known as "Denunciation of the Insinuations of John Rhea." The only possible defense for the legality and legitimacy of Jackson's invasion comes from his claim that Monroe issued a secret order to him (through Rhea).
Jackson scaffolded a second set of lies on top of this first falsehood: because of the secrecy of the secret order, all evidence was supposed to be obscured and destroyed and hidden from everyone in government and the military except for Jackson and Monroe. The editors of The Papers therefore state that the "existence or non-existence of Rhea's letter can probably never be established with certainty."
American historian Daniel Walker Howe has compared the behavior pattern in the construction of the "Rhea letter" fiction to the elaborate construction in 1828 of a false timeline (along with the recruitment of cronies to swear to Jackson's version) that plausibly excused his legally adulterous/bigamous marriage situation of 1789 to 1793. In both cases, lawyer Jackson knew enough about the requirements for proving a case that he benefited from the evidence of absence problem, or rather the impossibility of proving the negative ("the secret letter definitely did not exist," "the Natchez marriage definitely did not happen"), or as historian Feller put it, the whole trap was laid from the beginning with "no paper trail, no smoking gun."
Sources
(originally published as )
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376931295 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Rhea letter” date of establishment (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL