Robust Parameter Design

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Q7353536Snapshot

≈ 15 min read

Names in other languages

  • EnglishRobust Parameter Design
  • 中文穩健設計

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

A robust parameter design, introduced by Genichi Taguchi, is an experimental design used to exploit the interaction between control and uncontrollable noise variables by robustification—finding the settings of the control factors that minimize response variation from uncontrollable factors. Control variables are variables of which the experimenter has full control. Noise variables lie on the other side of the spectrum. While these variables may be easily controlled in an experimental setting, outside of the experimental world they are very hard, if not impossible, to control. Robust parameter designs use a naming convention similar to that of FFDs. A 2 (m1+m2)-(p1-p2) is a 2-level design where m1 is the number of control factors, m2 is the number of noise factors, p1 is the level of fractionation for control factors, and p2 is the level of fractionation for noise factors. Consider an RPD cake-baking example from Montgomery (2005), where an experimenter wants to improve the quality of cake. While the cake manufacturer can control the amount of flour, amount of sugar, amount of baking powder, and coloring content of the cake, other factors are uncontrollable, such as oven temperature and bake time. The manufacturer can print instructions for a bake time of 20 minutes but in the real world has no control over consumer baking habits.…

A robust parameter design, introduced by Genichi Taguchi, is an experimental design used to exploit the interaction between control and uncontrollable noise variables by robustification—finding the settings of the control factors that minimize response variation from uncontrollable factors. Control variables are variables of which the experimenter has full control. Noise variables lie on the other side of the spectrum. While these variables may be easily controlled in an experimental setting, outside of the experimental world they are very hard, if not impossible, to control. Robust parameter designs use a naming convention similar to that of FFDs. A 2 (m1+m2)-(p1-p2) is a 2-level design where m1 is the number of control factors, m2 is the number of noise factors, p1 is the level of fractionation for control factors, and p2 is the level of fractionation for noise factors. Consider an RPD cake-baking example from Montgomery (2005), where an experimenter wants to improve the quality of cake. While the cake manufacturer can control the amount of flour, amount of sugar, amount of baking powder, and coloring content of the cake, other factors are uncontrollable, such as oven temperature and bake time. The manufacturer can print instructions for a bake time of 20 minutes but in the real world has no control over consumer baking habits. Variations in the quality of the cake can arise from baking at 325° instead of 350° or from leaving the cake in the oven for a slightly too short or too long period of time. Robust parameter designs seek to minimize the effects of noise factors on quality. For this example, the manufacturer hopes to minimize the effects in fluctuation of bake time on cake quality, and in doing this the optimal settings for the control factors are required. RPDs are primarily used in a simulation setting where uncontrollable noise variables are generally easily controlled. Whereas in the real world, noise factors are difficult to control; in an experimental setting, control over these factors is easily maintained. For the cake-baking example, the experimenter can fluctuate bake-time and oven-temperature to understand the effects of such fluctuation that may occur when control is no longer in his/her hands. Robust parameter designs are very similar to fractional factorial designs (FFDs) in that the optimal design can be found using Hadamard matrices, principles of effect hierarchy and factor sparsity are maintained, and aliasing is present when full RPDs are fractionated. Much like FFDs, RPDs are screening designs and can provide a linear model of the system at hand. What is meant by effect hierarchy for FFDs is that higher-order interactions tend to have a negligible effect on the response. As stated in Carraway, main effects are most likely to have an effect on the response, then two-factor interactions, then three-factor interactions, and so on. The concept of effect sparsity is that not all factors will have an effect on the response. These principles are the foundation for fractionating Hadamard matrices. By fractionating, experimenters can form conclusions in fewer runs and with fewer resources. Oftentimes, RPDs are used at the early stages of an experiment. Because two-level RPDs assume linearity among factor effects, other methods may be used to model curvature after the number of factors has been reduced.

Construction

Hadamard matrices are square matrices consisting of only + and −. If a Hadamard matrix is normalized and fractionated, a design pattern is obtained. However, not all designs are equal, which means that some designs are better than others, and specific design criteria are used to determine which design is best. After obtaining a design pattern, experimenters generally know to which setting each factor should be set. Each row, in the pattern, indicates a run, and each column indicates a factor. For the partial design pattern shown left, the experimenter has identified seven factors that may have an effect on the response and hopes to gain insight as to which factors have an effect in eight runs. In the first run, factors 1, 4, 5, and 6 are set to high levels while factors 2, 3, and 7 are set to low levels. Low levels and high levels are settings typically defined by the subject matter expert. These values are extremes but not so extreme that the response is pushed into non-smooth regions. After each run, results are obtained; and by fluctuating multiple factors in single runs instead of using the OFAT method, interactions between variables may be estimated as well as the individual factor effects. If two factors interact, then the effect one factor has on the response is different depending on the settings of another factor. Fractionating Hadamard matrices appropriately is very time-consuming. Consider a 24-run design accommodating six factors. The number of Hadamard designs from each Hadamard matrix is 23 choose 6; that is 100,947 designs from each 24×24 Hadamard matrix. Since there are 60 Hadamard matrices of that size, the total number of designs to compare is 6,056,820. Leoppky, Bingham, and Sitter (2006) used complete search methodology and have listed the best RPDs for 12, 16, and 20 runs. Because complete search work is so exhaustive, the best designs for larger run sizes are often not readily available. In that case, other statistical methods may be used to fractionate a Hadamard matrix in such a way that allows only a tolerable amount of aliasing. Efficient algorithms such as forward selection and backward elimination have been produced for FFDs, but due to the complexity of aliasing introduced by distinguishing control and noise variables, these methods have not yet been proven effective for RPDs.

History and design criteria

To fully understand the design criteria, an understanding of history and fractional factorial designs is necessary. FFDs seek to understand which factors have an effect on a response and seek to optimize the response by finding the appropriate factor settings. Unlike RPDs, FFDs do not distinguish between control and noise variables. F(x) &= \sum_{J\in P}b_JX_J(x) \\ &= \sum_{J\in PC}\sum_{K\in PN}b_{J\cup K}X_{J\cup K}(x) \end{align} Where: b_L = \frac{1}{2^m}\sum_{x\in F}X_L(x);\quad b_0 = \frac{n}{2^m} If \left| \frac{b_{J\cup K}}{b_0} \right| = 1 then the design is regular; otherwise partial aliasing exists. While Ye developed this indicator function, Bingham and Sitter were working on clarification of resolution and aberration for robust parameter designs. In 2006, Leoppky, Bingham, and Sitter published the extended word-length pattern and indicator function for robust parameter designs. Because RPDs are concerned about minimizing process variation due to noise factors, the priority of effects changes from the hierarchy of effects of FFDs. Main effects are still the first priority, and two-factor interactions are still the second priority; but if any interactions have a control-by-noise (CN) interaction, then that interaction is increased by 0.5 on the priority scale. For example, a CCN three-factor interaction would be a priority 3 in a FFD because three-factor interactions are the third priority, two-factor interactions are the second priority, and main effects are the first priority. However, since RPDs are concerned about noise variables, the CCN interaction is a priority 2.5 effect. The CN interaction bumps the priority up by 0.5; so the traditional priority 3 minus the 0.5 for the CN interaction results in a 2.5 priority. A full table of priorities can be found in Leoppky, Bingham, and Sitter (2006).

Design comparison

Further investigation of the principles introduced will provide a deeper understanding of design comparison. For regular fractional factorial designs, the word length will determine what types of aliasing are present. For example, the word "2367" can be broken into aliasing structures as follows: The word 2367 is of length 4, and the worst-case aliasing is that main effects are aliased with three-factor interactions, and two-factor interactions are aliased with other two-factor interactions. Word lengths become less simplistic when talking about RPDs because the priority of effects has changed. Consider the word 23578 where factors 2, 3, and 5 are control variables and factors 7 and 8 are noise variables. The following aliasing strings can be derived from this word: 2=3578, 3=2578 5=2378 or C=CCNN 7=2358, 8=2357 or N=CCCN 23=578, 25=378, 35=278 or CC=CNN 27=358 and 28=357 or CN=CCN 235=78 or CCC=NN Now that one can see what types of aliasing occur, one must use Leoppky, Bingham, and Sitter's priority of effects to determine the worst amount of aliasing present. This means that any CN interaction bumps that priority up by 0.5; and the word length is obtained by summing each side of the aliasing string. The table below finds the sums for each aliasing type found in the word 23578. Since lower sums indicate worse aliasing, this word has the worst-case aliasing of length 4. It is important to understand that in an FFD the differentiation between control and noise would not be taken into account, and this word would be of length 5; but RPDs are concerned with this distinction and even though the word appears to be length 5, design criteria determines priority 4. Now, assume design D1 contains only the word just analyzed (23578). If D1 was compared to D2, and the worst-case aliasing found in D2 was priority 3.5, then D1 would be the better design. If, however, the worst-case aliasing of D2 was priority 4, then minimum aberration must be taken into consideration. For each design, we would calculate the frequencies of each type of worst-case aliasing. The better design would be chosen as the design that minimizes the occurrence of worst-case aliasing. These frequencies can be organized using the extended word length pattern (EWLP). For any two 2 (m1+m2 )-(p1+p2) fractional factorial robust parameter designs, D1 and D2, we say that D1 has less aberration than D2 if there exists an r such that, B i (D1) = B i (D2) for all i and B r (D1) r (D2) . If no other design has less aberration than D1, then D1 is the minimum aberration fractional factorial robust parameter design. Leoppky, Bingham, and Sitter (2006) also provide the RPD indicator function as: For a given design, D, and a run, x∈D , define a contrast X L(x) = Π l∈L x l on D, where L ∈ P and P is the set of all subsets of {1, 2, ..., m} . Further, define P C to be the set of all subsets of {1, 2,..., m} and P N to be the set of all subset of {1, 2, ..., m} , where an element of P is of the form L ≡ J ∪ K where J ∈ P C and K ∈ P N . Let F be a robust parameter design with indicator function F(x)= Σ J∈PC Σ K∈PN b J∪K X J∪K (x) , if b J∪K ≠ 0 , then X J∪K is a word of the design F with word length r + (1- |b J∪K ⁄ b 0 |) / 2 , where |b J∪K ⁄ b 0 | is a measure of the degree of confounding for the word X J∪K . Further let g r+l / 2t be the number of words of length (r+l / 2t) , where r = 2.0, 2.5, 3.0, ... according to Table 2.1. Thus, the robust parameter design extended word length pattern is (g 2.0 ,...,g 2.0+((t-1)) ⁄ 2t ,...,g m-1 ,...,g m+(t-1) ⁄ 2t ) . Consider designs D1 and D2 with the following EWLPs: D1: [(0 0 3)(2 3 1)(2 5 5)] D2: [(0 0 3)(2 4 0)(2 4 6)] One can read an EWLP from left to right since the left side indicates the most serious level of aliasing, and the aliasing becomes less serious as we move to the right. D2 is the better design because there is one more occurrence of more serious aliasing than in D1.

Uses and examples

Design of experiments (DOE) is a fundamental part of experimentation, modeling, and simulation. Banks states, "Experimental design is concerned with reducing the time and effort associated with simulating by identifying the information needed to be gathered from each simulation replication, how many replications need to be made, and what model parameter changes need to be compared." After a conceptual model has been implemented as a programmed model, DOE is necessary to perform experimentation and obtain simulation results in the most timely and cost-efficient manner. The following examples demonstrate situations where RPDs can be used to draw significant conclusions.

Analyzing

Because RPDs relate so closely to FFDs, the same analysis methods can be applied. ANOVA can be used to determine which factors are significant. Center points can be run to determine if curvature is present. Many statistics software packages have split-plot designs stored and ready for analysis. RPDs are screening designs and are often used to reduce the number of factors that are thought to have an effect on the response.

References

Further reading

Box, G.E.P., (1988), Signal-to-Noise Ratios, Performance Criteria, and Transformations (with discussion), Technometrics, 30 1-40. Box, G.E.P., Hunter, W.G., and Hunter, J.S. (1978), Statistics for Experimenters. Wiley. Castillo, E. (2007), Process Optimization: A Statistical Approach. Springer. Deng, L.Y. and Tang, B. (1999), Generalized Resolution and Minimum Aberration Criteria for Plackett-Burman and Other Non-regular Factorial Designs, Statistica Sinica, 9 1071-1082. Deng, L.Y. and Tang, B. (2002), Design Selection and Classification for Hadamard Matrices Using Generalized Minimum Aberration Criteria, Technometrics, 44 173-184. Lawson, J. and Erjavec, J. (2001), Modern Statistics for Engineering and Quality Improvement. Duxbury. Loeppky, J. (2004), Ranking Non-Regular Designs. Dissertation, Simon Fraser University. Novosad, S. and Ingram, D. (2006), Optimal Non-regular Designs that Provide Alternative to the 16-Run and 32-Run Regular Fractional Factorial Designs. Arkansas State University, State University, AR. Pistone, G. and Wynn, H.P. (1996), Generalized Confounding with Gröbner Bases, Biometrika, 83 653-666. Taguchi, G. (1986), Introduction to Quality Engineering. New York: Quality Resources. Tang, B. and Deng. L.Y. (1999), Minimum G2-aberration for Non-regular Fractional Factorial Designs, The Annals of Statistics, 27 1914-1926. Wiley, A. and Ingram, D. (2007), Uncovering the Complex Aliasing Patterns of Some Non-regular Designs. Senior Honors Thesis, Arkansas State University, State University, AR.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1374376766 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Provenance

snapshot robust-parameter-design-829209-9a49b16c9db60d63 · hash 9a49b16c9db60d63fd33f38c0a4d2a0e1eb72194f77a466ea02a55db7737efbe · captured 1789141100.0 · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “Robust Parameter Design”, snapshot robust-parameter-design-829209-9a49b16c9db60d63. https://encyclopegia.org/a/robust-parameter-design

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.