Screams Without Words
On December 28, 2023, The New York Times published an exposé entitled " Screams Without Words': How Hamas Weaponized Sexual Violence on Oct. 7" on rape and sexual violence during the October 7 attacks and Gaza war, describing such violence…
≈ 8 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
On December 28, 2023, The New York Times published an exposé entitled " Screams Without Words': How Hamas Weaponized Sexual Violence on Oct. 7" on rape and sexual violence during the October 7 attacks and Gaza war, describing such violence as having been "weaponized" by Hamas. The investigative team, led by Times staffer Jeffrey Gettleman and including Israeli freelancers Adam Sella and Anat Schwartz, spent October to December 2023 collecting video footage, photographs, GPS data from mobile phones and interviews from more than 150 people, and concluded that sexual assaults and mutilations of Israeli women and girls were carried out in least seven locations on 7 October.
Critics of the piece have described it as atrocity propaganda. In February 2024, Jeremy Scahill, Ryan Grim, and Daniel Boguslaw published "Between the Hammer and the Anvil" in The Intercept, which called into question the journalistic practices that went into the making the piece as well as the qualifications and motivations of Anat Schwartz, an Israeli filmmaker who contributed to the piece.
The editorial process behind the article was criticized, with concerns raised including the use of inexperienced reporters, an overreliance on witness testimony, weak corroboration, and a lack of supporting forensic evidence. The Times stood by its story, saying that it was "rigorously reported, sourced and edited". |- style="vertical-align:top; background:lavenderblush;" | colspan="2" |4 ZAKA emergency responders |Reported discovering corpses of women at the festival with their legs spread and underwear missing, some with hands tied by rope and zipties.
Jamal Waraki of ZAKA said he saw a dead woman bent over half naked with her underwear rolled down between her knees. |Note: The Intercept reported that Anat Schwartz had "extensive conversations" with ZAKA members such as Yossi Landau, whom it said she relied on for accounts of some of the bodies of women claimed to have been found with signs of sexual violence. The Intercept adds that ZAKA and Landau have been documented to have mishandled evidence and spread multiple false stories about the events of October 7, including debunked allegations of Hamas operatives beheading babies and cutting the fetus from a pregnant woman's body, and that its workers are not trained forensic scientists or crime scene experts, but that these shortcomings are not mentioned by the NYT article. |- style="vertical-align:top;" |Yinon Rivlin |Rave producer |Reported finding the body of a young woman on her stomach with no pants or underwear, legs spread apart with her vagina sliced open | |- style="vertical-align:top;" ! colspan="4" |Be'eri massacre |- style="vertical-align:top;" | colspan="2" |8 ZAKA volunteer medics, 2 soldiers | Reported seeing at least 24 bodies of females naked or half naked, some mutilated, others tied up, in Be'eri and Kfar Aza | Also in ARCCI report, February 2024. |- style="vertical-align:top; background:lavenderblush;" | colspan="2" |Unnamed Unit 669 paramedic ("Sgt. G") |Reported finding the bodies of girls, 13 and 16, one with boxer shorts ripped, bruises by her groin, one with pajama pants pulled to her knees, bottom exposed, semen smeared on her back.
No photos or forensic evidence were taken at the scene, as he was searching for survivors. |Other account: A November 18, 2023, CNN report quoted witness "G", a Unit 669 paramedic, stating that he had found 2 dead teenage girls together in a Be'eri house, one with pants pulled down and semen on her back. Notes: The Intercept examined the Israeli government's list of the victims who died at Kibbutz Be'eri as well as the community's memorial page.
They found the victims in Be'eri matching the description of the New York Times reporting to be sisters Y. and N. Sharabi, aged 13 and 16. When asked about claims of rape made by the New York Times, spokesperson for Kibbutz Be'eri Michal Paikin said: "You're talking about the Sharabi girls? [...]
No, they just — they were shot. I'm saying 'just,' but they were shot and were not subjected to sexual abuse." Paikin also contested graphic claims of rape and sexual violence provided by the paramedic, who served as the source for the allegation and was also published in the Washington Post, CNN, and other outlets.
"It's not true," she told The Intercept, referring to the paramedic's claims about the girls. "They were not sexually abused." |- style="vertical-align:top;" ! colspan="4" | IDF bases |- style="vertical-align:top; background:lavenderblush;" |Shari Mendes |Shura base, reservist |Reported seeing four bodies with signs of sexual violence including blood in their pelvic areas as she prepared bodies for burial. |Note: The Intercept reported that Mendes became a prominent figure in Israeli government and media narratives on October 7 sexual violence "despite the fact that she has no medical or forensic credentials to legally determine rape".
The Intercept also questioned Mendes' credibility based on a testimony she gave to the Daily Mail in October 2023 of what she had seen, including: "A baby was cut out of a pregnant woman and beheaded and then the mother was beheaded." The official Israeli list of those killed in the attacks did not list a pregnant woman. |- style="vertical-align:top;" |Captain Maayan |Shura base, medical forensic team member |Reported seeing at least 10 bodies of female soldiers with signs of sexual violence, including cuts in their vagina, underwear soaked in blood, and in one case, missing fingernails. | style=" | |}
Call for external investigation
On 29 April 2024, more than 50 tenured journalism professors signed a letter calling on the New York Times to "immediately commission a group of journalism experts to conduct a thorough and full independent review of the reporting, editing and publishing processes for 'Screams Without Words' and release a report of the findings." Shahan Mufti, a professor at the University of Richmond, told The National that the statement's aim was to prompt the NYT to "eventually concede that there are problems with the story and retract it or at least correct it" after the publication had so far been "digging its heels deeper and deeper".
Mufti said that it was all the more important given the high stakes of the piece in light of the ICJ discussion of plausible genocide and UN agency warnings of man-made famine. In response, the Times reiterated confidence in the article's quality.
Contributor boycott
In October 2025, over 300 contributors to The New York Times announced a boycott of the newspaper's opinion section, citing concerns over its coverage of the Gaza war and specifically calling for the retraction of the 2024 investigative report 'Screams Without Words.' The open letter signed by the contributors stated that the report had been "debunked," arguing that it relied heavily on unnamed sources, contained unverifiable stories, and included contradictory statements from some of the family members of alleged victims.
The signatories likened the controversy surrounding the report to the Times 2004 misreporting on Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction, suggesting a pattern of publishing unverified claims that support U.S. and Israeli government narratives. The boycott letter accompanying these demands also urged The New York Times editorial board to adopt new standards for covering Israel and Palestine and to use its influence to call for an American arms embargo on Israel, asserting that such action was necessary to bring about a lasting ceasefire.
See also
List of The New York Times controversies
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376564772 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.