Sensitivity auditing

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 4 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Sensitivity auditing is an extension of sensitivity analysis for use in policy-relevant modelling studies. Its use is recommended - i.a. in the European Commission Impact assessment guidelines and by the European Science Academies - when a sensitivity analysis (SA) of a model-based study is meant to demonstrate the robustness of the evidence provided by the model in the context whereby the inference feeds into a policy or decision-making process.

Sensitivity auditing is an extension of sensitivity analysis for use in policy-relevant modelling studies. Its use is recommended - i.a. in the European Commission Impact assessment guidelines and by the European Science Academies - when a sensitivity analysis (SA) of a model-based study is meant to demonstrate the robustness of the evidence provided by the model in the context whereby the inference feeds into a policy or decision-making process.

Approach

In settings where scientific work feeds into policy, the framing of the analysis, its institutional context, and the motivations of its author may become highly relevant, and a pure SA - with its focus on quantified uncertainty - may be insufficient. The emphasis on the framing may, among other things, derive from the relevance of the policy study to different constituencies that are characterized by different norms and values, and hence by a different story about `what the problem is' and foremost about `who is telling the story'. Most often the framing includes implicit assumptions, which could be political (e.g. which group needs to be protected) all the way to technical (e.g. which variable can be treated as a constant). In order to take these concerns into due consideration, sensitivity auditing extends the instruments of sensitivity analysis to provide an assessment of the entire knowledge- and model-generating process. It takes inspiration from NUSAP, a method used to communicate the quality of quantitative information with the generation of `Pedigrees' of numbers. Likewise, sensitivity auditing has been developed to provide pedigrees of models and model-based inferences. Sensitivity auditing is especially suitable in an adversarial context, where not only the nature of the evidence, but also the degree of certainty and uncertainty associated to the evidence, is the subject of partisan interests. These are the settings considered in Post-normal science or in Mode 2 science. Post-normal science (PNS) is a concept developed by Silvio Funtowicz and Jerome Ravetz, which proposes a methodology of inquiry that is appropriate when “facts are uncertain, values in dispute, stakes high and decisions urgent” (Funtowicz and Ravetz, 1992: 251–273). Mode 2 Science, coined in 1994 by Gibbons et al., refers to a mode of production of scientific knowledge that is context-driven, problem-focused and interdisciplinary. Sensitivity auditing consists of a seven-point checklist: 1. Use Math Wisely: Ask if complex math is being used when simpler math could do the job. Check if the model is being stretched beyond its intended use. 2. Look for Assumptions: Find out what assumptions were made in the study, and see if they were clearly stated or hidden. 3. Avoid Garbage In, Garbage Out: Check if the data used in the model were manipulated to make the results look more certain than they really are, or if they were made overly uncertain to avoid regulation. 4. Prepare for Criticism: It's better to find problems in your study before others do. Do robust checks for uncertainty and sensitivity before publishing. 5. Be Transparent: Don't keep your model a secret. Make it clear and understandable to the public. 6. Focus on the Right Problem: Ensure your model is addressing the correct issue and not just solving a problem that isn't really there. 7. Do Thorough Analyses: Conduct in-depth tests to measure uncertainty and sensitivity using the best methods available.

References

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1317153919 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Provenance

snapshot enwiki-001317153919 · captured 1760627373.0 · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “Sensitivity auditing”, snapshot enwiki-001317153919. https://encyclopegia.org/a/sensitivity-auditing

Sources cited in this revision

Extracted from the cited revision's reference blocks; absent citations are not invented.