Small clause
≈ 8 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In linguistics, a small clause consists of a subject and its predicate, but lacks an overt expression of tense. Small clauses have the semantic subject-predicate characteristics of a clause, and have some, but not all, properties of a syntactic constituent. Structural analyses of small clauses vary according to whether a flat or layered analysis is pursued. The small clause is also related to the phenomena of raising-to-object, exceptional case-marking, accusativus cum infinitivo, and object control.
In linguistics, a small clause consists of a subject and its predicate, but lacks an overt expression of tense. Small clauses have the semantic subject-predicate characteristics of a clause, and have some, but not all, properties of a syntactic constituent. Structural analyses of small clauses vary according to whether a flat or layered analysis is pursued. The small clause is also related to the phenomena of raising-to-object, exceptional case-marking, accusativus cum infinitivo, and object control. I consider [ John very stupid ] I expect [ that sailor off my ship ] We feared [ John killed by the enemy ] I saw [ John come to the kitchen ]
Structural analyses
Broadly speaking, there are three competing analyses of the structure of small clauses. the flat structure analysis treats the subject and predicate of the small clause as sister constituents the layered structure analysis treats the subject and predicate as a single "small clause" (SC) constituent the X-bar theory analysis treats the subject and predicate as a single constituent projected from the head of the small clause, which may be V, N, A, or P (with some analyses having additional functional structure) I regard Fred as insane. I consider Fred as my best friend. Some have taken this as evidence that this structure does not adequately portray the structure of a small clause, and that a better structure must include some intermediate projection that combines the subject and the predicate which would assign a head to the constituent. Mayor Shinn considered Eulalie [ AP talented ] and [ NP a tyrant ] Mayor Shinn considered [ PrP Eulalie [ Pr' (P) [ AP talented ]] and [ Pr' (P) [ NP a tyrant ]] This structure answers the question of the category of the word as in small clause constructions such as I regard Fred as my best friend. This structure was an issue if as is analyzed as a preposition, as prepositions do not take adjective phrase complements. However, analyzing as as the overt realization of the Pr head is consistent with X-bar theory. Additionally, some have theorized that a combination of the three structures can illustrate why the subjects of verbal small clauses and adjectival small clauses seem to behave differently, as noted by Basilico: The prisoner seems/appears to be intelligent. The prisoner seems/appears intelligent. The prisoner seems/appears to leave every day at noon. * The prisoner seems/appears leave every day at noon. Here, examples (13) and (14) show that the subject of an adjectival small clause — with our without copular be — can raise to the matrix subject position. However, with a verbal clause, omission of infinitival to leads to ungrammatically, as shown by the contrast between the well-formed (15) and the ill-formed (16), where the asterisk (*) marks ungrammaticality. From this evidence, some linguists have theorized that the subjects of adjectival and verbal small clauses must differ in syntactic position. This conclusion is bolstered by the knowledge that verbal and adjectival small clauses differ in their predication forms. While adjectival small clauses involve categorical predication where the predicate ascribes a property to the subject, verbal small clauses involve thetic predications where an event that the subject is participating in is reported. Basilico uses this to argue that a small clause should be analyzed as a Topic Phrase, which is projected from the predicate head (the Topic), with the subject introduced as the specifier of the Topic Phrase. In this way, he argues that in an adjectival small clause, the predicate is formed for an individual topic, and in a verbal small clause the events form a predicate of events for a stage topic, which accounts for why verbal small clauses cannot be raised to the matrix subject position. I consider [ Mary smart ] I consider [ Mary my best friend ] I consider [ Mary out of her mind ] The small clause examples in (17) to (19) contrast with the examples in (20) to (22), with the critical difference being the inclusion of the copular verb be preceded by infinitival to: I consider [ Mary to be smart ] I consider [ Mary to be my best friend ] I consider [ Mary to be out of her mind ] In some analyses the presence of the copular verb and tense (infinitival to) makes the bolded portions a full clause rather than a small clause. However, other analyses treat infinitival clauses as a kind of small clause. The latter approach proposes that small clauses lack inflected tense but can have a bare infinitival verb. Under this theory, NP VP constructions are allowed. The following examples contrast small clauses with non-finite verbs with main clauses with finite verbs. They think that they are ready to leave. *They think that they are ready left. They think that they must leave. The asterisk here represents that the sentence (24) is generally held to be ungrammatical by native English speakers. I consider [ Mr. Nyman a genius ]. *I consider [ Mr. Nyman in my shed ]. Example (18) is ungrammatical as the verb "consider" does take an NP complement, but not a PP complement. However, this theory of selectional requirement is also disputed, as substitution of different small clauses can create grammatical readings. Both examples (28) and (29) take PP complements, yet (28) is grammatical but (29) is not. I consider [ the team in no fit state to play ]. *I consider [ my friends on the roof ]. The matrix verb's selection of case also supports the theory that the matrix verb's selectional requirements affect small clause licensing. The verb consider in (30) marks accusative case on the subject NP of the small clause. This conclusion is supported by pronoun-substitution, where the accusative caseform is grammatical (31), but the nominative case form is not (32). I consider [ Natasha a visionary ]. I consider [ her a visionary ]. *I consider [ she a visionary ]. In Serbo-Croatian, the verb smatrati 'to consider' selects for accusative case for its subject argument and instrumental case as its complement argument. *The doctor considers [ that patient dead tomorrow ]. Our pilot considers [ that island off our route ]. Some small clauses that appear to be ungrammatical can be well-formed given the appropriate context. This suggests that the semantic relation of the main verb and the small clause affects sentences' grammaticality. *I consider [ John off my ship ]. As soon as he sets foot on the gangplank, I'll consider [ John off my ship ]. I consider [ Rome not a good choice ]. *I consider [ Rome might not a good choice ]. He considers [ Maria wise ] and [ Jane talented ]. She considers [ John a tyrant ] and [ Martin a clown ]. [ Bill behind the wheel ] is a scary thought. - Small clause functioning as subject [ Sam drunk ] is something everyone wants to avoid. - Small clause functioning as subject Most theories of syntax judge subjects to be single constituents, hence the small clauses Bill behind the wheel and Sam drunk here should each be construed as one constituent. Concerning small clauses in subject position, see Culicover, Haegeman and Guéron. With [ Bill behind the wheel ], we're in trouble. - Small clause as complement of with With [ Sam drunk ], we've got a big problem. - Small clause as complement of with These data are also easier to accommodate if the small clause is a constituent. *[ Lots of books dirty ] is a common problem in libraries. [ Lots of books dirty from mistreatment ] is a common problem in libraries. A second argument is coordination tests make incorrect predictions about constituency, particularly regarding small clauses. This casts doubt upon the status of small clauses as constituents. Louis gave [a book to Marie yesterday] and [a painting to Barbara the day before]. Another counterexample of constituency looks at depictive secondary predicates. They sponged [ the water up ]. One school of thought argues that this example has [the water up] behaving as a constituent small clause, while another school of thought argues that the verb "sponge" does not select for a small clause, and that the water up semantically, but not syntactically, shows the resultative state of the verb.
Cross-linguistic variation
Expressive exclamatives
See also
Balancing and deranking Constituent Constituent order Dependency grammar Exceptional case-marking Information structure Phrase structure grammar Raising Subcategorization
References
Literature
Aarts, B. 1992. Small clauses in English: the non-verbal types. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Borsley, R. 1991. Syntactic theory: A unified approach. London: Edward Arnold. Chomsky, N. 1981. Lectures on government and binding: The Pisa lectures. Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter. Chomsky, N. 1986. Barriers. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Culicover, P. 1997. Principles and parameters: An introduction to syntactic theory. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Culicover, P. and R. Jackendoff. 2005. Simpler syntax. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Haegeman, L. 1994. Introduction to government and binding theory, 2nd edition. Oxford, UK: Blackwell. Haegeman, L. and J. Guéron 1999. English grammar: A generative perspective. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishers. Matthews, P. 2007. Syntactic relations: A critical survey. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Ouhalla, J. 1994. Transformational grammar: From rules to principles and parameters. London: Edward Arnold. Wardhaugh, R. 2003. Understanding English grammar, second edition. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1343101648 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.