Spin glass
In condensed matter physics, a spin glass is a magnetic state characterized by randomness, despite cooperative behavior in freezing of spins at a temperature called the "freezing temperature," T f .
≈ 15 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In condensed matter physics, a spin glass is a magnetic state characterized by randomness, despite cooperative behavior in freezing of spins at a temperature called the "freezing temperature," T f . In ferromagnetic solids, component atoms' magnetic spins all align in the same direction. When contrasted with a ferromagnet, a spin glass is defined as a "disordered" magnetic state in which spins are aligned and coupled without a regular pattern.
A spin glass should not be confused with a "spin-on glass." The latter is a thin film which is applied via spin coating, and is usually based on SiO 2 . The term "glass" comes from an analogy between the magnetic disorder in a spin glass and the positional disorder of a conventional, chemical glass (e.g., a window glass).
In any amorphous solid, such as window glass, the atomic bond structure is highly irregular; in contrast, a crystal has a uniform pattern of atomic bonds. In ferromagnetic solids, magnetic spins all align in the same direction; this is analogous to a crystal's lattice-based structure.
The individual atomic bonds in a spin glass are a mixture of roughly equal numbers of ferromagnetic bonds (where neighbors have the same orientation) and antiferromagnetic bonds (where neighbors have exactly the opposite orientation, where north and south poles are flipped 180 degrees).…
In condensed matter physics, a spin glass is a magnetic state characterized by randomness, despite cooperative behavior in freezing of spins at a temperature called the "freezing temperature," T f . In ferromagnetic solids, component atoms' magnetic spins all align in the same direction. When contrasted with a ferromagnet, a spin glass is defined as a "disordered" magnetic state in which spins are aligned and coupled without a regular pattern.
A spin glass should not be confused with a "spin-on glass." The latter is a thin film which is applied via spin coating, and is usually based on SiO 2 . The term "glass" comes from an analogy between the magnetic disorder in a spin glass and the positional disorder of a conventional, chemical glass (e.g., a window glass).
In any amorphous solid, such as window glass, the atomic bond structure is highly irregular; in contrast, a crystal has a uniform pattern of atomic bonds. In ferromagnetic solids, magnetic spins all align in the same direction; this is analogous to a crystal's lattice-based structure.
The individual atomic bonds in a spin glass are a mixture of roughly equal numbers of ferromagnetic bonds (where neighbors have the same orientation) and antiferromagnetic bonds (where neighbors have exactly the opposite orientation, where north and south poles are flipped 180 degrees). These patterns of aligned and misaligned atomic magnets create what are known as frustrated interactions distortions in the geometry of atomic bonds compared to what would be seen in a regular, fully aligned solid.
They may also create situations where more than one geometric arrangement of atoms is stable. There are two main aspects of spin glass. On the physical side, spin glasses are real materials with distinctive properties, a review of which was published in 19821.
On the mathematical side, models from statistical mechanics inform the study of both real spin glasses and analogous systems (e.g., human social systems). Spin glasses and the complex internal structures that arise within them are termed "metastable" because they are "stuck" in stable configurations other than the lowest-energy configuration (which would be aligned and ferromagnetic).
While difficult, the study of spin glasses has yielded valuable results in fields outside of physics, including chemistry, computer science and neural networks, pure mathematics, complex systems science, and even sociology.
Magnetic behavior
The key methods of determining whether a material is a spin glass are rooted in its magnetic behavior. Because of the underlying disordered structure of the magnetic moments, a spin glass is expected to exhibit a unique combination of features.
A list of necessary criteria is proposed by Mydosh in a review paper: The ac susceptibility \chi_\mathrm{ac} = \chi' + i\chi = \frac{\partial M}{\partial B_{ac}} is the response of the spin glass to an alternating magnetic field. It consists of an (reactive) in-phase component \chi' and an (absorptive) out-of-phase component \chi .
The expectation for a spin glass is that \chi(T) peaks sharply at the freezing temperature T_f . It is, furthermore expected that the freezing temperature is only weakly dependent on the excitation frequency. An explanation for this is that during the freezing process, the fluctuations lead to a slowing down of the spin dynamics and thus a higher absorption \chi .
The temperature dependent magnetization M(T) in the frozen state must depend on the magnetic history: A pronounced splitting between the magnetization in heating must occur where a constant M is expected up to T_f when the sample was cooled across the transition in a magnetic field (so called field cooled FC). This is opposed to a field-free cooling and application of the magnetic field only in the frozen state (zero-field cooling ZFC).
Underlying this is that the glass is frozen into a (partially) magnetized state in a FC protocol. The magnetic specific heat c_m shows a broad, field-dependent maximum at T_f , whereas it is sharp at the transition to an ordered state (like a ferro- or antiferromagnet). Because spin glasses are based on disorder, there is a decay of the magnetized state, it ages.
This means that a zero-field cooled magnetized state will decay back into an unmagnetized one. There will be a maximum in the quantity S(t) = (1/H)\frac{\partial M}{\partial \ln t} . Above the spin glass transition temperature, T c , the spin glass exhibits typical magnetic behaviour (such as paramagnetism).
If a magnetic field is applied as the sample is cooled to the transition temperature, magnetization of the sample increases as described by the Curie law. Surprisingly, the sum of the two complicated functions of time (the zero-field-cooled and remanent magnetizations) is a constant, namely the field-cooled value, and thus both share identical functional forms with time, at least in the limit of very small external fields.
Edwards–Anderson model
The Edwards-Anderson model is similar to the Ising model, in which spins are arranged on a d -dimensional lattice with only nearest neighbor interactions. Critical temperatures can be solved for exactly and a glassy phase is observed to exist at low temperatures.
The Hamiltonian for this spin system is given by H = -\sum_{\langle ij\rangle} J_{ij} S_i S_j, where S_i refers to the Pauli spin matrix for the spin-half particle at lattice point i and the sum over \langle ij\rangle includes all nearest-neighbor lattice points i and j . The variables J_{ij} characterize the magnetic interactions between neighboring spins and are called bond or link variables. The interaction is antiferromagnetic for negative J_{ij} and ferromagnetic for positive J_{ij} .
In order to determine the partition function for this system, one needs to average the free energy f\left[J_{ij}\right] = -\frac{1}{\beta} \ln\mathcal{Z}\left[J_{ij}\right] where \mathcal{Z}\left[J_{ij}\right] = \operatorname{Tr}_S \left(e^{-\beta H}\right) , over all possible values of J_{ij} . The distribution of values of J_{ij} is taken to be a Gaussian with a mean J_0 and a variance J^2 : P(J_{ij}) = \sqrt{\frac{N}{2\pi J^2}} \exp\left\{-\frac N {2J^2} \left(J_{ij} - \frac{J_0}{N}\right)^2\right\}.
For the +J and -J random-bond Ising model, in which nearest-neighbor couplings take the values +J and -J with probabilities p and 1 - p, the Nishimori line is the locus in the temperature-disorder phase diagram satisfying \exp(-2\beta J)=(1-p)/p . On this line, gauge transformations give exact results such as the internal energy, making it one of the few exactly controlled cases of finite-dimensional spin-glass models. In information-processing applications, Nishimori used related spin-glass methods to show that, for certain error-correcting code ensembles, the decoding error can be minimized at a finite decoding temperature matched to the channel noise.
Iba later discussed the Nishimori line from the viewpoint of Bayesian statistics. Solving for the free energy using the replica method, below a certain temperature, a new magnetic phase called the spin glass phase (or glassy phase) of the system is found to exist which is characterized by a vanishing magnetization m = 0 along with a non-vanishing value of the two point correlation function between spins at the same lattice point but at two different replicas: q = \sum_{i=1}^N S^\alpha_i S^\beta_i \neq 0, where \alpha, \beta are replica indices.
The order parameter for the ferromagnetic to spin glass phase transition is therefore q , and that for paramagnetic to spin glass is again q . Hence the new set of order parameters describing the three magnetic phases consists of both m and q . Under the assumption of replica symmetry, the mean-field free energy is given by the expression: \begin{align} \beta f ={} - \frac{\beta^2 J^2}{4}(1 - q)^2 + \frac{\beta J_0 m^2}{2} - \int \exp\left( -\frac{z^2} 2 \right) \log \left(2\cosh\left(\beta Jz + \beta J_0 m\right)\right) \, \mathrm{d}z. \end{align}
Sherrington–Kirkpatrick model
In addition to unusual experimental properties, spin glasses are the subject of extensive theoretical and computational investigations. A substantial part of early theoretical work on spin glasses dealt with a form of mean-field theory based on a set of replicas of the partition function of the system.
An important, exactly solvable model of a spin glass was introduced by David Sherrington and Scott Kirkpatrick in 1975. It is an Ising model with long range frustrated ferro- as well as antiferromagnetic couplings. It corresponds to a mean-field approximation of spin glasses describing the slow dynamics of the magnetization and the complex non-ergodic equilibrium state.
Unlike the Edwards–Anderson (EA) model, the range of each spin-spin interaction can be arbitrarily large (not restricted to neighboring sites). Any two spins can be linked with a ferromagnetic or an antiferromagnetic bond; the distribution of these bonds is the same as in the EA model.
The SK Hamiltonian is H = - \frac 1\sqrt N \sum_{i where J_{ij}, S_i, S_j have same meanings as in the EA model. The equilibrium solution of the model, after initial attempts by Sherrington, Kirkpatrick and others, was found by Giorgio Parisi in 1979 using the replica method.
The subsequent work interpreting the Parisi solution—by M. Mezard, G. Parisi, M.A. Virasoro and many others—revealed the complex nature of glassy, low-temperature phases, characterized by ergodicity breaking, ultrametricity and non-selfaverageness. Further developments led to the creation of the cavity method, which allowed study of the low-temperature phase without replicas.
A rigorous proof of the Parisi solution has been provided in the work of Francesco Guerra and Michel Talagrand. , the energy function becomes H = - \frac 1\sqrt N \sum_{i Let all couplings J_{ij} are IID samples from the gaussian distribution of mean 0 and variance J^2 . In 1979, J.R.L. de Almeida and David Thouless found that, as in the case of the Ising model, the mean-field solution to the SK model becomes unstable when under low-temperature, low-magnetic field state.
The stability region on the phase diagram of the SK model is determined by two dimensionless parameters x := \frac{kT}{J}, \quad y := \frac{M}{J} . Its phase diagram has two parts, divided by the de Almeida-Thouless curve, The curve is the solution set to the equations \begin{aligned} & x^2 = \frac{1}{(2 \pi)^{1 / 2}} \int \mathrm{d} z\; \mathrm{e}^{-\frac 12 z^2} \operatorname{sech}^4\left(\frac{q^{1 / 2} z + y}{x}\right), \\ & q=\frac{1}{(2 \pi)^{1 / 2}} \int \mathrm{d} z\; \mathrm{e}^{-\frac{1}{2} z^2} \tanh ^2\left(\frac{q^{1 / 2} z + y}{x}\right) . \end{aligned} The phase transition occurs at x = 1 .
Just below it, we have y^2 \approx \frac 43 ( 1-x)^3. At low temperature, high magnetic field limit, the line is x \approx \frac{4}{3\sqrt{2\pi}} e^{-\frac 12 y^2}
Infinite-range model
This is also called the "p-spin model". The infinite-range model is a generalization of the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick model where we not only consider two-spin interactions but p -spin interactions, where p \leq N and N is the total number of spins. Unlike the Edwards–Anderson model, but similar to the SK model, the interaction range is infinite.
The Hamiltonian for this model is described by: H = -\sum_{i_1 where J_{i_1\dots i_p}, S_{i_1},\dots, S_{i_p} have similar meanings as in the EA model. The p\to \infty limit of this model is known as the random energy model.
In this limit, the probability of the spin glass existing in a particular state depends only on the energy of that state and not on the individual spin configurations in it. A Gaussian distribution of magnetic bonds across the lattice is assumed usually to solve this model. Any other distribution is expected to give the same result, as a consequence of the central limit theorem.
The Gaussian distribution function, with mean \frac{J_0}{N} and variance \frac{J^2}{N} , is given as: P\left(J_{i_1\cdots i_p}\right) = \sqrt{\frac{N^{p-1}}{J^2 \pi p!}} \exp\left\{-\frac{N^{p-1}}{J^2 p!} \left(J_{i_1 \cdots i_p} - \frac{J_0 p!}{2N^{p-1}}\right)\right\} The order parameters for this system are given by the magnetization m and the two point spin correlation between spins at the same site q , in two different replicas, which are the same as for the SK model. This infinite range model can be solved explicitly for the free energy in terms of m and q , under the assumption of replica symmetry as well as 1-Replica Symmetry Breaking. \begin{align} \beta f ={} &\frac{1}{4}\beta^2 J^2 q^p - \frac{1}{2}p\beta^2 J^2 q^p - \frac{1}{4}\beta^2 J^2 + \frac{1}{2}\beta J_0 p m^p + \frac{1}{4\sqrt{2\pi}}p\beta^2 J^2 q^{p-1} +{} \\ &\int \exp\left(-\frac{1}{2}z^2\right) \log\left(2\cosh\left(\beta Jz \sqrt{\frac{1}{2}pq^{p-1}} + \frac{1}{2}\beta J_0 p m^{p-1}\right)\right)\, \mathrm{d}z \end{align}
Non-ergodic behavior and applications
A thermodynamic system is ergodic when, given any (equilibrium) instance of the system, it eventually visits every other possible (equilibrium) state (of the same energy). One characteristic of spin glass systems is that, below the freezing temperature T_\text{f} , instances are trapped in a "non-ergodic" set of states: the system may fluctuate between several states, but cannot transition to other states of equivalent energy.
Intuitively, one can say that the system cannot escape from deep minima of the hierarchically disordered energy landscape; the distances between minima are given by an ultrametric, with tall energy barriers between minima. The participation ratio counts the number of states that are accessible from a given instance, that is, the number of states that participate in the ground state.
The ergodic aspect of spin glass was instrumental in the awarding of half the 2021 Nobel Prize in Physics to Giorgio Parisi. For physical systems, such as dilute manganese in copper, the freezing temperature is typically as low as 30 kelvins (−240 °C), and so the spin-glass magnetism appears to be practically without applications in daily life.
The non-ergodic states and rugged energy landscapes are, however, quite useful in understanding the behavior of certain neural networks, including Hopfield networks, as well as many problems in computer science optimization and genetics.
Spin-glass without structural disorder
Elemental crystalline neodymium is paramagnetic at room temperature and becomes an antiferromagnet with incommensurate order upon cooling below 19.9 K. Below this transition temperature it exhibits a complex set of magnetic phases that have long spin relaxation times and spin-glass behavior that does not rely on structural disorder.
History
A detailed account of the history of spin glasses from the early 1960s to the late 1980s can be found in a series of popular articles by Philip W. Anderson in Physics Today.
See also
Amorphous magnet Antiferromagnetic interaction Cavity method Crystal structure Geometrical frustration Orientational glass Phase transition Quenched disorder Random energy model Replica trick Solid-state physics Spin ice
Literature
. ShieldSquare Captcha . . . .... . .
External links
Statistics of frequency of the term "Spin glass" in arxiv.org
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378465572 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Spin glass” publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL