Lesson plan

Table 2 fallacy

The Table 2 Fallacy is a term coined by Daniel Westreich and Sander Greenland in 2013. It is a concept in causal inference. In scientific papers reporting observational studies, people often report both crude and adjusted associations between variables included in a regression model and the outcome of interest in Table 2. If the purpose of the analysis is causal inference, usually, the variables one would choose to adjust for will differ for each exposure - outcome pairing. The Table 2 Fallacy occurs when people seek to give a causal interpretation to the other parameters estimated using a multivariable regression model that was only designed to explore a single exposure - outcome association. Table 2 Fallacy is a common error made in reporting epidemiological results in a wide range of subject areas. A high profile example was a paper exploring associations between demographic and health characteristics and death from COVID-19, which was used by the French government to define which groups of workers were deemed at risk. A number of letters to the editor argued that the paper wrongly implied that causal interpretations should be given to multiple parameters taken from a single multivariable regression model. This claim was contested by the study authors, who argued that their paper did not make causal claims.

Back to article

Article summary

The Table 2 Fallacy is a term coined by Daniel Westreich and Sander Greenland in 2013. It is a concept in causal inference. In scientific papers reporting observational studies, people often report both crude and adjusted associations between variables included in a regression model and the outcome of interest in Table 2. If the purpose of the analysis is causal inference, usually, the variables one would choose to adjust for will differ for each exposure - outcome pairing. The Table 2 Fallacy occurs when people seek to give a causal interpretation to the other parameters estimated using a multivariable regression model that was only designed to explore a single exposure - outcome association. Table 2 Fallacy is a common error made in reporting epidemiological results in a wide range of subject areas. A high profile example was a paper exploring associations between demographic and health characteristics and death from COVID-19, which was used by the French government to define which groups of workers were deemed at risk. A number of letters to the editor argued that the paper wrongly implied that causal interpretations should be given to multiple parameters taken from a single multivariable regression model. This claim was contested by the study authors, who argued that their paper did not make causal claims.

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.