Teaching reading
≈ 9 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Teaching reading has significant differences between teaching reading for alphabetic languages and for logographic languages.
Teaching reading has significant differences between teaching reading for alphabetic languages and for logographic languages.
For alphabetic languages
Educators have debated for years about which method is best to teach reading for the English language. There are three main methods, phonics, whole language and balanced literacy. There are also a variety of other areas and practices such as phonemic awareness, fluency, reading comprehension, sight words and sight vocabulary, the three-cueing system (the searchlights model in England), guided reading, shared reading, and leveled reading. Each practice is employed in different manners depending on the country and the specific school division. In 2001, some researchers reached two conclusions: 1) "mastering the alphabetic principle is essential" and 2) "instructional techniques (namely, phonics) that teach this principle directly are more effective than those that do not". However, while they make it clear they have some fundamental disagreements with some of the claims made by whole-language advocates, some principles of whole-language have value such as the need to ensure that students are enthusiastic about books and eager to learn to read.
Reading wars: phonics vs. whole language
For decades, the merits of phonics vs. whole language have been debated. It is sometimes referred to as the reading wars. Phonics was a popular way to learn reading in the 19th century. William Holmes McGuffey (1800–1873), an American educator, author, and Presbyterian minister who had a lifelong interest in teaching children, compiled the first four of the McGuffey Readers in 1836. In 1841 Horace Mann, the Secretary of the Massachusetts Board of Education, advocated for a whole-word method of teaching reading to replace phonics. Others advocated for a return to phonics, such as Rudolf Flesch in his book Why Johnny Can't Read (1955). The whole-word method received support from Kenneth J. Goodman who wrote an article in 1967 entitled Reading: A psycholinguistic guessing game. In it, he says efficient reading is the result of the "skill in selecting the fewest, most productive cues necessary to produce guesses which are right the first time". Although not supported by scientific studies, the theory became very influential as the whole language method. At the same time, Marie Clay, the creator of the often criticized Reading recovery program suggested that young readers use "multiple clues from the text" as well as content to read. Since the 1970s some whole language supporters such as Frank Smith, are unyielding in arguing that phonics should be taught little, if at all. Yet, other researchers say instruction in phonics and phonemic awareness are "critically important" and "essential" to developing early reading skills. In 20001, the National Reading Panel (U.S.) identified five ingredients of effective reading instruction, of which phonics is one, and the other four are phonemic awareness, fluency, vocabulary and comprehension. Reports from other countries, such as the Australian report on Teaching reading (2005) and the U.K. Independent review of the teaching of early reading (Rose Report 2006) have also supported the use of phonics. Some notable researchers such as Stanislas Dehaene and Mark Seidenberg have clearly stated their disapproval of whole language. Furthermore, a 2017 study in the UK that compared teaching with phonics vs. teaching whole written words concluded that phonics is more effective, saying "our findings suggest that interventions aiming to improve the accuracy of reading aloud and/or comprehension in the early stages of learning should focus on the systematicity present in print-to-sound relationships, rather than attempting to teach direct access to the meanings of whole written words". More recently, some educators have advocated for the theory of balanced literacy purported to combine phonics and whole language yet not necessarily consistently or systematically. It may include elements such as word study and phonics mini-lessons, differentiated learning, cueing, leveled reading, shared reading, guided reading, independent reading, and sight words. According to a survey in 2010, 68% of K–2 teachers in the United States practice balanced literacy; however, only 52% of teachers included phonics in their definition of balanced literacy. In addition, 75% of teachers teach the three-cueing system (i.e., meaning/structure/visual or semantic/syntactic/graphophonic) that has its roots in whole language. In addition, some phonics supporters assert that balanced literacy is merely whole language by another name. And critics of whole language and sceptics of balanced literacy, such as neuroscientist Mark Seidenberg, state that struggling readers should not be encouraged to skip words they find puzzling or rely on semantic and syntactic cues to guess words. Over time a growing number of countries and states have put greater emphasis on phonics and other evidence-based practices. This has focused attention on Systematic phonics and Structured literacy. (see Phonics practices by country or region).
Tutoring in reading
The use of tutoring to improve academic performance, including reading skills, is increasing. A multi-level study in 2023 about "High-Dosage Tutoring" programs for beginning readers concluded that "a convincing and robust body of research provides evidence that tutoring is an effective intervention to accelerate student learning, particularly for students that perform below academic thresholds". One-to-one tutoring is the most effective intervention for improving the reading achievement of struggling elementary school students, with a medium effect size of 0.41. Small-group tutoring also improves students' literacy, with a small effect size of 0.24. A follow-up study to the NRP concluded that, when added together, the combined effect of systematic phonics instruction (d=.24), effective one-to-one tutoring (d=.40), and systematic language activities (syntax, morphology, and etymology, d=.29) "may triple the effect of phonics alone". Another study suggests that phonologically based reading instruction for first-graders at risk for learning disabilities can be delivered by non-teachers. In the study, non-certified tutors gave students intensive one-to-one tutoring for 30 minutes, 4 days a week for one school year. The students outperformed untutored control students on measures of reading, spelling, and decoding; with effect sizes ranging from .42 to 1.24. The tutoring included instruction in phonological skills, letter-sound correspondence, explicit decoding, rime analysis, writing, spelling, and reading phonetically controlled text. Although the effects diminished at the end of second grade, the tutored students continued to significantly outperform untutored students in decoding and spelling. Robert Slavin, of Best evidence Encyclopedia, says "only tutoring, both one-to-one and one-to-small group, in reading and mathematics, had an effect size larger than +0.10 ... averages are around +0.30", and "well-trained teaching assistants using structured tutoring materials or software can obtain outcomes as good as those obtained by certified teachers as tutors". Other studies conclude that programs using non-teacher tutors can produce reading improvements for first-grade students, if the programs are carefully designed and structured, and tutors receive regular training and supervision. A meta-analysis in 2023 found that so-called high-impact tutoring increased achievement by 3 to 15 months of learning across grade levels, and the best results came from programs that a) use teachers or paraprofessionals as tutors, b) are held in earlier grades, c) occur at least 3 days per week, and d) are held during school. According to a report in January 2026, the San Francisco school district is expanding a tutoring program in which the percentage of participating students reading at grade level increased from 24% to 54%. Not all tutoring programs produce the expected results. This is because, in part, "larger programs tend to have higher student-tutor ratios and less time spent in tutoring than smaller programs". In addition, with larger programs the quality of delivery and implementation is reduced. One study suggests schools should start tutoring programs early rather than wait until students show signs of struggling. However, tutoring programs can cost between $1,000 and $4,000 per student. Many parents seek out private tutors because they are unhappy with the results they see from their child's education system. However, those parents often face challenges when hiring private literacy tutors, including high demand, long waitlists, limited knowledge, a lack of tutors in their area, inadequately trained tutors, and costs. A study in Ontario, Canada, found that many families paid all or part of a psychoeducational assessment outside of the school, at an average cost to the parents of $1,800. In addition, most parents who accessed private tutoring services paid the median cost of $3,500.
For logographic languages
Languages such as Chinese and Japanese are normally written (fully or partly) in logograms (hanzi and kanji, respectively), which represent a whole word or morpheme with a single character. There are a large number of characters, and the sound that each makes must be learned directly or from other characters that contain "hints" in them. For example, in Japanese, the On-reading of the kanji 民 is min and the related kanji 眠 shares the same On-reading, min: the right-hand part shows the character's pronunciation. However, this is not true for all characters. Kun readings, on the other hand, have to be learned and memorized as there is no way to tell from each character. Ruby characters are used in textbooks to help children learn the sounds that each logogram makes. These are written in a smaller size, using an alphabetic or syllabic script. For example, hiragana is typically used in Japanese, and the pinyin romanization into Latin alphabet characters is used in Chinese. | style="padding:0 1.5em" | or || |} The examples above each spell the word kanji, which is made up of two kanji characters: 漢 (kan, written in hiragana as かん), and 字 (ji, written in hiragana as じ). Textbooks are sometimes edited as a cohesive set across grades so that children will not encounter characters they are not yet expected to have learned.
International research reports about best practices
Beginning in 2000, several reading research reports were published, together with their conclusions about the best ways to teach reading:
2000 – National Reading Panel (NRP) (U.S.)
The NRP identified five ingredients of effective reading instruction: phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension and concluded that systematic phonics instruction is more effective than unsystematic phonics instruction or those with no phonics instruction.
2005 – Teaching Reading, National Inquiry into the Teaching of Literacy (Australia 2005-The Rowe Report)
This report supports the use of systematic phonics.
2006 – Independent review of the teaching of early reading (Rose Report 2006) (England)
The Rose Report supports systematic synthetic phonics.
2022 – Right to Read inquiry report (R2R) (Canada)
The R2R report from the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) says that teachers need to be trained in evidence-based instruction methods and concludes that Structured literacy "is the most effective way to teach early reading".
References
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1374853787 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.