Time preference
≈ 8 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In behavioral economics, time preference (or time discounting, delay discounting, temporal discounting, long-term orientation ) is the current relative valuation placed on receiving a good at an earlier date compared with receiving it at a later date. Applications for these preferences include finance, health, and climate change.
Time preferences are captured mathematically in the discount function. The main models of discounting include exponential, hyperbolic, and quasi hyperbolic. The higher the time preference, the higher the discount placed on returns receivable or costs payable in the future.
Several factors correlate with an individual's time preference, including age, income, race, risk, and temptation. On a larger level, ideas such as sign effects, sub-additivity, and the elicitation method can influence how people display time preference. Time preference can also inform wider preferences about real world behavior and attitudes, such as pro-social behavior.
Cultural differences can explain differences in discounting as they both have similar underlying psychological influences. The discount rate is also useful in many fields, such as finance and climate change.
In behavioral economics, time preference (or time discounting, delay discounting, temporal discounting, long-term orientation ) is the current relative valuation placed on receiving a good at an earlier date compared with receiving it at a later date. Applications for these preferences include finance, health, and climate change.
Time preferences are captured mathematically in the discount function. The main models of discounting include exponential, hyperbolic, and quasi hyperbolic. The higher the time preference, the higher the discount placed on returns receivable or costs payable in the future.
Several factors correlate with an individual's time preference, including age, income, race, risk, and temptation. On a larger level, ideas such as sign effects, sub-additivity, and the elicitation method can influence how people display time preference. Time preference can also inform wider preferences about real world behavior and attitudes, such as pro-social behavior.
Cultural differences can explain differences in discounting as they both have similar underlying psychological influences. The discount rate is also useful in many fields, such as finance and climate change.
Example
An individual's time preference can be found in choices between smaller-sooner and larger-later rewards. A person offered $100 today or $110 in one month reveals their discount rate. Choosing the immediate $100, suggests an annual discount rate of at least 10%, whereas indifference of preference for the delayed amount indicates a lower rate.
Psychologists and economists use series of similar questions (money earlier or later or MEL methods) to estimate preferences. In everyday terms, time preferences appear in decisions like whether or not to contribute to a retirement account.
Choosing to not contribute a portion of one's paycheck to a retirement account is a high time preference decision, whereas contributing to said account is a low time preference decision. U^t(c_t, \dots, c_T) = \sum_{k=0}^{T-t} D(k) u(c_{t+k}) where D(k) = \left(\frac{1}{1 + \rho}\right)^k is commonly thought of as the discount function, with \rho being the discount rate.
It says that your value of the future is exponentially less than your value of the present, as scaled by \rho and k . Although the equation was never meant to be normative, ie, making a recommendation as to how people behave, it was the first template for modeling utility over time. Later, its descriptive, validity, or ability to describe how people actually behave, was evaluated.
Inconsistencies led to the theorizing of a new equation for time preference. D(k) = \begin{cases} 1 & \text{if } k = 0 \\ \beta \delta^k & \text{if } k > 0 \end{cases} This function describes a difference between the discount rate today and the next period, and then constant discounting after. It is commonly called the (\beta, \delta) model.
A simple hyperbolic delay discounting equation is that of \frac{v}{V} = \frac{1}{1 + kD} Where v is the discounted value, V is the non-discounted value, k is the discount rate, and D is the delay. This is one of the most common hyperbolic discounting functions used today, and is especially useful in comparing two discounting scenarios, as the k parameter can be easily interpreted.
U_t(u_t, u_{t+1}, \dots, u_T) = \delta^t u_t + \beta \sum_{s=t+1}^T \delta^{s-t} u_s This explains that the sum of your current and all future utilities is equal to a delta parameter multiplied by your current utility plus all your future discounted utilities (scaled by beta).
Factors
Although the average discount rate may be of interest, that average typically obscures differences in individual valuations. Many factors that differ by people can influence their discount rates. This helps predict time preference for specific subgroups. r = \delta + \eta g Here, r is the rate of time preference, or the discount rate.
It is the sum of the pure rate of time preference ( \delta ) and the growth rate of per capita consumption ( g ), adjusted by the factor ( \eta ), representing the elasticity of marginal utility or inter-temporal inequality aversion. The next big finding on the climate discount rate was the Stern Review.
It was a report commissioned by the UK government in 2006 on the state of climate change. Major finding of the report is that urgent action is needed to avert the worst impacts of climate change; much more urgent than previously thought. This is due to his estimation of the discount rate.
In the report, Stern sets the Ramsey parameters to \delta = .1% , \eta = 1 and g=1.3% , meaning r=1.4% . With a discount rate this low, meaning future generations are almost equally as valued, this means that society needs to drastically reduce consumption. There was push back against this idea, most notably from economist William Nordhaus.
He wrote several papers reviewing the Stern Report and the assumptions in it. He argues that the near zero rate of time preference ( \delta = .1% ) is critical to the recommendations made. Furthermore, he says that a higher discount rate is consistent with market interest rates.
There is no consensus still on the climate discount rate that should be used. Considerations from experts span morality, interest rates, consumer preferences, intergenerational equity, and global equity. At the country level, the revealed environmental discount rates can span from 1%-10%.
Differences in time preference across countries
Since many of the psychological factors that cause discounting behavior also vary across countries, it makes sense that time preference may not be universal. Due to cultural factors, different countries may view allocations between the present and the future differently.
Differences of time preferences across countries have been found in several large-scale studies, in particular the INTRA study and the GPS study. Oded Galor and Omer Ozak explore the roots of observed differences in time preference across nations.
They establish that pre-industrial agricultural characteristics that were favorable to higher return to agricultural investment triggered a process of selection, adaptation, and learning that brought about a higher prevalence of long-term orientation. These agricultural characteristics are associated with contemporary economic and human behavior such as technological adoption, education, saving, and smoking.
The most comprehensive data set of time preferences encompasses 117 countries and is calculated by merging several previous datasets, including the aforementioned INTRA- and GPS-data, but also, e.g., survey questions from the World Value Survey. Many cross-cultural studies look at the differences between two or three countries. However, some have gone further.
A study on 53 counties found significant differences in time preference by country.
Cultural differences in predictors
There are many cultural differences that influence perceptions in general. Some aspects of culture which may be relevant to time preference include individualism/collectivism, uncertainty avoidance, and long term orientation. Countries with higher uncertainty avoidance have higher present bias, meaning they discount the future more steeply. On the other hand, countries higher in individualism and long term orientation discount less steeply.
See also
Decision theory Delayed gratification Discount function Discounted utility Discounting Dynamic inconsistency Hofstede's cultural dimensions theory – A theory of cultural differences in time preference Intertemporal choice Net present value Time value of money Treasury test discount rate Patience
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378118523 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.