Transformation problem
≈ 15 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In 20th-century discussions of Karl Marx's economics, the transformation problem is the problem of finding a general rule by which to transform the "values" of commodities (based on their socially necessary labour content, according to his labour theory of value) into the "competitive prices" of the marketplace. This problem was first introduced by Marxist economist Conrad Schmidt and later dealt with by Marx in chapter 9 of the draft of volume 3 of Capital. The essential difficulty was this: given that Marx derived profit, in the form of surplus value, from direct labour inputs, and that the ratio of direct labour input to capital input varied widely between commodities, how could he reconcile this with a tendency toward an average rate of profit on all capital invested among industries, if such a tendency (as predicted by Marx and Ricardo) exists?
In 20th-century discussions of Karl Marx's economics, the transformation problem is the problem of finding a general rule by which to transform the "values" of commodities (based on their socially necessary labour content, according to his labour theory of value) into the "competitive prices" of the marketplace. This problem was first introduced by Marxist economist Conrad Schmidt and later dealt with by Marx in chapter 9 of the draft of volume 3 of Capital. The essential difficulty was this: given that Marx derived profit, in the form of surplus value, from direct labour inputs, and that the ratio of direct labour input to capital input varied widely between commodities, how could he reconcile this with a tendency toward an average rate of profit on all capital invested among industries, if such a tendency (as predicted by Marx and Ricardo) exists? Marx defines value as the number of hours of labor socially necessary to produce a commodity. This includes two elements: First, it includes the hours that a worker of normal skill and dedication would take to produce a commodity under average conditions and with the usual equipment (Marx terms this "living labor"). Second, it includes the labor embodied in raw materials, tools, and machinery used up or worn away during its production (which Marx terms "dead labor" as it is not done by live beings). In capitalism, workers spend a portion of their working day reproducing the value of their means of subsistence, represented as wages (necessary labor), and a portion of their day producing value above and beyond that, referred to as surplus value, which goes to the capitalist (surplus labor). Marx uses this to establish that the value of a commodity C is composed of the value of the dead labor, or constant capital c , and the value of the necessary labor, or variable capital v that was originally paid for prior to the production process, plus the value of the surplus labor, or surplus value s generated by living labor but not paid for by the capitalist ( C = c + v + s ). According to Marx, the source of capitalist profit is this surplus value created by the surplus labor of the workers, and the rate of profit r can be defined as r = s / (c + v) , since in this theory only new, living labor produces value, and only surplus labor is not paid for by the capitalist. When this formula is combined with the assumption that the rate of surplus value ( s/v ) tends to equalize across industries, it should be the case that enterprises with a low organic composition ( c/v ), or a higher proportion of capital spent on living labor, would have a higher rate of profit than enterprises with a high organic composition, or a higher proportion of capital spent on raw materials and means of production. However, in models of classical perfect competition, higher rates of profit are not generally found in enterprises with a low organic composition, and low rates of profit are not generally found in enterprises with a high organic composition. Instead, there is a tendency toward equalization of the rate of profit in industries of different organic compositions. That is, in such models with no barriers to entry, capitalists are free to disinvest or invest in any industry, a tendency exists towards the formation of a general rate of profits, constant across all industries. Marx outlined the transformation problem as a theoretical solution to this discrepancy. The tendency of the rate of profit toward equalization means that, in this theory, there is no simple translation from value to money—e.g., 1 hour of value equals 20 dollars—that is the same across every sector of the economy. While such a simple translation may hold approximately true in general, Marx postulated that there is an economy-wide, systematic deviation according to the organic compositions of the different industries, such that 1 hour of value equals 20 dollars times T, where T represents a transformation factor that varies according to the organic composition of the industry in consideration. In this theory, T is approximately 1 in industries where the organic composition is close to average, less than 1 in industries where the organic composition is below average, and greater than 1 in industries where the organic composition is higher than average. Because Marx was considering only socially necessary labor, this variation among industries has nothing to do with higher-paid, skilled labor versus lower-paid, unskilled labor. This transformation factor varies only with respect to the organic compositions of different industries. In this case, Smith noticed, each hunter will be willing to exchange one deer (which costs him l_D hours) for {l_D \over l_B} beavers. The ratio {l_D \over l_B} —i.e., the relative quantity of labour embodied in (unit) deer production with respect to beaver production—gives thus the exchange ratio between deer and beavers, the "relative price" of deer in units of beavers. Moreover, since the only costs are here labor costs, this ratio is also the "relative unit cost" of deer for any given competitive uniform wage rate w . Hence the relative quantity of labor embodied in deer production coincides with the competitive relative price of deer in units of beavers, which can be written as {P_D \over P_B} (where the P stands for absolute competitive prices in some arbitrary unit of account, and are defined as P_i = wl_i ). P_i = wl_i + k_A a_i , (i = B, D) where k_A denotes the capital cost incurred in using each arrow. This capital cost is made up of two parts. First, there is the replacement cost of substituting the arrow when it is lost in production. This is P_A , or the competitive price of the arrows, multiplied by the proportion h \le 1 of arrows lost after each shot. Second, there is the net rental or return required by the arrows' owner (who may or may not be the same person as the hunter using it). This can be expressed as the product r P_A , where r is the (uniform) net rate of return of the system. Summing up, and assuming a uniform replacement rate h , the absolute competitive prices of beavers and deer may be written as P_i = wl_i + (h + r) P_A a_i Yet we still have to determine the arrows' competitive price P_A . Assuming arrows are produced by labor only, with l_A man-hours per arrow, we have: P_A = wl_A Assuming further, for simplicity, that h = 1 (i.e., all arrows are lost after just one shot, so that they are circulating capital), the absolute competitive prices of beavers and deer become: P_i = wl_i + (1 + r) wl_A a_i Here, l_i is the quantity of labor directly embodied in beaver and deer unit production, while l_A a_i is the labor indirectly thus embodied, through previous arrow production. The sum of the two, E_i = l_i + l_A a_i , gives the total quantity of labor embodied. It is now obvious that the relative competitive price of deer {P_D \over P_B} can no longer be generally expressed as the ratio between total amounts of labour embodied. With a_i > 0 the ratio {E_D \over E_B} will correspond to {P_D \over P_B} only in two very special cases: if either r = 0 ; or, if {l_B \over l_D} = {a_B \over a_D} . In general the two ratios will not only differ: {P_D \over P_B} may change for any given {E_D \over E_B} , if the net rate of return or the wages vary. As it will now be seen, this general lack of any functional relationship between {E_D \over E_B} and {P_D \over P_B} , of which Ricardo had been particularly well aware, is at the heart of Marx's transformation problem. For Marx, r is the quotient of surplus value to the value of capital advanced to non-labor inputs, and is typically positive in a competitive capitalist economy. Let us take two commodities, e.g., corn and iron. The proportions in which they are exchangeable, whatever those proportions may be, can always be represented by an equation in which a given quantity of corn is equated to some quantity of iron: e.g., 1 quarter corn = x cwt. iron. What does this equation tell us? It tells us that in two different things—in 1 quarter of corn and x cwt. of iron, there exists in equal quantities something common to both. The two things must therefore be equal to a third, which in itself is neither the one nor the other. Each of them, so far as it is exchange value, must therefore be reducible to this third. This common 'something' cannot be either a geometrical, a chemical, or any other natural property of commodities. Such properties claim our attention only in so far as they affect the utility of those commodities, make them use values. But the exchange of commodities is evidently an act characterised by a total abstraction from use value. If then we leave out of consideration the use value of commodities, they have only one common property left, that of being products of labour. […] Along with the useful qualities of the products themselves, we put out of sight both the useful character of the various kinds of labour embodied in them, and the concrete forms of that labour; there is nothing left but what is common to them all; all are reduced to one and the same sort of labour, human labour in the abstract. A use value, or useful article, therefore, has value only because human labour in the abstract has been embodied or materialised in it. How, then, is the magnitude of this value to be measured? Plainly, by the quantity of the value-creating substance, the labour, contained in the article. —Karl Marx, Capital, Volume I, Chapter 1 As labour produces in this sense more than its own value, the direct-labour input is called variable capital and denoted as v . The quantity of value that living labour transmits to the deer, in our previous example, varies according to the intensity of the exploitation. In the previous example, v_i = l_W l_i . By contrast, the value of other inputs—in our example, the indirect (or "dead") past labour embodied in the used-up arrows—is transmitted to the product as it stands, without additions. It is hence called constant capital and denoted as c. The value transmitted by the arrow to the deer can never be greater than the value of the arrow itself. In our previous example, c_i = l_A a_i . p_i = c_i + v_i + s_i = l_A a_i + l_W l_i + s_i Where p_i stands for the (unit) Marxian value of beavers and deer. However, from Marx's definition of value as total labour embodied, it must also be true that: p_i = l_A a_i + l_i = E_i Solving for s_i the above two relationships one has: {s_i \over v_i} = {(1- l_W) \over l_W} = \sigma for all i . This necessarily uniform ratio {s_i \over v_i} = \sigma is called by Marx the rate of exploitation, and it allows to re-write Marx's value equations as: p_i = c_i + v_i (1 + \sigma) = l_A a_i + l_W l_i (1 + \sigma) The following two tables adapt the deer-beaver-arrow example seen above (which, of course, is not found in Marx, and is only a useful simplification) to illustrate Marx's approach. In both cases it is assumed that the total quantities of beavers and deer captured are Q_B and Q_D respectively. It is also supposed that the subsistence real wage is one beaver per unit of labour, so that the amount of labour embodied in it is l_W = E_B = l_A a_B + l_B . Table 1 shows how the total amount of surplus value of the system, shown in the last row, is determined. Table 2 illustrates how Marx thought this total would be redistributed between the two industries, as "profit" at a uniform return rate, r, over constant capital. First, the condition that total "profit" must equal total surplus value—in the final row of table 2—is used to determine r. The result is then multiplied by the value of the constant capital of each industry to get its "profit". Finally, each (absolute) competitive price in labour units is obtained, as the sum of constant capital, variable capital, and "profit" per unit of output, in the last column of table 2. Tables 1 and 2 parallel the tables in which Marx elaborated his numerical example. The simultaneous linear equations method of computing competitive (relative) prices in an equilibrium economy is today very well known. In the greatly simplified model of tables 1 and 2, where the wage rate is assumed as given and equal to the price of beavers, the most convenient way is to express such prices is in units of beavers, which means normalising w = P_B = 1 . This yields the (relative) price of arrows as P_A = l_A beavers. Substituting this into the relative-price condition for beavers, 1 = l_B + (1 + r) l_A a_B , gives the solution for the rate of return as r = {(1 - l_B) \over (l_A a_B)} - 1 Finally, the price condition for deer can hence be written as P_D = l_D + (1 + r) l_A a_D = l_D + {a_D (1 - l_B) \over a_B} . This latter result, which gives the correct competitive price of deer in units of beavers for the simple model used here, is generally inconsistent with Marx's price formulae of table 2. Ernest Mandel, defending Marx, explains this discrepancy in term of the time frame of production rather than as a logical error; i.e., in this simplified model, capital goods are purchased at a labour value price, but final products are sold under prices that reflect redistributed surplus value.
Marxian and Sraffian critiques
Some mathematical economists assert that a set of functions in which Marx's equalities hold does not generally exist at the individual enterprise or aggregate level, so that chapter 9's transformation problem has no general solution, outside two very special cases. This was first pointed out by, among others, Bortkiewicz (1906). In the second half of the 20th century, Leontief’s and Sraffa’s work on linear production models provided a framework within which to argue this result in a general way. Although he never actually mentioned the transformation problem, Sraffa’s (1960) chapter 6 on the "reduction" of prices to "dated" amounts of current and past embodied labour gave implicitly the first general proof, showing that the competitive price P_i of the i^{th} produced good can be expressed as P_i = \sum_{n=0}^\infty l_{in} w {(1+r)^n} , where n is the time lag, l_{in} is the lagged-labour input coefficient, w is the wage, and r is the "profit" (or net return) rate. Since total embodied labour is defined as E_i = \sum_{n=0}^\infty l_{in} , it follows from Sraffa’s result that there is generally no function from E_i to P_i , as was made explicit and elaborated upon by later writers, notably Ian Steedman in Marx after Sraffa. A standard reference, with an extensive survey of the entire literature prior to 1971 and a comprehensive bibliography, is Samuelson's (1971) "Understanding the Marxian Notion of Exploitation: A Summary of the So-Called Transformation Problem Between Marxian Values and Competitive Prices" Journal of Economic Literature 9 2 399–431. Proponents of the temporal single system interpretation such as Moseley (1999), who argue that the determination of prices by simultaneous linear equations (which assumes that prices are the same at the start and end of the production period) is logically inconsistent with the determination of value by labour time, reject the principles of the mathematical proof that Marx's transformation problem has no general solution. Other Marxian economists accept the proof, but reject its relevance for some key elements of Marxian political economy. Still others reject Marxian economics outright, and emphasise the politics of the assumed relations of production instead. Hagendorf, Klaus: Labour Values and the Theory of the Firm. Part I: The Competitive Firm. Paris: EURODOS; 2009. Moseley, Fred (1999). "A 'New Solution' for the Transformation Problem: A Sympathetic Critique".
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1375481996 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.