Transgender genocide
, a German trans woman who was targeted by the Nazi regime as an "incurable transvestite" and murdered at the Mauthausen concentration camp in 1943 Transgender genocide or trans genocide (also transgendercide) describes the targeting of…
≈ 16 min read
Transgender genocide. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001378836752. /a/transgender-genocide
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
a German trans woman who was targeted by the Nazi regime as an "incurable transvestite" and murdered at the Mauthausen concentration camp in 1943 Transgender genocide or trans genocide (also transgendercide) describes the targeting of transgender people as part of wider genocides, as well as describe an elevated level of erasure, systematic discrimination, and violence against transgender people. The term is related to the common meaning as well as the legal concept of genocide, which the Genocide Convention describes as an intentional effort to completely or partially destroy a group based on its nationality, ethnicity, race, or religion.
Some legal scholars and transgender rights activists have argued this definition should be expanded to include transgender persons. , the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment from 2010–2016|alt=Juan E. Méndez speaks at a podium Some surveys have indicated that there is a concern among transgender individuals that trans-associated genetic research may lead to eugenics. A study conducted in 2021 found that many of those surveyed believe that genetic research could end up with a kind of "eugenics" that would, in effect, "eliminate" transgender people, while some respondents feared that, in more transphobic areas, trans-associated research would lead to "medical genocide".
This concern has been supported by scholars who highlight the link between the medical care transgender people can access and receive and eugenics movements historically and contemporaneously. In 2022, a study found that almost of half of individuals interviewed feared the "weeding out" of LGBTQ people while a quarter explicitly referred to "cleansing or eugenics".
Lawyer Agripino Kennedy links biological essentialist language in recent U.S. laws and bills targeting transgender people to past and current eugenic ideologies, and on the history of eugenic laws targeting the queer community, and transgender people, specifically in the U.S. and Germany. Sterilization that is forced upon transgender people in order to obtain legal recognition is characterized by various researchers, including political theorist Anna Carastathis, as a violation of reproductive rights, eugenic, and genocidal.
On the extent of this practice among European countries, she cites a 2013 report by the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. Recognizing that transgender persons are not covered by legal definitions of genocide, she argues "that trans people are systematically written out of legal existence" both through the compulsory sterilization and their exclusion from the Genocide Convention.
In contradistinction to Carastathis, political scientist Jemima Repo argues that compulsory sterilization does give transgender people a political existence, but at the expense of a capacity to extend kinship (i.e., family) into the future. As a result, Repo says that reproduction, at least in Finland, becomes a mode of transgender resistance in the face of sterilization demands. members plunder the library of the Institute for Sexology|alt=Two men stand atop a messy pile of books and documents, looking at some papers they are holding.
One of the men is wearing a Nazi stormtrooper uniform. members at the Opernplatz book burning in Berlin|alt=A crowd of people observes a large, burning pile of books. Many in the crowd have one arm raised in a Nazi salute. Sociologist Matthew Waites examines the absence of sexuality, gender, sexual orientation or gender identity as group categories in the Genocide Convention.
He argues that those targeted by the Nazis because of their non-conforming gender identities should be recognized as a genocide unique from the Holocaust. According to the Museum of Jewish Heritage, the Nazi German government "brutally targeted the trans community, deporting many trans people to concentration camps and wiping out vibrant community structures."
This area of research is underdeveloped and the number of transgender victims is unknown. Heather Panter, writing in the book Genocide and Victimology, noted that the number of transgender people targeted by the Nazis was likely lower than the number of gay people targeted.
Matt Fuller and Leah Owen argued that while Nazi anti-queer ideology was "incoherent and erratic", they targeted transgender people with extermination and memoricide. They cited the looting and burning of the books at the Institute for Sexology as an example of this memoricide.
The Institute for Sexology published journals on trans and queer issues and pioneered early gender-affirming surgeries. The institute also hosted the D'Eon Organization, which was founded in 19301 to advocate trans rights.
Fuller and Owen cited research conducted by Heike Bauer into the work of Magnus Hirschfeld at the Institute for Sexology, to explain a psychological element to this, stating "the mere presence of the bodies and desires of trans people was a challenge, threat, and source of anxiety to many Nazis, meaning they – or the physical archive that reflected their identity – had to be destroyed." The Nazis provided varied justifications for their targeting of queer people and often conflated trans issues with homosexuality.
In a document outlining the division of labor in the Reich Central Office for the Combating of Homosexuality and Abortion, "transvestites" were listed as a responsibility of the organization, separately from "all manifestations of homosexuality" and "combating of all enemies of positive population growth", suggesting trans identity was conceived of as a distinct issue and threat by the Nazis. The distinction of "transvestites" was seen contemporaneously with the publication of books such as by Hermann Voss, which espoused the benefits of Nazi persecution of such "transvestites".
This persecution included removing rights such as the issuing of " " ("transvestite certificates") that protected such individuals from arrest, that had been achieved under the Weimar government. As part of the 1933 mass incarceration of gay men in Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp, Hamburg city administration told the chief of police to "pay particular attention to transvestites and to deliver them to the concentration camps if necessary."
A prominent case was that of Liddy Bacroff, who was executed at Mauthausen concentration camp in 1943. Fuller and Owen further argued that transmasculine and transfeminine individuals faced inconsistent treatment.
Masculine presentations from those assigned female at birth were stigmatized: the National Socialist Women's League published a book in 19341 which warned gender ambiguity represented "signs of degeneration emanating from an alien race ... inimical to reproduction and for this reason damaging to the Volk. Healthy races do not artificially blur sexual differences" and Himmler complained in 1937 about the "nauseat[ing] catastrophe that was masculinizing ['young girls and women'] so that, over time, the difference between the sexes, the polarity, is blurred.
From there, the path to homosexuality is not too far off." There is an inconsistency in individual accounts of transmasculine people.
One was forcibly detransitioned, another was detained in Lichtenburg concentration and released 10 months later with a permit from the Gestapo to wear men's clothing, and another was allowed to dress as a man without a permit following a medical examination and a promise that they had never engaged in homosexual relations. In 2022, the Regional Court of Cologne ruled that denying that trans people were targeted by the Nazis qualifies as "a denial of Nazi crimes".
On , the German government dedicated its annual Holocaust memorial commemoration to LGBTQ victims of the Holocaust. This marked the first time the German government had granted official recognition to transgender people as victims of the Holocaust.
In a speech given at the commemoration, German Bundestag President Bärbel Bas stated "For our remembrance culture, it's important that we tell the stories of all victims of persecution, that we make their injustice visible, that we recognize their suffering." Transgender people have also been recognized or commemorated as victims of the Holocaust by the Human Rights Campaign, Amnesty International, the European Parliament, the Museum of Jewish Heritage, and the United Nations. executing indigenous Panamanians by war dogs for same-sex practices by Theodor de Bry, 1594 |alt=Some dogs attack several people who are cowering on the ground near some decapitated heads.
Several men in colonial attire stand and observe the executions. Their posture is relaxed and most of them hold swords or halberds.
The violence perpetrated against Indigenous peoples of the Americas who did not conform to European sexual and gender norms due to this nonconformity has been described as genocide, while others such as Deborah A. Miranda and Gregory D. Smithers view such as an example of gendercide which was a tool in the genocide of indigenous peoples. Thais Torres-Castro and Amalia Morales-Villena highlight this in the colonization of Puerto Rico and the genocide of indigenous people who did not follow the gender binary.
Deborah A. Miranda uses the term gendercide to identify the Spanish colonial practice of systemically targeting (the Spanish term for third gender people) in an attempt to exterminate them. Miranda details two cases, one in 1513 at Santa Clara in present day Panama, where Vasco Núñez de Balboa encountered about forty Indigenous men "dressed as women", and had them eaten alive by his war dogs.
Afterwards the Spanish had such third gender people rounded up and systematically killed. The other is the 1775 memoir of Spanish soldier Pedro Fages, who wrote that about two or three could be identified in each Indigenous Californian village and were "held in great esteem" in their communities.
Fages sought to initiate a swift reduction of the , writing that "these accursed people will disappear with the growth of the missions. The abominable vice will be eliminated to the extent that the Catholic faith and all the other virtues are firmly implanted there." Qwo-Li Driskill writes how this violence was waged against people now understood as two-spirit.
Indigenous people subjected to the American Indian boarding schools system have reported how they were taught and pressured to abuse two-spirit individuals within the schools. Ongoing violence against Two-spirit and LGBTQ Indigenous peoples of Canada has also been a focus of study and analysis within the genocidal occurrence of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women.
In broader discussions, the coloniality of gender has been used to understand the erasure and violence against people referred to as occupying a third gender by Western anthropologists in the Americas through European colonialism. and travesti-cide at a march in protest of the death of Cynthia Moreira, June 2018 |alt=A person in a crowd holds up a sign which says, "Basta de transfemicidios y travesticidios" Adam Jones describes Brazil's treatment of transgender people as "unquestionably gendercidal", noting that at least one trans person was reported killed every 27 hours in 2014. Professor of psychology Jaqueline Gomes de Jesus has argued that structural and interpersonal violence directed at transgender people in Brazil would satisfy the criteria in articles 2(a) to 2(d) of the Genocide Convention.
This is supported by legal scholar Leandro Reinaldo da Cunha. De Jesus also highlights the prominence of violence against transgender people in Latin America, where of the 816 murders of transgender people recorded from 2008 to 2011, 79% of them occurred in Latin America.
Brazil has had the highest amount of transgender murder victims in the world since 2008, with 31% of recorded killings of transgender people occurring in Brazil in 2022–2023. This has led to the average lifespan of a transgender Brazilian being less than half that of a cisgender Brazilian.
As 71% of transgender people murdered in Brazil are black, and suggest that this constitutes a racialised genocide. The neologism (meaning transgendercide) has been adopted as a term used in Brazil to classify transgender genocide. In Argentina, while progressive gender identity legislation was passed in 2012, the average life expectancy of transgender people remained at 35 years.
In 2018, the first conviction was handed down for the murder of human rights activist Diana Sacayán, where the crime was labelled as " ", though this decision was overturned on appeal in 2020 due to lack of evidence. In 2021, Argentina amended its penal code to officially include the crimes of " ", and " ". at CPAC 2025.
Knowles' previous comments at CPAC 2023 received widespread condemnation for the use of eliminationist rhetoric. |alt=Michael Knowles speaks at a podium with the CPAC logo Statements made by American right-wing media figures regarding trans people have been criticized as genocidal. During a speech at the 2023 Conservative Political Action Conference, political commentator Michael Knowles stated, "There can be no middle way in dealing with transgenderism.
It is all or nothing [...] For the good of society, and especially for the good of the poor people who have fallen victim to this confusion, transgenderism must be eradicated from public life entirely".
The previous week, Knowles had claimed on his online show presented by the Daily Wire that a genocide against trans people is impossible because they are "not a legitimate category of being." His statements were described as "blatantly genocidal" and that they could exacerbate "genocidal fervor", and were criticized by multiple organizations including the Human Rights Campaign, the Anti-Defamation League, and the American Constitution Society.
The Lemkin Institute in its response noted, "The speed of Knowles' response suggests that he may be concerned that his words put him in violation of laws against incitement and may make him accountable for future hate crimes and mass atrocities against trans people." Matt Walsh, another Daily Wire commentator and a key figure of the anti-gender movement in the United States, garnered similar criticism in December 2024 after stating "We are not gonna rest until every child is protected, until trans ideology is entirely erased from the earth" at a protest against gender-affirming care for transgender youth.
Since the start of the second Donald Trump presidency, a variety of executive orders and legislation have been implemented targeting transgender people, with such orders and legislation being described as "arguably genocidal". In February 2025, the Lemkin Institute issued a "Red Flag Alert for Genocide" of transgender individuals, highlighting a series of executive orders issued by the Trump Administration, arguing that these were the first steps toward "removing a trans presence from collective life and preventing trans people from existing as themselves".
In April 2025, after Planned Parenthood of Arizona announced they would no longer provide gender-affirming care, transgender journalist David Forbes wrote, "in short, ending trans healthcare on a large scale is a recipe for mass death, and the clear intention is to push society towards our genocide. That is the point of it."
The Lemkin Institute issued a second "Red Flag Alert" in June 2025 in response to the United States v. Skrmetti U.S. Supreme Court decision, which allowed Tennessee to ban gender affirming healthcare for transgender youth, stating that the "decision marks a radicalization of attempts to erase trans people, in whole, as a group, as it prevents trans children and their families from accessing the necessary and appropriate healthcare to support and confirm their gender identity." In September 2025, after the Annunciation Catholic Church shooting, the U.S. Department of Justice held internal meetings to discuss possible methods of placing restrictions on transgender people owning firearms by declaring them "mentally ill" and therefore unfit to own a firearm.
In 2026, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives proposed new rules that would require anyone purchasing a new gun to provide their "biological sex at birth" rather than their gender identity. The proposed rules have been described as a "backdoor ban" on transgender people purchasing firearms.
Transgender journalist Finley Smith, commenting on the proposed rules, noted that "Disarming minority groups is one of the early stages of genocidal behavior." Smith acknowledged that, if implemented, the rule change may not immediately affect transgender people who currently own firearms, but argued that the change would still represent "a serious threat" to transgender people, in part because it could result in transgender people whose current legal gender marker does not match their original birth certificate being charged with a felony for "providing seemingly contradictory information that the federal government could read as a lie".
In January 2026, journalist Walker Bragman interviewed three genocide scholars who were concerned that the US was at the "early stages of committing genocide" against transgender people. Former presidents of the International Association of Genocide Scholars Henry Theriault and Gregory Stanton explained that the Trump administration wanted "to destroy a gender group," accuse them of corrupting traditional and family values, marginalize them socially and economically partly in order to urge them to kill themselves, and give tacit permission to law enforcers to use force specifically against them.
Stanton and Haley Brown, experts on genocide, deemed these tactics to be "directly borrowed from the Nazis." Their comments were supported by Holocaust educator Lori Shepherd in an interview discussing the targeting of transgender people in the U.S. The third "Red Flag Alert" issued by the Lemkin Institute in March 2026, cited record-breaking increases in anti-transgender legislation and stated that "the United States is squarely within the early to middle stages of a genocidal process against trans people, the goal of which is to completely erase transgender people not only from public life but also from existence in the U.S. and globally."
The Lemkin Institute also highlighted the misinformation about transgender violence attempting to paint all transgender people as a threat to the US, pointing to a variety of high profile media individuals and senior officials of government departments such as Jim O'Neil of the Department of Health and Human Services. Writing for the Humanist, Michael McGrady Jr. argued that the Trump administration is engaging in "memoricide", which he defines as a form of genocide and trans erasure, through executive orders and removal of transgender-related information from government websites.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378836752 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Transgender genocide” date of foundation (×2) · confidence 0.95 revision URL