Uintatherium
≈ 16 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Uintatherium is an extinct genus of dinoceratan mammal that lived during the Eocene epoch. Two species are currently recognized: U. anceps is found in the United States and lived during the early to middle Eocene (50.5–37 million years ago), while U. insperatus is found in China and lived during the middle and late Eocene (48–37 million years ago). The first fossils of Uintatherium were recovered from the Fort Bridger Basin and were initially believed to belong to a new species of brontothere. Several previously recognized species, as well as genera such as Edward Drinker Cope's Loxolophodon and Othniel Charles Marsh's Tinoceras, are now assigned to Uintatherium anceps. The systematic position of Uintatherium and other dinoceratans has long been debated. Originally, they were assigned to the order Amblypoda, which united various early ungulates from the Paleogene. Amblypoda has since fallen out of use. The most widespread hypothesis is that dinoceratans are related to the South American xenungulates, together forming a mirorder called Uintatheriamorpha. If this is correct, dinoceratans, and thus Uintatherium, would not be ungulates at all. However, it is possible that the traits shared between the two groups evolved independently.…
Uintatherium is an extinct genus of dinoceratan mammal that lived during the Eocene epoch. Two species are currently recognized: U. anceps is found in the United States and lived during the early to middle Eocene (50.5–37 million years ago), while U. insperatus is found in China and lived during the middle and late Eocene (48–37 million years ago). The first fossils of Uintatherium were recovered from the Fort Bridger Basin and were initially believed to belong to a new species of brontothere. Several previously recognized species, as well as genera such as Edward Drinker Cope's Loxolophodon and Othniel Charles Marsh's Tinoceras, are now assigned to Uintatherium anceps. The systematic position of Uintatherium and other dinoceratans has long been debated. Originally, they were assigned to the order Amblypoda, which united various early ungulates from the Paleogene. Amblypoda has since fallen out of use. The most widespread hypothesis is that dinoceratans are related to the South American xenungulates, together forming a mirorder called Uintatheriamorpha. If this is correct, dinoceratans, and thus Uintatherium, would not be ungulates at all. However, it is possible that the traits shared between the two groups evolved independently. Within Dinocerata itself, Uintatherium belongs to the family Uintatheriidae and is one of two members of Uintatheriinae; the other two are Eobasileus and Tetheopsis. Uintatherium was a large animal, with U. anceps having a shoulder height of and a body mass of . The largest Uintatherium skulls known, originally assigned to Loxolophodon, measure in length. The skull bears a series of bony, skin-covered protrusions, sometimes referred to as horns: one pair on the tip of the snout, one pair above the gap between the canine and cheek teeth, and one pair toward the back of the skull. The skull was similar to that of the other two uintatheriine genera, though broader, and in Eobasileus, the middle pair of protrusions sat further back, directly above the cheek teeth. The canines of Uintatherium were very large and supported by a pair of bony flanges that extended from the lower jaw. They were likely sexually dimorphic, and may have been used in display or for defense. The skeleton of Uintatherium bears a combination of characteristics often associated with proboscideans (elephants and relatives) and rhinocerotids. Uintatherium evolved during the Paleocene-Eocene thermal maximum, a period which saw some of the highest global temperatures in Earth's history. Most of the North American continent was covered in closed-canopy forests, with the Bridger Formation, one of the localities U. anceps is best known from, consisting of an inland lake surrounded by birch, elm and redwood forests. The depositional environment of the later Uinta Formation also featured open savannahs that resulted from a global cooling and aridification trend in North America. The Chinese species, U. insperatus, lived in an environment of brackish marshes and semi-arid steppe.
Description
of U. anceps|left]] Uintatherium was a large, graviportal animal (one with adaptations for supporting a high body weight), with short, robust, and dense limb bones. There were pronounced differences between sexes: males had larger canines, larger flanges on the lower jaws, larger sagittal crests, larger horns, and an overall larger body size. As it was a fairly large mammal which lived mostly in warm environments, William Berryman Scott suggested that Uintatherium may have been predominantly hairless, though noted that there is no direct evidence. Its thick, barrel-shaped ribcage has led some to suggest that it may have practised hindgut fermentation, like modern horses and sea cows.
Skull
The skull of Uintatherium is roughly three times longer than it is wide. Most U. anceps skulls range from in length, whereas the only known U. insperatus skull measures . Some specimens have skulls which, when measured at the zygomatic arches, are roughly wide, suggesting a very large skull size. Furthermore, some specimens initially assigned to Loxolophodon have skull lengths of up to , nearly a third larger than most others. The skull of U. anceps can be distinguished from those of other uintatheriins by its broadness, while that of U. insperatus was slenderer. Eobasileus and Tetheopsis have skulls which are relatively longer and slenderer than U. anceps . The nasal bones of Uintatherium are very long, comprising roughly half of the total length of the skull. They project far enough anteriorly (forwards) that they completely overhang the external nares. While an elephant-like trunk or proboscis was suggested early on based on supposed affinities to proboscideans, the structure of the nasal passage and olfactory nerves suggest that no such appendage existed. In its place, there may have been a flexible upper lip, similar to that of modern rhinoceros, and a long, muscular tongue. The frontal bones are large, almost as wide as long, though considerably shorter than the nasals. Uintatherium has large zygomatic arches, of which the maxilla comprises the anterior portion, similar to proboscideans. Like other dinoceratans, the skull of Uintatherium lacks a postorbital process. At the back of the skull is a very large occipital crest, extending posteriorly (rearward) further than the occipital condyles. To either side of the occipital crest is a pair of very large parasagittal crests, alternatively known as the posterior crests, or the parietal-occipital crests. The parietal bones of Uintatherium, like its close relatives, are tightly fused, and they bear a distinct transverse ridge which would have provided structural support. The occiput, overhung by a large occipital crest, is rectangular in outline (though was subject to individual variation), and has deep concavities on its posterior surface where powerful neck muscles and ligaments would have attached. Much like other dinoceratans, Uintatherium s skull is adorned with a series of well-developed outgrowths, sometimes called horns, three pairs in total. The first pair sits at the front of each nasal, and differs in form between specimens: in some, these protrusions are small and deflected upward and outward, while in others, they are larger and more horizontal. In U. insperatus, it is slightly longer and more triangular, and the portion of the nasal anterior to it is slightly longer. The second pair, above the maxillae, sit directly above the diastema (gap) separating the canines and premolars. The last pair, the so-called parietal horns, sit far anterior to (in front of) the occipital bone, on the parasagittal crests. This differs from the related Eobasileus and Tetheopsis, in which the parietal horns are closer to the occipital. Furthermore, in those two genera, the maxillary set of horns sits above the premolars, meaning the portion of the snout anterior to the maxillary horns is fairly long, whereas in Uintatherium, the portion of the snout anterior to the maxillary horns is fairly short. In U. anceps, the maxillary and parietal horns projected outward slightly, while in U. insperatus, they are essentially erect. Despite their description as horns, it is unlikely that any of these outgrowths were cornified (reinforced by keratin), as there is no evidence of the vascularization necessary for a keratinous covering. It is likely that they were covered only by skin. Nevertheless, damage to several Uintatherium horn cores, likely inflicted while the animals were still alive, suggests that they used their horns in agonistic behaviors. Like other animals with extensive cranial ornamentation, Uintatherium s skull was lightened by well-developed sinuses, though not to the same extent. Projecting from the anteroventral (towards the front and bottom) portion of Uintatherium s mandibles (lower jaws) are a pair of large flanges. In most specimens, these would have provided support to the large upper canines, though specimens formerly assigned to Loxolophodon have smaller flanges which do not extend as far. It has been suggested that the observed difference in flange size is the result of sexual dimorphism, with larger-flanged jaws belonging to males. Similar structures are observed in the related Bathyopsis. The mandibles of Uintatherium are otherwise fairly slender. Unlike most other ungulates, the condyles of the jaw joint are deflected posteriorly, likely to accommodate the large upper tusks; without such a modification, the jaws would be unable to fully open. This condition is otherwise only seen in some marsupials and insectivorans. The condyles are small and sit slightly above the level of the cheek teeth. The mandible's coronoid process is large, curves posteriorly, and is pointed dorsally (at the top).
Paleoecology
Paleoenvironment
Uintatherium evolved during a period in Earth's climatic history called the Paleocene-Eocene thermal maximum. This period saw some of the highest average temperatures in Earth's history with temperatures in Colorado (where Uintatherium fossils have been found) reaching an annual average of —much higher than today where the mean annual temperature in Colorado is only around . Although global average temperatures declined throughout the Eocene, the average temperatures in North America remained relatively constant during the first half of the period, and only cooled slightly towards the end of the Eocene. Even though temperatures remained relatively constant, the uplifting of the Rocky Mountains and their associated volcanism led to considerable drying in the North American interior. The arid scrublands which characterize the western United States today (as exemplified by Arizona, Nevada, and New Mexico) began to emerge during this period. This transition, at least directly around the Rocky Mountains, appears to have begun around 42 million years ago. When Uintatherium first appeared in North America, most of the continent was covered in closed-canopy forests. This environment is exemplified by the Bridger Formation, which consisted of inland lakes surrounded by dense forests. This is inferred by the abundance of plant fossils and the presence of a great diversity of primate fossils, which are predominantly arboreal. Fossils of redwoods, elms, and birch trees are known from throughout North America during this period, suggesting that the amount of precipitation did not vary considerably across latitudes. Even organisms more typically adapted to low-latitude environments, such as palm trees and crocodylians, are found as far north as Alaska and Ellesmere Island, exemplifying the extreme climatic conditions of the early and middle Eocene. By the time of the Uinta Formation, the landscape had changed considerably. The large lakes emblematic of the earlier Eocene had shrunk, and the majority of deposition was the product of low-volume streams. Insectivorous and frugivorous mammals (especially primates) declined in diversity alongside a rise of folivorous artiodactyls, which is interpreted as reflecting an increase in more open habitats resulting from a gradual decline in tree cover. Considerable forests existed, likely alongside the numerous waterways, but these were probably interspersed by open savannah environments. This trend towards aridification was caused by a general decrease in precipitation in North America while average annual temperatures remained high. It would not be until the later parts of the Eocene that the global cooling began to affect North American ecosystems, by which point, Uintatherium was already extinct. U. insparatus appeared in Asia during the middle part of the Eocene. Its fossils are known from the Lushi Basin in China, which consisted of large, deep lakes that preserve fossils of bivalves and gastropods. These lakes were surrounded by forests and swamps and were interspersed by semi-arid steppe. Intermittent flooding at the time also produced brackish lakes and swamps. The inland lakes varied in size over the course of the middle Eocene before eventually disappearing completely and being replaced by rivers and floodplains.
Contemporary fauna
North America
Uintatherium anceps is known from the Bridger, Uinta, and Washakie formations, from the Bridgerian and Uintan North American land mammal ages. This corresponds to the interval between 50.5 and 39.7 million years ago—a span of just over 10 million years within the Eocene. The oldest remains confidently assigned to this species are from the faunal zone "BR3" of the Bridger Formation, which is at the end of the Bridgerian land mammal age. In the Bridger Formation, U. anceps coexisted with a variety of primitive ungulates including helohyids, homacodontids, brontotheriids, amynodontids, and hyopsodontids. The environment was also host to some of the ancestors of modern perissodactyl groups including Hyrachyus (a primitive relative of rhinos), Helaletes (an early relative of tapirs), and several species of Orohippus (a primitive horse). North America at the time also had a diverse assemblage of early primates including Microsyops, Notharctus, Smilodectes, and the members of Omomyidae (relatives of modern tarsiers). Mammalian predators of the region included mesonychids like Mesonyx and Harpagolestes, hyaenodontids like Limnocyon and Sinopa, oxyaenids like Patriofelis and Machaeroides, and early carnivoran-relatives like Miacis and Vulpavus. A variety of more enigmatic mammal forms were also present including members of Tillodontia, Stylinodontidae, and Pantolestidae and the small insectivorous Apatemys and Metacheiromys. Primitive sciuromorph rodents, leptictids, and eulypotyphlans coexisted with the metatherians Herpetotherium and Peradectes. Reptiles were also abundant in this environment. Fossils from turtles including softshelled turtles, tortoises, terrapins, and baenids lived alongside anguids, varanids, teiids, and boids as well as crocodilians like Boverisuchus and Borealosuchus. Remains of primitive owls and cranes have also been found. In the transition from the Bridgerian to the Uintan, several of these animals became extinct and new forms emerged. The oxyaenids and phenacodontids disappeared during this transition and new groups like the oromerycids and the earliest chalicotheres (the eomoropids). This transition is followed by the appearance of several medium and large ungulate genera including Protylopus, Amynodon, and Eobasileus. This faunal subinterval is represented by the Devil's Graveyard Formation and has been argued to be a distinct land mammal sub-age (the "Shoshonian" or "UI1b biochronological zone"), although this is not universally accepted. This transition also saw a marked decline in primate diversity in North America, which would continue throughout the Eocene until primates eventually became extinct in North America. The middle-Uintan land mammal age (sometimes called "UI2" biochronological zone) is the most recent interval from which fossils of U. anceps are known. This corresponds to the eponymous Uinta Formation. This interval saw the diversification of brontotheres, helohyids, and rhinocerotoids as well as the emergence of the first protoceratids, agriochoerids, and camelids. It also saw the extinction of North American cimolestans and leptictids as well as most of the remaining North American primates, with only the omomyids remaining extant. Primitive carnivoramorphs like Miocyon also emerged. The end of this interval saw the final extinction of Uintatherium in North America alongside other long-lived genera such as Mesonyx and Hyrachyus.
Asia
The second species of Uintatherium, U. insperatus, lived in the Lushi Formation what is now Henan, China during the Middle Eocene. The precise age of the fossils assigned to this species are uncertain, but they have been estimated to be between 48 and 37 million years ago, which is roughly contemporaneous with the existence of U. anceps in North America. This corresponds to the Sharamurunian Asian land mammal age, which lasted for about the same length of time. Remains assigned to U. cf. insperatus have also been found in the similarly-aged Uqbulak Formation in the Junggar Basin. The composition of Asian land mammal assemblages was similar in several ways to the contemporary assemblages in North America, although the precise timing of faunal turnover is not as well studied with respect to Eocene ecosystems in Asia. The carnivorous mammals of the continent were generally similar, with mesonychids, haplodectids, hyaenodontids, and the carnivoramorphan Miacis being the most abundant predators. However, several endemic carnivores coexisted with these including Eusmilus (an early nimravid), Cynodictis (a primitive amphicyonid), and the controversial carnivorous ungulate Andrewsarchus. Prey for these animals included a diverse array of terrestrial ungulates including late surviving members of Paleocene lineages such as the coryphodont Eudinoceras, dichobunids, tillodontians, and taeniodontans. Ungulate groups common in North America were also represented, including Hyrachyus as well as the helohyids, brontotheriids, helaletiids, and amynodontids. They were accompanied by a diverse array of perissodactyls, which underwent a radiation in Asia during the Middle Eocene. These new groups included the paraceratheriids, hyracodontids, chalicotheriids, and deperetellids. The artiodactyl anthracotheres also first evolved in Asia during this period.
References
Further reading
Academy of Natural Sciences National Park Service Wood, Horace Elmer 1923, The problem of the Uintatherium molars, Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History; v. 48, article 18 Fossil Evidence – Eocene: Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372607372 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.