Unconstitutional constitutional amendment
An unconstitutional constitutional amendment is a concept in judicial review based on the idea that even a properly passed and properly ratified constitutional amendment, specifically one that is not explicitly prohibited by a…
≈ 6 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
An unconstitutional constitutional amendment is a concept in judicial review based on the idea that even a properly passed and properly ratified constitutional amendment, specifically one that is not explicitly prohibited by a constitution's text, can nevertheless be unconstitutional on substantive (as opposed to procedural) grounds—such as due to this amendment conflicting with some constitutional or even extra-constitutional norm, value, and/or principle. As Israeli legal academic 2017 book Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments: The Limits of Amendment Powers demonstrates, the unconstitutional constitutional amendment doctrine has been adopted by various courts and legal scholars in various countries throughout history.
While this doctrine has generally applied specifically to constitutional amendments, there have been moves and proposals to also apply this doctrine to original parts of a constitution.
Germany
Contemporary Germany arose from the ashes of World War II and the totalitarian experience of Nazism. Based on the legacy of the Weimar Constitution and especially on the correction of its flaws, the Federal Republic of Germany was born in 19491 (as West Germany) and the Federal Constitutional Court has been active since 1951.
The court's jurisdiction is focused on constitutional issues and the compliance of all governmental institutions with the constitution. Both ordinary laws and constitutional laws (and amendments) passed by the Parliament are subject to its judicial review, since they have to be compatible with the core principles of the Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany defined by the eternity clause, i.e. articles 1-20, the federal structure of Germany and the participation of the federal states in legislation.
Honduras
In 2015, the Supreme Court of Honduras declared unconstitutional a part of the original 1982 constitution of Honduras that created a one-term limit for the president of Honduras and also created protective provisions punishing attempts to alter this presidential term limit. This case was novel in the sense that a part of an original constitution rather than a constitutional amendment was declared unconstitutional.
India
In the 1960s and 1970s, the Indian Supreme Court articulated the basic structure doctrine—as in, the idea that a constitutional amendment that violates the basic structure of the Indian Constitution should be declared unconstitutional. This was a significant reversal from 1951—when the Indian Supreme Court declared that the constitutional amendment power was unlimited.
Israel
Israel does not have a unified constitution; its legal framework is instead codified in a series of quasi-constitutional Basic Laws. In July 2023, the ruling coalition under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu passed an amendment to Basic Law: The Judiciary, which defines the powers of that branch of government.
It would have limited the powers of the Supreme Court of Israel to strike down legislation that it considers contrary to the Basic Laws. The law was very controversial and led to widespread protests in the country. On 1 January 2024, the Supreme Court ruled 12-3 that it may reject amendments to Basic Laws in "extreme" circumstances.
That specific amendment was struck down by an 8–7 vote. In the decision, the justices noted that the judicial overhaul would jeopardise the basic characteristic of Israel as a democratic country.
Italy
Similar to Germany, the Italian Republic was born out of fascism. The Constitution of Italy, effective since 1948, is largely amendable, however the Constitutional Court of Italy (active since 1955) decides on the constitutionality of both ordinary laws and constitutional laws, for example, in respects to inviolable human rights, highlighted by the Constitution's "Article 2".
The Constitutional Court's ruling is final and not subject to appeal. An example of an unconstitutional constitutional amendment would be a measure to restore the monarchy, which was abolished in 1946. This is because Italy's republican form of government is explicitly protected in an entrenched clause, which is impossible to amend.
Taiwan (Republic of China)
Even though the ROC Constitution made no mentioning of judicial reviews of constitutional amendments, in Interpretation No. 499, the Council of the Grand Justices (Constitutional Court) declared a Constitutional Amendment unconstitutional and struck it down. This set the precedence of court review of constitutional amendments in Taiwan ROC.
Finland
The Parliament of Finland enjoys parliamentary sovereignty: its acts do not undergo judicial review, and cannot be stricken down by any court, so the constitutionality of a constitutional amendment is a purely political question. A supermajority can immediately enact an emergency constitutional amendment.
In 1973, President of Finland Urho Kekkonen requested a four-year term extension by means of an emergency constitutional amendment, in order to avoid arranging presidential elections. He succeeded in persuading the opposition National Coalition Party and Swedish People's Party to vote for the amendment, and obtained his extension.
Finland has had for most of its independence a semi-presidential system, but in the last few decades the powers of the President have been diminished. Constitutional amendments, which came into effect in 1991 and 1992, as well as the most recently drafted constitution of 2000 (amended in 2012), have made the presidency a primarily ceremonial office.
United Kingdom
The Constitution of the United Kingdom is not strictly codified in contrast to that of many other nations. This enables the constitution to be easily changed as no provisions are formally entrenched.
The United Kingdom has a doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty, so the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (active since 2009) is in fact limited in its powers of judicial review as it cannot overturn any primary legislation made by the Parliament of the United Kingdom and any Act of Parliament can become part of the UK's constitutional sources without binding scrutiny.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376755058 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Unconstitutional constitutional amendment” date of birth (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL