Utility assessment
≈ 6 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Utility assessment, also called utility measurement, is a process by which the utility function of individuals or groups can be estimated. There are many different methods for utility assessment.
How it works
Utility assessment, also called utility measurement, is a process by which the utility function of individuals or groups can be estimated. There are many different methods for utility assessment. Bernoulli himself assumed that the utility is logarithmic, that is, u(x)=log(x) where x is the amount of money; this was sufficient for solving the St. Petersburg paradox. Gustav Fechner also supplied psychophysical justification for the logarithmic function (known as the Weber–Fechner law).
Evidence and sources
But Stanley Smith Stevens showed that the relation between physical stimulus and psychological perception can be better explained by a power function, that is, u(x)=x p , with exponent p between 0.3 and 2. Many investigators tried to determine whether utility is better represented by logarithmic functions or by power functions. Using various methods, they showed that power functions fit utility data better.
Impact
As a result, power functions were incorporated into psychological decision theories, such as Cumulative prospect theory, rank-affected multiplicative (RAM) weights model, and transfer of attention exchange (TAX) model. Some economic applications still use logarithmic functions though. Wakker noted that power functions can have a negative exponent, but in this case their sign should change so that they remain increasing. One way to define this generalized family of functions is: u_r(x) = x^r/r which is increasing for any exponent r ≠ 0.
Moreover, the limit of this function when r → 0 is exactly the logarithmic function: u_0(x) = \ln(x) . Therefore, the family of functions u r (x) for all real p is sometimes called power-log utility. In equivalence procedures, subjects are asked to adjust a sum of money in one lottery so that it becomes equivalent - in their eyes - to another lottery. For example, subjects may be asked to consider two lotteries: (a) getting $x for sure; (b) getting $20 with probability 60% and getting $0 with probability 40%.
They are asked "for what value of x, would you be indifferent between these two lotteries?". Each such question yields an equation of the form \sum_i p_{1,i} u(x_{1,i}) = \sum_i p_{2,i} u(x_{2,i}) , which can be used to assess the form of the utility function. For example, if the subject answers x=$10, we get the equation u(10) = 0.6 u(20) + 0.4 u(0) . Assuming power utility, this yields {10}^r = 0.6 \cdot {20}^r , which yields r=\log(0.6)/\log(0.5)\approx 0.74 .
In choice procedures, subjects are shown two or more lotteries, and asked which lottery they prefer. For example, subjects may be asked to choose between two options: "(a) getting $10 for sure; (b) getting $20 with probability 60% and getting $0 with probability 40%". Each such question yields an inequality of the form \sum_i p_{1,i} u(x_{1,i}) > \sum_i p_{2,i} u(x_{2,i}) , where p 1,i and x 1,i are the probabilites and sums in the preferred lottery, and p 2,i and x 2,i are the probabilities and sums in the other lottery.
The advantage of choice questions is that they are easier to answer; a sequence of such questions can lead to the point of equivalence. There are several problems with these procedures. First, they assume people weight events by their true (objective) probabilities, p 1,i and p 2,i . In fact, much evidence shows that people weight events by subjective probabilities. In particular, people tend to overweight small probabilities and underweight medium to large probabilities (see Prospect theory).
The non-linearity in the subjective probability may be confounded with the concavity of the utility function. For example, the person indifferent between the lotteries [100%: $10] and [60%:$20, 40%:0] can be modeled by a linear utility function, if we assume that he underweights the probability 60% to around 50%. One way to avoid this confounding is using equal probabilities in all queries; this was done, for example, by Coombs and Komorita.
This trick works for non-configural weight theories, which assume that the subjective probability is a function of the objective probability (that is, every objective probability is translated to a unique subjective probability). In this case, when all probabilities in the queries are equal, and they cancel out in the equations. The equations involve only the utilities, and we can again use them to infer the form of the utility function.
However, configural weight theories, motivated by the Allais paradox, show that subjective probability may depend both on the objective probability and on the outcome. Kirby presented a way to design the queries such that, for power-log utilities and negative-exponential utilities, the predictions do not depend on canceling subjective probabilities. A second problem is that some experiments use both gains and losses.
However, later research show that the concavity of the utility function may be different between gains and losses (see prospect theory and loss aversion). Combining gain and loss domains may yield an incorrect utility function. A possible solution is to measure each of these two domains separately. Eugene Galanter devised another solution, for both the first and the second problem. He conducted experiments in which no probabilities were used; instead, he asked questions such as "how much money would you need in order to feel twice as happy as $10"?
If the answer is e.g. $18, then we get an equation such as u(18) = 2 u(10) , which gives information on the utility function, without and dependence on probabilities and risk attitudes. His experiments consistently showed that power functions better fit the data than log functions. A third problem is that most experiments compare the relative fit of different utility models to the data. For example, they can show that power functions fit the data better than logarithmic functions, but cannot reject the hypothesis that power functions fit the data.
Kirby presented a novel experiment design, that allowed him to get point-predictions for each model separately. His experiments indicate that both power-log functions and negative-exponent functions do not fit the data. He leaves finding a better-fitting function as an open problem. Based on these two phases, a linear additive utility model was estimated.
A mixed logit model was used, and the coefficients of the worst outcome 3 in the 5 dimensions were (from most important to least important): pain/discomfort:-0.463, anxiety/depression:-0.380, usual-activities:-0.322, mobility:-0.305, self-care:-0.221. Note that 1-0.463-0.380-0.322-0.305-0.221 = -0.691, which is indeed the anchor value of the 33333 state.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1357331601 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.